Coaching Staff Discussion on coaching panel 2020 Who stays, who goes

[Angry Red Bull]

If this years draft is a taste of what we can expect from Dalrymple then I’m ecstatic. Really early days of course but our draft selections as a group are wonderful choices. I really hope that the chatter about Beatson leaving is off the mark because I think with both their skills that our recruitment will be in good hands.

 

[Kiama Chris]

If this years draft is a taste of what we can expect from Dalrymple then I’m ecstatic. Really early days of course but our draft selections as a group are wonderful choices. I really hope that the chatter about Beatson leaving is off the mark because I think with both their skills that our recruitment will be in good hands.

Yep. 2 new skilful mids coming for sure next year. Taking a good strategic approach. The trade ins are good gap fillers in the right age group. For sure not everyone will make best 22 but that's life. There'll be healthy competition for spots.

 

[Punts]

Probably should wait till they debut and make a consistent impact before the praise

 

[SwansProudly]

Kinnear Beatson re-signs with Swans

Report: Highly rated list manager re-signs with club, knocks back Carlton advance

He was strongly linked to the vacant position at Carlton.

www.sen.com.au

 

[Ticky009]

Kinnear Beatson re-signs with Swans

Report: Highly rated list manager re-signs with club, knocks back Carlton advance

He was strongly linked to the vacant position at Carlton.

www.sen.com.au

Well, puke will be happy!

Also shows there was some basis to the Carl rumour.

 

[Wolfgang West]

Probably should wait till they debut and make a consistent impact before the praise

I would have thought you would have known better than to come in here speaking sense Punts. Not the place for it.

 

[GotTheGoodes]

Kinnear Beatson re-signs with Swans

Report: Highly rated list manager re-signs with club, knocks back Carlton advance

He was strongly linked to the vacant position at Carlton.

www.sen.com.au

This I am very happy about.

Sorry swansfan51

 

[caesar88]

Beatson & Darymple have the potential to form a very good recruiting duo for us. They have great track records in different areas (Darymple with classy juniors, Beatson with diamonds in the rough)

Still too early to tell so far but it’s good that he’s sticking around. Only a fool would deny what an asset he’s been for us.

 

[Ticky009]

Recruiting team:
In case people missed it here's the latest list of our main recruiting team and their roles

Ross in the hot seat chatting all things recruiting

Sydney Swans Media sat down with Future Recruiting Coordinator Ross Monaghan to chat all things scouting, from the make-up of the club’s recruitment team to the depth of footy they consume to what they’re looking for in potential draftees or recruits and more.

www.sydneyswans.com.au

 

[BloodySwan]

Dean Solomon let go by the Suns. Was only second to Longmuire for the Freo role is my understanding. Our coaches could do with some experience

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

Doubt Stewie would be giving him a strong reference.

Pass.

 

[Kapers]

Stevie J looks like the likeliest to be cut from the coaching panel atm.
Is our forward line a mess because of Stevie J or because of our midfield?

I don't know what's best for our club moving forward, but I do think our next in line for coaching should 100% be from outside the club (although I wouldn't mind Cox being given more responsibility).

Wouldn't mind Kennealy back, but I have no clue how to judge each coach separate from the other.

 

[BloodySwan]

Stevie J looks like the likeliest to be cut from the coaching panel atm.
Is our forward line a mess because of Stevie J or because of our midfield?

I don't know what's best for our club moving forward, but I do think our next in line for coaching should 100% be from outside the club (although I wouldn't mind Cox being given more responsibility).

Wouldn't mind Kennealy back, but I have no clue how to judge each coach separate from the other.

I don't have any stats to back this but would have thought our scores per inside 50 to actually be pretty high. Last 2 weeks we've been getting inside 50 and not scoring but before that we seemed to be going pretty well in that department

 

[dazedjosh]

With the NEAFL merging with the VFL and the likelihood of smaller list sizes and thus smaller reserves, I'm guessing one or two of Kirk, Perris, or Laidler will be going. I'd tip Laidler to stay simply because he's doing the press for the 2's and seems to be more prominent in the team. I don't have any evidence beyond that to back up my suspicion.

I think Cox is staying, in fact I'm tipping him to replace Horse at the end of Horse's current contract.

I'm not sure about Stevie J, McVeigh, or Kennelly. I could see one of them going, but I have no idea who that might be.

 

[S120]

With the NEAFL merging with the VFL and the likelihood of smaller list sizes and thus smaller reserves, I'm guessing one or two of Kirk, Perris, or Laidler will be going. I'd tip Laidler to stay simply because he's doing the press for the 2's and seems to be more prominent in the team. I don't have any evidence beyond that to back up my suspicion.

I think Cox is staying, in fact I'm tipping him to replace Horse at the end of Horse's current contract.

I'm not sure about Stevie J, McVeigh, or Kennelly. I could see one of them going, but I have no idea who that might be.

Think I remember it being reported McVeigh signed a 4 year deal or something with the club as a coach. Can't imagine he'll be getting the chop.

EDIT: https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl...aims-for-one-last-hurrah-20190801-p52cs6.html

 

[The King!]

Blakey Going might help his son

 

[RobbieK]

Blakey Going might help his son

Or it might not.

 

[The King!]

Or it might not.

well true, but this whole thread is just guessing from the outside to be fair

 

[bedford]

Think I remember it being reported McVeigh signed a 4 year deal or something with the club as a coach. Can't imagine he'll be getting the chop.

EDIT: https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl...aims-for-one-last-hurrah-20190801-p52cs6.html

And what a joke that is . Never known any other way . He is the next coach

 

[Angry Red Bull]

And what a joke that is . Never known any other way . He is the next coach

You don’t like that he was contracted as a coach? He was virtually coaching the side as a player so is a natural progression. Personally I’m glad

 

[Tedeski]

Lol.
I'm loving Longmire coaching, Macca by his side, Harley & Gardiner watching on.

 

[The King!]

Lol.
I'm loving Longmire coaching, Macca by his side, Harley & Gardiner watching on.

Which part

 

[bedford]

You don’t like that he was contracted as a coach? He was virtually coaching the side as a player so is a natural progression. Personally I’m glad

It's been proved that the best way to learn as a coach is to go to another club and get fresh ideas , look at the stars that are failures . Tim Watson, Nathan Buckley, Michael Voss etc. All he has ever seen is Roos/Horse. Kevin Sheedy always freshened up and Hardwick improved by doing the same thing. He would have been good going to Geelong or Richmond eg. The club is there for the old boys. Pointing is not coaching.

 

[Tedeski]

Which part

All.
It will be fun reading until they're gone & the next lot become cannon fodder unless they win every week.

 

[Tedeski]

It's been proved that the best way to learn as a coach is to go to another club and get fresh ideas , look at the stars that are failures . Tim Watson, Nathan Buckley, Michael Voss etc. All he has ever seen is Roos/Horse. Kevin Sheedy always freshened up and Hardwick improved by doing the same thing. He would have been good going to Geelong or Richmond eg. The club is there for the old boys. Pointing is not coaching.

With all due respect Bedders, the only one saying that Macca will be the next coach is you.
It's highly likely he will move away as a next level assistant with another club rather than coach our club right after Horse, & I base this on the very points you raised in your post. I agree with you but not with the bit about Macca taking over from Horse.