Didak Injured

[HBF]

Guys and Gals, it's being reported on the main board that Didak has injured his knee and may require a knee reconstruction thus ruling him out of the 2007 season. I didn't hear it, but apparently Clinton Grybas reported it on 3AW.

This is not a troll, just reporting what's on the main board.

 

[sharpy36]

Thats bad luck isnt it

I think its BS because has he even been training

 

[Murray]

Not true.
He went in for a kneee scrape and they discovered some more damaged tissue.
He may need another minor operation or perhaps no operation at all.

 

[Dazman]

Guys and Gals, it's being reported on the main board that Didak has injured his knee and may require a knee reconstruction thus ruling him out of the 2007 season. I didn't hear it, but apparently Clinton Grybas reported it on 3AW.

This is not a troll, just reporting what's on the main board.

Good work idiot. If thats just 'reporting' I'd hate to see what you're like when you are making up stories.

 

[WakeUpPies]

Guys and Gals, it's being reported on the main board that Didak has injured his knee and may require a knee reconstruction thus ruling him out of the 2007 season. I didn't hear it, but apparently Clinton Grybas reported it on 3AW.

This is not a troll, just reporting what's on the main board.

yes, he need a knee reco yet he played like 8 or so matches after he got injured

 

[magpies42]

yes, he need a knee reco yet he played like 8 or so matches after he got injured

it is possible. you dont need a do completly rupture ur acl to have a reco! they could just be playing it safe, because they dont want it to rupture when we are competing for a premiership in a few years time!
its hard to tell i guess because the spin doctors down at collingwood are so good!
My tip is that he may need a minor tweak but he should be ok, i hope!

p.s it could also be a ploy so that he doesnt have to play in the international rules Sh_itries

 

[Jabso]

He injured it pretty early in the season and I don't think he would be playing with his knee too severly injured. Surely it would of caved in after a few rounds?

 

[PieLebo87]

He went in for minor, but they found a slight tear, he may choose a reco or play restricted next year. Better for his future that he has full reco to repair tear. And once and for all, this isnt BS, everyone in Collingwood board has to realise Dids has a knee injury that could mean he is out for 2007.

 

[UpTheGuts]

Peter Brukner on ABC said (at 5.55pm today) that it's like the Hayes one where he didn't even know it was torn. Most likely sustained in R22. Brukner expects him to elect to have a full knee reco...

Now that really is "reporting" Dazman.... don't shoot the messenger!

 

[PieLebo87]

Peter Brukner on ABC said (at 5.55pm today) that it's like the Hayes one where he didn't even know it was torn. Most likely sustained in R22. Brukner expects him to elect to have a full knee reco...

Now that really is "reporting" Dazman.... don't shoot the messenger!

No, it was the initial Freo game when he first hurt his knee. He still played well, but there was a slight obviousness that he wasnt 100%. He'd been carrying a knee since then. News today justified my suspicion, and I didnt want it to

 

[magpies42]

i knew there was something wrong when he went up for that marking contest and hyper extended his knee. The contact was not that severe, and it all pointed to the fact that there was something wrong before hand. (cant remember which game it was but i remember posting something to this point after the game!)

 

[Harmer]

So is he definitely gone?

 

[PieLebo87]

So is he definitely gone?

He can still play through next year, but there has to be a decision made as to whether it is better that he just has a full knee reco now and sit next year out. That hasnt been decided yet.

 

[FieryNayta]

Good work idiot. If thats just 'reporting' I'd hate to see what you're like when you are making up stories.

Now that there seems to be some truth to this rumour, do YOU feel like an idiot? You should, as HBF came to your board to make an honest comment for disusion and you over-reacted like a petulent child. Just shows your ignorance and inability to have legitimate opinion to share with others. Goodluck in life, your gonna need it.

 

[MarkT]

If this is all true I hope he has the reco. There is no point limping through the season and then needing the operation and missing 2008. The way things are going, it is almost at the point where we should write his season off trade a few, retire a few and use the 2006 and 2007 draft. Minus Didak I can’t see us being top 4 in 2007. It would seem pointless squeezing another year out of Burns and Wakelin and continuing with players like Lockyer and co who probably won’t be part of the next onslaught.

 

[toorakbum]

If this is all true I hope he has the reco. There is no point limping through the season and then needing the operation and missing 2008. The way things are going, it is almost at the point where we should write his season off trade a few, retire a few and use the 2006 and 2007 draft. Minus Didak I can’t see us being top 4 in 2007. It would seem pointless squeezing another year out of Burns and Wakelin and continuing with players like Lockyer and co who probably won’t be part of the next onslaught.

Pretty much how I feel. We need a complete overhaul of the midfield and that's not something that happens overnight.