Think Tank Did Jobe give his medal back ?

[Xtreme]

Bigfooty presents
a Bay 13 Production

What really happened to Jobe's Brownlow medal ?

 

[Danger2Jenkins]

He said he wouldn't give it back but then Trent Cotchin said he'd take it. Brendan Gale got on the phone, it was reawarded days later and the rest is history

 

[HairyO]

Gil claimed it was in his desk, but couldnt remember where he left it

 

[Danger2Jenkins]

How can they even give Cotchin/Mitchell the medal with 30 votes missing. The missing votes would've been awarded to other players and changed the entire outcome.

And since the votes need to be made after every game, they couldn't simply reaward the votes once they pillaged Jobe of the medal. The brownlow that year needed to be crossed out not rewarded.

 

[Mitchell Madness]

How can they even give Cotchin/Mitchell the medal with 30 votes missing. The missing votes would've been awarded to other players and changed the entire outcome.

And since the votes need to be made after every game, they couldn't simply reaward the votes once they pillaged Jobe of the medal. The brownlow that year needed to be crossed out not rewarded.

No different to a player getting suspended in rd 22, and the vote showing had have been miles in front

 

[jsdsgn]

i remember there were about 6 blokes within 2 votes of mitchell/cotchin that year so the AFL is lucky they didnt have to award it to more blokes

 

[Hawk Dork]

Its rarer than a 1930s Penny
His grandkids will find it and become Billionaires in a few decades time

 

[Craze]

How can they even give Cotchin/Mitchell the medal with 30 votes missing. The missing votes would've been awarded to other players and changed the entire outcome.

And since the votes need to be made after every game, they couldn't simply reaward the votes once they pillaged Jobe of the medal. The brownlow that year needed to be crossed out not rewarded.

Nice melt. I'll add this to the 'Things that Geelong supporters sook about' thread.

 

[leobarryustar]

Interestingly Jab got one brownlow point from a Richmond game where Cockskin 29&3ed for no points

 

[RAPPA]

He sold it for a manual coffee machine so he could practice his skills as a barista

 

[Upgrayedd]

How can they even give Cotchin/Mitchell the medal with 30 votes missing. The missing votes would've been awarded to other players and changed the entire outcome.

And since the votes need to be made after every game, they couldn't simply reaward the votes once they pillaged Jobe of the medal. The brownlow that year needed to be crossed out not rewarded.

If you get suspended during the season do you have all your points deducted?


*Edit* oh didnt realise this way the bay, Tom Hawkins is also fat.

 

[HairyO]

Thread needs to be bigger so all the talentless flog reporters jump on board and run with the story.

Hi Damien.

 

[brett15]

Nice melt. I'll add this to the 'Things that Geelong supporters sook about' thread.

just proof Geelong endorse cheating when they'd prefer to see an Essendon player win anything

 

[Wojcinski]

just proof Geelong endorse cheating when they'd prefer to see an Essendon player win anything

I mean the 2012 Brownlow is pretty hollow. No one really thinks Cockchin or Bitchell are actual Brownlow medalists.

 

[TazHawk15]

I mean the 2012 Brownlow is pretty hollow. No one really thinks Cockchin or Bitchell are actual Brownlow medalists.

Same as no one thinks Jimmy Bartel is one.

 

[HairyO]

I mean the 2012 Brownlow is pretty hollow. No one really thinks Cockchin or Bitchell are actual Brownlow medalists.

More would recognise them as the legitimate winners than would recognise the Danked Cat flags.

 

[Wojcinski]

Same as no one thinks Jimmy Bartel is one.

Sure they do.



Where are the pics of Cockchin and Bitchell being presented their medals on Brownlow night?

 

[Craze]

I mean the 2012 Brownlow is pretty hollow. No one really thinks Cockchin or Bitchell are actual Brownlow medalists.

Hawthorn’s 3-peat hurt you. Richmond flags have finished the job. You’re just an angry shell of a human being.

 

[brett15]

I mean the 2012 Brownlow is pretty hollow. No one really thinks Cockchin or Bitchell are actual Brownlow medalists.

hahaha Geelong supporters say the darnedest things

In your mind Geelong won the 2008 flag as well

 

[HirdsTheWord]

hahaha Geelong supporters say the darnedest things

In your mind Geelong won the 2008 flag as well

He’s right you know....

2012 is just a void year.