astro_toby
Cancelled
- Joined
- Sep 30, 2004
- Posts
- 5,455
- Reaction score
- 1,339
- AFL Club
- Richmond
have you guys delisted anybody this season?
-
Guest - BigFooty Tipping 2026 - Get on! - $500 first prize - Weekly Prizes - Click to Join
PLUS Your club board comp is now up!
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Opening Round
The Golden Ticket - Official AFL on-seller of MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Delistings?
- Thread starter astro_toby
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
not yetastro_toby said:
Kildonan
Premium Platinum
Aussie Jones Retired
Rookie listed player Luke Mullins has also retired/resigned
The club has not yet posted any delistings and has until 2pm Monday to do so.
Rookie listed player Luke Mullins has also retired/resigned
The club has not yet posted any delistings and has until 2pm Monday to do so.
I'm sure it wont be till monday and then papers will say how we are struggling with the salary cap and there will be all these rumours etc etc.StKildonan said:
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Kildonan
Premium Platinum
Our Player List:
That is 38 Senior listed players and 1 Rookie
I believe we have to trim our list to 35 Senior listed players and I think McDonnell has another year on his Rookie contract.
Can anyone confirm these details ?
Code:
Name - Games Age Date of Birth Height Weight
Harvey, Robert (V+) 317 34 21-Aug-71 181cm 84kg
Peckett, Justin (V+) 235 33 5-Oct-72 182cm 84kg
Thompson, Andrew 194 33 21-Oct-72 180cm 81kg
Gehrig, Fraser - 213 29 3-Mar-76 195cm 104kg
Hudghton, Max - 173 29 2-Sep-76 191cm 92kg
Powell, Stephen - 132 29 7-Sep-76 181cm 84kg
[COLOR=Red]Jones, Austinn - 226 29 28-Sep-76 176cm 82kg[/COLOR]
Hamill, Aaron - 181 28 20-Aug-77 184cm 94kg
Voss, Brett - 136 27 22-Feb-78 181cm 84kg
Hayes, Lenny - 140 25 14-Jan-80 186cm 85kg
Milne, Stephen - 97 25 8-Mar-80 176cm 80kg
Baker, Steven - 114 25 22-May-80 179cm 83kg
Penny, Luke - 80 24 8-Feb-81 193cm 94kg
Blake, Jason - 74 24 15-Mar-81 189cm 87kg
Fiora, Aaron - 91 24 19-Apr-81 186cm 80kg
Stone, Nick - 20 24 1-Oct-81 196cm 97kg
Schwarze, Troy - 60 23 23-Dec-81 190cm 89kg
Ackland, Cain - 34 23 16-Mar-82 196cm 96kg
Murray, Allan - 12 23 20-May-82 180cm 83kg
Guerra, Brent - 96 23 29-May-82 181cm 97kg
Fisher, Sam - 28 23 10-Jul-82 191cm 88kg
Koschitzke, Justin 71 23 20-Sep-82 197cm 96kg
Riewoldt, Nick - 91 23 17-Oct-82 193cm 95kg
Clarke, Xavier - 66 22 28-Sep-83 181cm 80kg
Montagna, Leigh - 30 21 2-Nov-83 178cm 76kg
Brooks, Barry - 7 21 24-Dec-83 198cm 95kg
Dal Santo, Nick - 75 21 22-Feb-84 185cm 83kg
Fisher, Leigh - 10 21 19-Apr-84 184cm 90kg
Gram, Jason - 9 21 27-Apr-84 186cm 84kg
Ball, Luke - 65 21 25-May-84 183cm 84kg
Maguire, Matthew 67 21 30-May-84 190cm 96kg
McGough, Mark - 46 21 22-Jun-84 188cm 88kg
Ferguson, Matthew 8 21 1-Oct-84 187cm 87kg
[COLOR=Red]Mullins, Luke (R) 3 20 24-Dec-84 187cm 82kg[/COLOR]
Goddard, Brendon 61 20 20-May-85 189cm 96kg
Pfitzner, Dylan - 0 20 13-Apr-85 196cm 82kg
Watts, Fergus - 5 20 21-Sep-85 195cm 95kg
Clarke, Raphael - 17 20 24-Sep-85 188cm 82kg
McQualter, Andrew 7 19 9-Jun-86 179cm 79kg
Gwilt, James - 3 19 11-Aug-86 188cm 88kg
McDonnell, Edward (R) 0 18 30-Dec-86 192cm 87kgThat is 38 Senior listed players and 1 Rookie
I believe we have to trim our list to 35 Senior listed players and I think McDonnell has another year on his Rookie contract.
