MVP Didaka Final Results 2021!

[manicmagpie]

Round 1

5: Moore (130 votes)
4: Maynard (62)
3: Pendlebury (58)
2: Mihocek (37)
1: Cox (27)

Others:

Crisp 25
Noble 25
Quaynor 17
Howe 7
Elliott 1
De Goey 1


A rare unanimous sentiment from this board with Moore gathering every single voter's top spot in Round 1.


Round 2

5: Adams (130 votes)
4: Moore (109)
3: Crisp (77)
2: De Goey (47)
1: Pendlebury (41)

Others:

Grundy 7
Elliott 3
Noble 3
Sidebottom 2
Daicos 1


Also a lot of common ground in Round 2. Unusually for a win, almost every voter picked the same 5 players but in different orders. You more normally you see that with a bad loss with few players contributing.


Round 3

5: Grundy (104 votes)
4: Quaynor (71)
3: Roughead (61)
2: Pendlebury (42)
1: Howe (16)

Others:

Noble 10
Sier 6
Daicos 5

Grundy polled BOG from every poster except one (who chose Roughy).


LEADERBOARD:




Moore skips out to an early lead with the ever consistent captain in 2nd after polling in every game. No one else has polled twice yet.

 

[manicmagpie]

Round 4:

5: Madgen (57 votes)
4: Sidebottom (43)
3: Moore (39)
2: Crisp (32)
1: Daicos (22)

McCreery, WHE 10
Howe, Mihocek 5
Maynard 2

Hands up all those who thought Madgen would get a BOG this year?


Round 5:

5: Grundy (60 votes)
4: Mihocek (31)
3: Crisp (28)
2: Maynard (27)
1: Pendlebury (22)

McCreery 6
Moore 5
Sidebottom 1

A unanimous BOG for Grundy. McCreery a good effort to be in 6th spot in each of his first two onfield appearances.

LEADERBOARD

 

[jackcass]

Round 4:

5: Madgen (57 votes)
4: Sidebottom (43)
3: Moore (39)
2: Crisp (32)
1: Daicos (22)

McCreery, WHE 10
Howe, Mihocek 5
Maynard 2

Hands up all those who thought Madgen would get a BOG this year?


Round 5:

5: Grundy (60 votes)
4: Mihocek (31)
3: Crisp (28)
2: Maynard (27)
1: Pendlebury (22)

McCreery 6
Moore 5
Sidebottom 1

A unanimous BOG for Grundy. McCreery a good effort to be in 6th spot in each of his first two onfield appearances.

LEADERBOARD

View attachment 1108164

LOL, Madge BOG according to the masses, love it.

 

[manicmagpie]

Round 6 v Essendon

5: Crisp (82 votes)
4: Pendlebury (78)
3: Cameron (63)
2: Quaynor (28)
1: Grundy (28)

Daicos 23
Roughead 8
McCreery 3
Murphy, Thomas 1


Round 7 v GC

5: Mihocek (95 votes)
4: Daicos (70)
3: Pendlebury (44)
2: Noble (26)
1: (Grundy 19)

Murphy 13
Quaynor 10
McCreery 6
Poulter, Sidebottom 1


Round 8 v North

5: Moore (105 votes)
4: De Goey (91)
3: Crisp (65)
2: Maynard (51)
1: Noble (20)

Pendlebury 11
Grundy 8
Sidebottom 4
Mayne 2
Cameron, Quaynor, Daicos 1


LEADERBOARD after Round 8



Moore has 17 votes out of a possible 25 in games where he played down back, and 0 from 15 in games where he played up forward.

Crisp and Pendlebury as consistent as ever have polled in most weeks.

6 different BOGs and 17 different players polling votes from 8 games might normally indicate that the team has a nice even spread but this year it just looks like no top level players dominating.

 

[manicmagpie]

Round 9 v Sydney

5: Crisp (46 votes)
4: Hoskin-Elliott (44)
3: Maynard (34)
2: Mayne (21)
1: Daicos (14)

De Goey 6
Grundy 4
Sidey, Poulter, Noble 3
Moore, McCreery 1

A rare case of the player who got the most BOGs not ending up on top. WHE had 5 BOGs to Crisp's 3, but Crisp did get votes off everyone enabling him to take it out.

