Didak

[Punchy Bassett]

Collingwood people? Lets see Meeson/Wood/Fevola/Waters/Jolly.
All people overrate their players. We and you are no different son!

Difference is, it is the teams FANS that do this, when it comes to the Pies it is your OFFICALS who do the trading that are deluded.

 

[crowsarethebest]

What has Didak exactly done this year, apart from hanging out with a murderer? He's got off-field issues and is coming off a reco which has made him lose a yard of pace. He was an AA this year but the knee-reco has really made him struggle. You just aren't the same after a knee reco. I want him but I wouldn't make him a priority.

 

[understudy]

I assume the smiley because you are ****ing kidding right?

The smile is because I dont think you are going to get anywhere near him.

 

[CrowMagnum]

What has Didak exactly done this year, apart from hanging out with a murderer? He's got off-field issues and is coming off a reco which has made him lose a yard of pace. He was an AA this year but the knee-reco has really made him struggle. You just aren't the same after a knee reco. I want him but I wouldn't make him a priority.

Hang on there he did kick the Point of the Year

 

[bus24]

Lets hang our 2nd best player for the year shall we?

Until late this year he was an absolute shoe in for the B&F and everyone was singing his praises and well and truly on the Scotty Dog Thompson bandwagon.

This bloke is one of our few hard nuts in the middle, capable of winning the hard ball + clearances + first possesions. Leads our tackles by 7 over Edwards and by 20 over 3rd placed Robert Shirley.

So in a year we're we've been pathetic out of the middle, we're jumping at the chance to punt our toughest and best midfielder by far this year.

Some of the crap I've seen posted about Thomo over the last few days has been ABSOLUTELY RIDICULOUS !!!

Even taking into account his clangers Saturday, he was still easily one of our best.

He'll probably come 2nd in the B&F (a strong chance of winning), and deservedly so.

If people need to feel the need to bag someone, how about not having potshots at our best/2nd best player for the year?

 

[mymansyd]

Lets hang our 2nd best player for the year shall we?

Until late this year he was an absolute shoe in for the B&F and everyone was singing his praises and well and truly on the Scotty Dog Thompson bandwagon.

This bloke is one of our few hard nuts in the middle, capable of winning the hard ball + clearances + first possesions. Leads our tackles by 7 over Edwards and by 20 over 3rd placed Robert Shirley.

So in a year we're we've been pathetic out of the middle, we're jumping at the chance to punt our toughest and best midfielder by far this year.

Some of the crap I've seen posted about Thomo over the last few days has been ABSOLUTELY RIDICULOUS !!!

Even taking into account his clangers Saturday, he was still easily one of our best.

He'll probably come 2nd in the B&F (a strong chance of winning), and deservedly so.

If people need to feel the need to bag someone, how about not having potshots at our best/2nd best player for the year?

Here, here, couldn't have put it better myself. So, yes he makes some mistakes, but hey, his good stuff well and truly outweighs his bad stuff. I don't see anyone crucifying Andy McLeod for his crap game on Saturday. It seems that some players are above criticism?

I hope he wins the B&F.

 

[macca23]

The smile is because I dont think you are going to get anywhere near him.

My smile is because I don't want him.

 

[BEEG]

Not for mine.

Collingwood are notoriously devious demanding traders. They would want far in excess of his true value.

We're not going to win a flag next year, so let's not try topping up. Let's build from the bottom up.

ummmmmm how did the Tarrant deal go
just because we wouldnt swap Didak for Stevens all those years ago (which i think was the right move) doesnt mean we are demanding traders

 

[understudy]

My smile is because I don't want him.

Suits me fine.

 

[BEEG]

I honestly dont think Collingwood will give up our last Copeland winner and AA for 1st pick mattner and meeson i really think you will have to throw in 1 of Reilly or Knights and your 1st Rounder but i really wouldnt want 1 of those 2 you would have to get a 3 way deal happening with another club for it to happen Wood seems the gettable TARGET

 

[dylan101]

i wouldn't mind him but i don't want thompson or reilly to go, I'd probably give up knights to get him

 

[The Royal Sampler]

The Pies are notorious for being the worst club to trade with, as they think that all their players are worthy of the No.1 draft pick. Just ask Port about their attempts to trade with the Pies....

What, so you believe everything the Port Adelaide Power tells you now?

We've never had any problems dealing with your club before that I'm aware of.

In a weak draft, we'd probably want your 1st rounder, Meesen, and another player who would make our best 22 long-term. I don't want any more of this Medhurst shit.

Having said that, my preference would be to keep him.

 

[bus24]

Thompson to Collingwood, Didak to Adelaide. We get the better end of that deal. Thompson is a possession collector who doesn't hurt the opposition, Didak is a match winner who produces his best when the game is up for grabs. No-brainer and an ideal trade if that's what Collingwood is after.

You're having a laugh 88.

 

[BEEG]

Would you take Scott Thompson?

Would it be a straight swap and how old is he
i like thompson and rate him very high but his possesion is pour and he isnt really a ball winner but sayin all that collingwood love blokes with pour disposal

 

[MACDAICOS]

LOL......Idiots, don't know why your talking about trades for it's not going to happen.

Spoke to Didak at my sons footy clinic last week, He isnt going anywhere is still contracted to the club for 12 months and will re-sign a.s.a.p.

*People used to think the world was flat too.

 

[BEEG]

LOL......Idiots, don't know why your talking about trades for it's nor going to happen.

Spoke to Didak at my sons footy clinic last week, He isnt going anywhere is still contracted to the club for 12 months and will re-sign a.s.a.p.

*People used to think the world was flat too.

He isnt going to tell some stranger that his leaving at season end

 

[BEEG]

Thompson is 24, and yes a straight swap.

No you would have to throw in Meeson aswell but i still wouldnt want to deal id want your 1st round and a player but i think collingwood would look at thompson but he wont leave and like 1 of your fellow Adlaide supporters said he isnt that good

 

[BEEG]

Meh, if Collingwood agreed to the straight swap I would expect the AFC to take it instantly.

Would you say Thompson and 1st Round Pick
i see that being fair for both clubs your getting your 40 goals a year and 30assists and we are getting our 25 touches and a young kid

 

[bus24]

Would you say Thomson and 1st Round Pick
i see that being fair for both clubs your getting your 40 goals a year and 30assists and we are getting our 25 touches and a young kid

You've got to be ****ing joking

You're not in charge down at the Lexus are you, as it would explain the Nick Stevens situation.

Don't take any notice of FD88 saying that Thompson is no good. One of our most important players, especially when the experienced guys move on. He's seen very much as leadership material down the track.

Dreamer88 just wants a team full of flashy, outside players with pace. Doesn't take into account that guys are required to actually get the ****ing pill.

I can't believe people are even contemplating showing Thompson the door. It's a joke really. We have THE MOST fickle supporters around, or maybe it's just idiots like 88 that give that perception.

Trade our most important midfielder for a flashy HFF? Yeah....... ok

 

[crowman_23]

Would you say Thompson and 1st Round Pick
i see that being fair for both clubs your getting your 40 goals a year and 30assists and we are getting our 25 touches and a young kid

LMAO No thanks.

 

[macca23]

You've got to be ****ing joking

You're not in charge down at the Lexus are you, as it would explain the Nick Stevens situation.

Don't take any notice of FD88 saying that Thompson is no good. One of our most important players, especially when the experienced guys move on. He's seen very much as leadership material down the track.

Dreamer88 just wants a team full of flashy, outside players with pace. Doesn't take into account that guys are required to actually get the ****ing pill.

I can't believe people are even contemplating showing Thompson the door. It's a joke really. We have THE MOST fickle supporters around, or maybe it's just idiots like 88 that give that perception.

Trade our most important midfielder for a flashy HFF? Yeah....... ok

Actually bus, the whole thread is a farce.

Talk about trading Thompson, Knights and VB etc is garbage and won't happen.

Thank god some supporters don't run the AFC - we'd be rooted in no time.

 

[jonesy86]

trade would have to be pick #10 and a decent midfielder otherwise Collingwood would make him honour his contract...provided that these rumours are true

 

[Ferris_rules]

Just remember the AFC were able to trade Chris Groom for Andrew McLeod.


With that said I suggest:

Perrie for Didak.

Ok I am being stupid and delerious.

lol

 

[crowman_23]

Yeah because you and Bus know better right? Thompson is a dead-average player who can find the footy. His skills by hand and foot are poor. We have half a dozen kids on our list who we can break in with him out of the side, while Didak tears it up in the forward line and stints in the middle.

If a straight swap was on I would think about it. And even then would only be thinking. There is no way Collingwood would do a straight sway, and if it is so obvious Thompson is so 'average', which IMO he certainly isn't, then Collingwood are even less likely to take it.

We all know what Collingwoods trading history is like. It's hardly worth getting involved with them. Yes he would be a very handy trade if we were able to get him, but we are not going to get a trade with them that both parties will accept.

 

[BEEG]

Come on adelaide supporters we have sorted out your 1st round pick will be involved and a decent youngish Mid so come up with the Mid that you would give away????? you must really under estimate how good Didak is