Can anyone confirm these details ?
- Joined
- Jun 23, 2004
- Posts
- 13,497
- Reaction score
- 39
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Yes, the list must be narrowed down to 35 - Ed McDonnell does have another year to run.
Alan Murray and Barry Brooks will surely depart?
Alan Murray and Barry Brooks will surely depart?
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2000
- Posts
- 60,171
- Reaction score
- 161,434
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Snickers said:
So with Brookes and Stone gone our tallest player will be Kosi
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2000
- Posts
- 60,171
- Reaction score
- 161,434
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
deleted
Brooks will stay.
Murray, Stone, jones gone
Guerra, Schwarze, McGough, pfitzner (the last out of those 4)
Thomo, peckett and powell will still be there.
Murray, Stone, jones gone
Guerra, Schwarze, McGough, pfitzner (the last out of those 4)
Thomo, peckett and powell will still be there.
- Joined
- Jun 23, 2004
- Posts
- 13,497
- Reaction score
- 39
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Snickers said:
I think he has done a great job to hang around in AFL circles in recent years - Collingwood in 2000, Hawks 02-03, and Saints 04-05. Fair effort. Well done to him.
Thommo has signed for another year.
Kildonan
Premium Platinum
Kildonan
Premium Platinum
Our Updated Player List:
Red = Delisted / Retired
Red = Delisted / Retired
Code:
Name - Games Age Date of Birth Height Weight
Harvey, Robert (V+) 317 34 21-Aug-71 181cm 84kg
Peckett, Justin (V+) 235 33 5-Oct-72 182cm 84kg
Thompson, Andrew 194 33 21-Oct-72 180cm 81kg
Gehrig, Fraser - 213 29 3-Mar-76 195cm 104kg
Hudghton, Max - 173 29 2-Sep-76 191cm 92kg
Powell, Stephen - 132 29 7-Sep-76 181cm 84kg
[COLOR=Red]Jones, Austinn - 226 29 28-Sep-76 176cm 82kg[/COLOR]
Hamill, Aaron - 181 28 20-Aug-77 184cm 94kg
Voss, Brett - 136 27 22-Feb-78 181cm 84kg
Hayes, Lenny - 140 25 14-Jan-80 186cm 85kg
Milne, Stephen - 97 25 8-Mar-80 176cm 80kg
Baker, Steven - 114 25 22-May-80 179cm 83kg
Penny, Luke - 80 24 8-Feb-81 193cm 94kg
Blake, Jason - 74 24 15-Mar-81 189cm 87kg
Fiora, Aaron - 91 24 19-Apr-81 186cm 80kg
[COLOR=Red]Stone, Nick - 20 24 1-Oct-81 196cm 97kg[/COLOR]
Schwarze, Troy - 60 23 23-Dec-81 190cm 89kg
Ackland, Cain - 34 23 16-Mar-82 196cm 96kg
Murray, Allan - 12 23 20-May-82 180cm 83kg
[COLOR=Red]Guerra, Brent - 96 23 29-May-82 181cm 97kg[/COLOR]
Fisher, Sam - 28 23 10-Jul-82 191cm 88kg
Koschitzke, Justin 71 23 20-Sep-82 197cm 96kg
Riewoldt, Nick - 91 23 17-Oct-82 193cm 95kg
Clarke, Xavier - 66 22 28-Sep-83 181cm 80kg
Montagna, Leigh - 30 21 2-Nov-83 178cm 76kg
Brooks, Barry - 7 21 24-Dec-83 198cm 95kg
Dal Santo, Nick - 75 21 22-Feb-84 185cm 83kg
Fisher, Leigh - 10 21 19-Apr-84 184cm 90kg
Gram, Jason - 9 21 27-Apr-84 186cm 84kg
Ball, Luke - 65 21 25-May-84 183cm 84kg
Maguire, Matthew 67 21 30-May-84 190cm 96kg
McGough, Mark - 46 21 22-Jun-84 188cm 88kg
Ferguson, Matthew 8 21 1-Oct-84 187cm 87kg
[COLOR=Red]Mullins, Luke (R) 3 20 24-Dec-84 187cm 82kg[/COLOR]
Goddard, Brendon 61 20 20-May-85 189cm 96kg
Pfitzner, Dylan [COLOR=Red](R)[/COLOR]- 0 20 13-Apr-85 196cm 82kg