Round 10 v Port

5: Grundy (90 votes)
4: Crisp (81)
3: Roughead (74)
2: Adams (24)
1: Mayne (21)

Poulter 20
McCreery 12
Quaynor 9
Hoskin-Elliott, Moore 5
Daicos 3
Noble 1


LEADERBOARD:



Crisp's ultra consistent Collingwood career continues and he's now leaped ahead of the rest. He's polled in 7 of our 10 games.

Grundy scored his 3rd BOG against Port, the most for us so far.

 

[manicmagpie]

Round 11 v Geelong

5: De Goey (81 votes)
4: Mayne (66)
3: Crisp (62)
2: Cameron (36)
1: Quaynor (22)

Moore 16
Bianco 14
Maynard 12
Sier, Roughead 3


Round 12 v Adelaide

5: Elliott (124 votes)
4: Crisp (80)
3: Poulter (54)
2: Sidebottom (45)
1: Pendlebury (37)

Daicos 10
Bianco 9
Maynard 6
WHE, Roughead 5


LEADERBOARD:



Crisp keeps extending his lead and is way in front just after the half way point.

 

[Milo the border collie]

Crisp is currently our best player.

 

[manicmagpie]

Round 13 v Melbourne

5: Maynard (100 votes)
4: Pendlebury (95)
3: De Goey (87)
2: Cameron (35)
1: Quaynor (23)

Lynch 7
Moore 4
WHE, Crisp 3
Mayne 2
Noble 1


Round 15 v Freo

5: Maynard (77)
4: Grundy (53)
3: Hoskin-Elliott (38)
2: Pendlebury (27)
1: Adams (17)

Mayne 16
Crisp 13
Roughead 9
Sidebottom 8
Cameron, Quaynor 4
Bianco 2
Murphy, Thomas 1


Round 16 v St Kilda

5: De Goey (81)
4: Pendlebury (42)
3: Adams (35)
2: Quaynor (29)
1: Hoskin-Elliott (20)

Magden 14
Mayne 9
Elliott, Daicos 7
Crisp, Thomas 4
Noble, Grundy, Bianco 1


Round 17 v Richmond

5: Adams (79)
4: Crisp (67)
3: De Goey (50)
2: Maynard (42)
1: Pendlebury (38)

Grundy 31
WHE 13
Elliott 10

The most uniform votes I've seen in the Didaka. Only 8 players got votes and they all got at least 10.



LEADERBOARD



A great 4 games for Maynard (12 votes) and Pendlebury and De Goey (11 votes each) means that Crisp's lead doesn't seem insurmountable any more.

 

[manicmagpie]

Round 18 v C-----n

5: De Goey (94 votes)
4: Ruscoe (60)
3: Noble (38)
2: Mayne (34)
1: Henry (34) Mayne ahead of Henry on countback

Elliott 7
Mihocek 7
Maynard, Roughead, Grundy 2
Quaynor 1


Round 19 v Port

5: Crisp (71)
4: Madgen (43)
3: Grundy (41)
2: Mihocek (34)
1: Maynard (22)

Henry 15
Adams 8
De Goey 5
Roughead 1


Round 20 v WC

5: De Goey (91)
4: Crisp (72)
3: Sidebottom (51)
2: Grundy (40)
1: Maynard (36)

Adams 10
Ruscoe, Quaynor, Hoskin-Elliott 3
Roughead, Elliott 2
Mayne, Howe 1

LEADERBOARD:




Crisp has one hand on the Didaka trophy with De Goey needing near perfect scores in the last three weeks to get the victory. No one else can win from here but it's pretty tight for the minor placings.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

How has Elliott only polled five votes? Been a difference maker all season.

 

[Kirby]

JDG has flown home with a bullet

 

[manicmagpie]

Since there's no other Collingwood news to distract us at the moment let's finalise the Didaka.

