MVP Didaka Medal ~ Round 11 v Dockers

[Saintly Viewed]

And after going down by four points, perhaps once your blood pressure has gone down it’s time to Vote.

5 for the best Magpie

then 4, 3, 2, 1

This is a VOTING THREAD not a melting thread.

Plenty of other threads to do your must.

Will any one possibly challenge Pendlebury for best Magpie ?

Over to you.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

5 Pendlebury
4 Mayne
3 Roughead
2 Grundy
1 Howe

 

[manicmagpie]

5: Pendles - head, shoulders, torso and everything else above every other player
4: Maynard - saved us on many occasions in defence and actually seemed like he knew how to kick the ball properly, unlike most of our side.
3: Mayne - also saved us many times and put in huge efforts
2: Roughead - actually defended, which is more than you can say for some others back there
1: De Goey - 3 goals enough to get him a vote because he wasn’t part of a midfield that was comprehensively beaten or a defence that wouldn’t pick up an opponent

 

[nahnah]

5. Pendles
4. Maynard
3. De Goey
2. Roughead
1. Howe

 

[FAIRANDBALANCED]

5. Pendles
4. Maynard
3. De Goey
2. Roughead
1. Howe

Yeah plus one for me, dead on.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

5. S Pendlebury (mammoth game, 8 tackles, because we lost will get 2 Brownlow votes should be 3)
4. B Maynard (clear second best for me; helped us big time)
3. J Howe (very solid, lots of superior air work, high level efficiency)
2. J Roughead (where would we be without him, so solid)
1. B Grundy (powers through, just does clearances himself too often, AA certainty)


small cheers to a few.
C Mayne (everything is for team so under rated); J De Goey (powers us).

 

[Maggie5]

5. Pendlebury
4. Maynard
3. Grundy
2. JDG
1. Crisp

 

[Tippy78]

5. Pendles
4. Maynard
3. Grundy (very hard to determine if his taps were good and our midfield failed or his taps were poor)
2. De Goey
1. Mayne

 

[Jabso]

5. Pendlebury
4. Roughead
3. Maynard
2. Howe
1. Grundy

Unlucky: Crisp.

 

[sr36]

5 Mayne
4 Pendlebury
3 Howe
2 Grundy
1 Degoey

 

[ottoman]

5. Pendles
4. Maynard
3. Mayne
2. JDG
1. Howe

 

[Quicky]

5 - Grundy
4 - Pendlebury
3 - Maynard
2 - De Goey
1 - Mayne

 

[grayza2018]

5 Scott Pendlebury
4 Brayden Maynard
3 Jordan de Goey
2 Brodie Grundy
1 Jeremy Howe

 

[Leviathan Pie]

5 - S.Pendlebury
4 - J.Roughead
3 - B.Grundy
2 - J.De Goey
1 - J.Howe

 

[jackcass]

5 Pendles
4 Roughy
3 Grundy
2 Mayne
1 Maynard

 

[adammania9]

5 Pendles - unbelievable as usual

4 Howe - sensational with 11 marks and 17 kicks at high efficiency. Can’t ask for too much more.

3 Roughead - much like Howe, saved us on a number of occasions in the back half. 10 marks, 94% efficiency

2 Greenwood - another good showing I thought. Used it well and was involved all day.

1 Grundy - can’t fault his effort. Had a good day, his assistants just failed to capitalise.

Thought Mayne and Maynard were good, Aish solid and De Goey with three goals was pivotal.

 

[lyfsux]

5 Pendlebury
4 Roughhead
3 Grundy
2 Mayne
1 Maynard

 

[The Royal Sampler]

5 Pendles
4 Howe
3 Maynard
2 Hoskin-Elliott
1 Roughead

 

[manicmagpie]

5 Pendles
4 Howe
3 Maynard
2 Hoskin-Elliott
1 Roughead

That's genuinely the first time anyone has given Hoskin-Elliott a vote all season.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

I struggled to find many winners on the day, if I’m being honest. WHE laid some great tackles, contested well in the air and drilled an important goal.

 

[Albert Parker]

5 Pendlebury
4 Mayne
3 Roughead
2 Grundy
1 DeGoey

 

[Apples]

5 Pendlebury
4 Maynard
3 Mayne
2 Roughead
1 Grundy

 

[rand corp]

5 Pendlebury
4 Grundy
3 DeGoey
2 Crisp
1 Howe

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Interim tally completed; will leave open for a bit more so rustle up.
Day till tomorrow or as the mood takes me.

Strict Policy: NO votes allowed for Carlton regardless of the pleasure you may feel.

 

[Pieku]

5 Pendlebury
4 Mayne
3 Howe
2 Maynard
1 Grundy