Dick v Nahas

[Porkaspies09]

who do u guys reckon i reckon dick just

 

[cannons]

1 game doesn't make a player. Nahas, for now.

 

[hellfire]

1 game doesn't make a player. Nahas, for now.

Take your own advice, Nahas has done what exactly?

Dick was even better last week. [Probably BOG]

He was also fantastic against the Eagles, despite the statistics.

I'll take Dick. His crumbing is superb, his disposal is brilliant and he is a massive team man, always looks to give it off... yet he's kicked 8 in the last two weeks? He's a gem, Pie fans have been saying it since he was drafted!

 

[Rosella]

Nahas atm

 

[Jatz]

nahas

 

[smiddaz123]

1 game doesn't make a player. Nahas, for now.

So Nahas has had a long career of consistent games I guess.

 

[Redbear90]

Nahas for me , Dick looks good but to... hard to split

 

[Spluff]

Nahas.

 

[Themi#9]

Nahas!! GUN

 

[jonesy86]

Dick is younger and so far his best has been better than Nahas' best.

 

[Trav 20]

Nahas is too tiny and isn't being paid much respect by the opposition. He may eke out a career, but I'd be surprised.

 

[Themi#9]

Collingwood loving dick, no surprise there

 

[DerpWerls]

Nahas is too tiny and isn't being paid much respect by the opposition. He may eek out a career, but I'd be surprised.

According to footywire he is 4cm taller than Brent Harvey but 9 kgs lighter. He could probably gain 6-7 kilos without it having a negative impact on his game.

 

[Spluff]

Dick is younger and so far his best has been better than Nahas' best.

Let's see - 5 goals in an absolute mauling of the worst team in the competition, or 5 goals against a top 4 side in a game the team lost - I wonder which player performed better.

 

[jonesy86]

Let's see - 5 goals in an absolute mauling of the worst team in the competition, or 5 goals against a top 4 side in a game the team lost - I wonder which player performed better.

I was actually talking about the previous week when the game was in the balance against Port Adelaide, he sparked the side with 25 disposals and 3 goals. But that 5 goal and 3 goal assist performance against Melbourne was quite good too.

 

[Ron]

Nahas will be the new Martin McGrath.

 

[CUBS]

I could've got off the couch and kicked as many goals as Dick did against that Dees side that showed up last week.

Vote 1 Nahas

 

[smiddaz123]

I could've stayed on the couch and kicked as many goals as Nahas did this week. Mainly because he didn't kick any.

Vote 1 Dick.

 

[Xx_Toomey_xX]

Nahas, DIck has played one good game and thew rest hes played have been ......... preety poor. Nahas looks like a gun!

 

[Agetigers]

Dicks a good player, but there different players. Nahas runs and runs and chases bokes down, Dick is crafty and clean (much like leon) if he could add running players down hed be a GUN!!. Nahas is the opposite i want to see him kick a special goal or crum a pack perfectly( he has done it just not consistantly).

Dick ATM

 

[smiddaz123]

Nahas, DIck has played one good game and thew rest hes played have been ......... preety poor. Nahas looks like a gun!

Which was the poor game, 25 touches and 3 goals, or 16 touches and 5 goals?