Results for the last 3 games:

Round 21 v Haw:

5: De Goey (48 votes)
4: Crisp (41)
3: Maynard (28)
2: Grundy (28)
1: Macrae (7)

Howe, Elliott 5
Hoskin-Elliott 2
Madgen 1


Round 22 v Bris:

5: Crisp (66)
4: De Goey (59)
3: Elliott (29)
2: Mayne (11)
1: Ginnivan (11)

Sidebottom 7
Adams 6
Maynard 5
Hoskin-Elliott 3
Grundy 1


Round 23 v Ess:

5: Elliott (54)
4: De Goey (49)
3: Mayne (17)
2: Adams (15)
1: Crisp (11)

Daicos 11
Thomas, Howe, Madgen 7
Rantall 2

 

[manicmagpie]

Alright, the moment everyone* has been waiting for - the final placings for the Didaka Award 2021!

No expense has been spent on this glittering award ceremony.




Full list of results:



Some thoughts:

• De Goey stormed home with 5 BOGs, 2 2nds and 2 3rds in his last 11 games. This to me is the big story. If De Goey can make what he did in the second half of the year his new normal then he will become the genuine superstar he's always threatened to be.
• Crisp really is Mr Consistent
• 4 first year players ended up receiving votes
• Pendles still got votes in 10 of the 18 games he played, but didn't manage a single BOG.
• Moore was probably on track for a 3rd place finish given he missed half the year
• Grundy finished a lot higher up than you would guess if all you knew about him was what you read on this forum
• 25 different players received votes out of the 39 we used

 

[Maggie5]

Alright, the moment everyone* has been waiting for - the final placings for the Didaka Award 2021!

No expense has been spent on this glittering award ceremony.

View attachment 1221764


Full list of results:

View attachment 1221762

Some thoughts:

• De Goey stormed home with 5 BOGs, 2 2nds and 2 3rds in his last 11 games. This to me is the big story. If De Goey can make what he did in the second half of the year his new normal then he will become the genuine superstar he's always threatened to be.
• Crisp really is Mr Consistent
• 4 first year players ended up receiving votes
• Pendles still got votes in 10 of the 18 games he played, but didn't manage a single BOG.
• Moore was probably on track for a 3rd place finish given he missed half the year
• Grundy finished a lot higher up than you would guess if all you knew about him was what you read on this forum
• 25 different players received votes out of the 39 we used

Great job again, thank you.

 

[manicmagpie]

For those Didaka completists - here's the totals every player received in every game:

 

[rand corp]

Wonderful effort, thank you very much.

 

[manicmagpie]

Should add, as I neglected to do it earlier:

Congratulations Jack Crisp

25

Jack Crisp

Age

30

Ht

190cm

Wt

91kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

21.2

5star

K

11.5

4star

HB

9.7

5star

M

4.6

4star

T

4.0

5star

CL

2.2

4star

D

17.7

4star

K

10.7

4star

HB

7.0

4star

M

5.1

5star

T

1.6

3star

CL

1.0

3star

D

14.4

4star

K

8.4

4star

HB

6.0

4star

M

2.8

3star

T

3.0

5star

CL

1.4

4star

on a well deserved win!

Should be an unbackable favourite for the Copeland (whenever it's being held).

Ultra consistent throughout the year, stepped up to a midfield role, even added some strong overhead marking to his game by the end of the season. If only we had more players as durable and consistent as him.

 

[Leviathan Pie]

Should add, as I neglected to do it earlier:

Congratulations Jack Crisp on a well deserved win!

Should be an unbackable favourite for the Copeland (whenever it's being held).

Ultra consistent throughout the year, stepped up to a midfield role, even added some strong overhead marking to his game by the end of the season. If only we had more players as durable and consistent as him.

Great effort compiling as usual, MM.

Would dare say the board have got the top 3 (in order) pretty much spot-on come end of season, too.

 

[gouki88]

The picture of Shrek alongside Mayne's name is a hilarious send-off. Nice work MM, think the board got it right

 

[manicmagpie]

The picture of Shrek alongside Mayne's name is a hilarious send-off. Nice work MM, think the board got it right

I hope it wasn't too mean. But I must admit the link has popped into my mind on many occasions.

 

[Apples]

Thanks for another year's work MM.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

I hope it wasn't too mean. But I must admit the link has popped into my mind on many occasions.

Because he has a well-meaning heart and is an absolute beast on the footy field who will go above and beyond for a worthy cause, I’m sure.