Watts, Fergus - 5 20 21-Sep-85 195cm 95kg
Clarke, Raphael - 17 20 24-Sep-85 188cm 82kg
McQualter, Andrew 7 19 9-Jun-86 179cm 79kg
Gwilt, James - 3 19 11-Aug-86 188cm 88kg
McDonnell, Edward (R) 0 18 30-Dec-86 192cm 87kgKildonan
Premium Platinum
It looks as if the St Kilda football club are trying to keep their list together as much as possible. Aussie retiring aside, the delisting of Guerra is the most significant decision. I believe that his off-field lifestyle had as much to do with the decision as his less impressive form in 2005. Nevertheless, Guerra lent a degree of hardness to the team which (together with Hamill and Hayes) made St Kilda feared by opposition teams. Nick Stone has now been delisted by three clubs. He featured regularly in the Springvale best, yet did not make it in the AFL. He was well liked by his team mates and will probably go on to have a decent VFL career. Dylan Pfitzner was taken as a skinny tall with obvious potential. He was promoted to the senior list last year and played Springvale reserves for most of the season. He won the B&F for them in 2005. St Kilda seems to have decided that he hasn't come on as fast as they would have liked, (despite injury severely hampering his development) and yet they decided to use a Rookie spot to hang on to him for another season.
I suspect that they will promote him again next year.
I suspect that they will promote him again next year.
StKildonan said:
That much is evident, and I'm not saying that it's the wrong thing to do because obviously replacing a lot of players isn't possible this year. The Swans will be able to replace eight this year - but having three talls promoted off the rookie list was what made it possible.
Yet at the same time, it looks likely that the Saints are headed for a boom or bust 2006, with a clean-out at the end either way. Harvey, Peckett, Thompson will retire. Gehrig will probably join them, and Powell could be washed up in another year as well. Added to that, Murray, McGough, Brooks and Schwarze don't really cut it. Altogether, that translates into a) a lot of departures without easy replacement or b) holding on to the dead wood for two, rather than one, years more than you should. It's going to be a difficult one to handle.
I'd be interested in your thoughts - can the Saints stay in the top four once the veterans clear out at the end of next year? Or is 2006 the last role of the dice for the next three or so years? Do you guys agree with the decision to hold the list steady, with that many senior players approaching or past 30?
CharlieG said:Murray, Brooks, Schwarze and McGough would have to be pretty lucky, wouldn't they?
edit: sorry to be a parrot. Hadn't scrolled up beyond the list.
I think the club think the draft will be better next year, but add Harvey Gherig Frankie Powell and Thomo, and we will turn over quite a few players next year
Gwilt mcQualter etc need another year before they can replace the midfield veterans, with Ball Dal Hayes still their it should be OK. We should be able to replace Gherig with Watts/Kosi or Phitzer. WOuld like to see a ruckman thoughCharlieG said: