Derek Hine, The List Manager

[Mick39]

To start the ball rolling, let's clarify some things.

Hine took over as List Manager at the end of 2013, Geoff Walsh walked out during the middle part of that year, shortly after the Harry O'Brien drama.

Don't believe Derek is a bad recruiter. He is a very good recruiter of U18 kids, that is a difference to bringing traded players in.

Hine has brought in these recycled players. White, Tony Armstrong, Clinton Young, Taylor Adams, Varcoe & Crisp. I'd put his strike rate at 50/50.

A lot of criticism gets thrown towards Buckley but our list management under Hine has been questionable.

 

[sirlothie]

Mick39, the Muckraker

 

[Kappa]

To start the ball rolling, let's clarify some things.

Hine took over as List Manager at the end of 2013, Geoff Walsh walked out during the middle part of that year, shortly after the Harry O'Brien drama.

Don't believe Derek is a bad recruiter. He is a very good recruiter of U18 kids, that is a difference to bringing traded players in.

Hine has brought in these recycled players. White, Tony Armstrong, Clinton Young, Taylor Adams, Varcoe & Crisp. I'd put his strike rate at 50/50.

A lot of criticism gets thrown towards Buckley but our list management under Hine has been questionable.

Young is the only big failure in that group, Armstrong and White were brought in for next to nothing and White at least has performed how most level headed people expected him to.

Adams Varcoe and Crisp have all been good additions.

 

[Mick39]

Young is the only big failure in that group, Armstrong and White were brought in for next to nothing and White at least has performed how most level headed people expected him to.

Adams Varcoe and Crisp have all been good additions.

Our trade with White directly netted WC Elliot Yeo & Dom Sheed.

 

[Didak_attack]

Young was brought in for the 2013 season. So that was Walsh wasn't it?

Reads a lot better that way Armstrong and Crisp cost nothing, Varcoe somewhat cheap considering circumstances, Adams is proving his worth and yes at this stage White was expensive but was a need.

I would give Hine a good mark as list manager

 

[Kappa]

Our trade with White directly netted WC Elliot Yeo & Dom Sheed.

What was the trade exactly?

WCE would of gotten Elliot Yeo anyway after he nominated them

 

[Mick39]

What was the trade exactly?

WCE would of gotten Elliot Yeo anyway after he nominated them

Coll upgraded Pick 11 for 10. Freeman to Sheed.
Collingwood gave WC the second round pick which netted Yeo.

 

[nahnah]

Coll upgraded Pick 11 for 10. Freeman to Sheed.
Collingwood gave WC the second round pick which netted Yeo.

11 to 6 do your homework kid

 

[Kappa]

Coll upgraded Pick 11 for 10. Freeman to Sheed.
Collingwood gave WC the second round pick which netted Yeo.

And where does White fit into that?

 

[Wayne Arnold]

Coll upgraded Pick 11 for 10. Freeman to Sheed.
Collingwood gave WC the second round pick which netted Yeo.

Collingwood upgraded pick 11 to pick 6 which was used on Scharenberg

 

[Subprime]

And where does White fit into that?

Think we got 6 & 44 for 11 & 27

Shaz & White

 

[Mick39]

WC gave us 44 & we traded that to Sydney for White.

 

[Kappa]

Think we got 6 & 44 for 11 & 27

Shaz & White

If Scharenberg lives up to his potential I don't think anyone will be complaining about that trade...

 

[Subprime]

If Scharenberg lives up to his potential I don't think anyone will be complaining about that trade...

Agree and he's (hopefully) helped to bring Aish our way.

Some will always complain though.

 

[MyManLynch]

Our trade with White directly netted WC Elliot Yeo & Dom Sheed.

That WC deal netted us Scharenberg...
Try again...

 

[MyManLynch]

Sniper at work...stand clear.

 

[Mick39]

That WC deal netted us Scharenberg...
Try again...

Pick 11 became Pick 6.
My apologies, it was Dom Sheed at 11 v Scharenberg at 6.

 

[sirlothie]

Rather Scharenberg

 

[Mudeo]

Didn't Sheed tank his interviews from clubs outside of WA?

Sent from my E2053 using Tapatalk

 

[Anzacday]

Dekka coming up on SEN apparently

 

[motr]

Excellent thread, Mick. Good idea to kick it off before Hinesight kicks in.

I'm backing Hine to give Buckley a premiership team within the next 3 seasons. I'll be keeping this thread on the front page till one of us concedes.

 

[Soaring Magpie]

Maybe mick39 should be the list manager/ coach/director of football and captain of the club, he can do a better job than all of them in their roles. So he believes anyway.

 

[Vicky Park]

To start the ball rolling, let's clarify some things.

Hine took over as List Manager at the end of 2013, Geoff Walsh walked out during the middle part of that year, shortly after the Harry O'Brien drama.

Don't believe Derek is a bad recruiter. He is a very good recruiter of U18 kids, that is a difference to bringing traded players in.

Hine has brought in these recycled players. White, Tony Armstrong, Clinton Young, Taylor Adams, Varcoe & Crisp. I'd put his strike rate at 50/50.

A lot of criticism gets thrown towards Buckley but our list management under Hine has been questionable.

So Hine has had two seasons as List Manager to impact on our list, 2014 and 2015? That is not long enough to make an objective assessment.

 

[Markfs]

So Hine has had two seasons as List Manager to impact on our list, 2014 and 2015? That is not long enough to make an objective assessment.

objective? BF? que?

 

[Boris the Contradiction]

This thread....