For me, I'd keep Peake (that is, if it was a choice between those two, but that seems a bit simplistic). But realistically the gap between them to me seems miniscule. Peake appears to have better goal sense but I had read reports which savaged his accuracy and decisionmaking. Kicking accuracy is the question mark for Browne.
I'd like to see a breakdown of the list into some different categories. Backs, mid and forwards of course. But also hieght and pace. It seems we have lacked a bit of hieght in the midfiled on occassions, esp with M Carr and Headland either being missing or at tomes (DH) missing in action. Those too add something to the flea brigade.
Also in the backline, which is impossible to really assess due to injuries this year, has lacked it's running rebound until Scahmmer went back.
Warren to me has value as an alternative/backup ruckman.
Harsh realities from my flawed and inexperienced point of view is Seigert, Woods and Gilmore look like they are behind the 8 ball. The heroic Macca may have run his race. And Dunn would be worth trading and worth keeping all at the same time.