Remove this Banner Ad

Division 4 2019 Thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
adock said:
Silvan do have an Under 19s side and they won today by 178 points against Ringwood...
Click to expand...

Dunno how I missed that.
Looking through the unders results from y/day (again) looks like a few sides might struggle in their divisions.
Hopefully the kids stick at it.
 
doggiesmrx said:
East Burwood
Forest Hill
Fairpark
Coldstream
——————-
Silvan
Surrey Park
Kilsyth
Nunawading
NC/Lilydale

EB to beat FH in the grand final.
Click to expand...
EFL Follower said:
Hi all, new to this but have followed EFL for years.

My ladder prediction for Div 4.

East Burwood
Fairpark
Forest Hill
Surrey Park
Coldstream
Silvan
Kilsyth
Nunawading
NC / Lilydale

Happy to debate.
Click to expand...


My ladder prediction for Div 4 2019.

East Burwood (Premiers)
Fairpark (Runners Up)
Coldstream
Silvan
Surrey Park
Forest Hill
Nunawading
Kilsyth
North Croydon-Mt Lilydale
 
LocalFootyStats said:
My ladder prediction for Div 4 2019.

East Burwood (Premiers)
Fairpark (Runners Up)
Coldstream
Silvan
Surrey Park
Forest Hill
Nunawading
Kilsyth
North Croydon-Mt Lilydale
Click to expand...

Did the EFL think that north Croydon would be a decent outfit?
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

No, they probably thought that they would struggle, but they want 10 teams in each division. My thoughts are they will continue to take in teams in 4th Divvy and eventually feed teams from there up to higher divisions until they reach 10 teams per Division.
 
Aeglos said:
Dunno how I missed that.
Looking through the unders results from y/day (again) looks like a few sides might struggle in their divisions.
Hopefully the kids stick at it.
Click to expand...
That's the worry, could be some byes as players depart.
 
You can't find out anything about transfers because the EFL Transfers page isn't working
 
CliffMcTainshaw said:
No, they probably thought that they would struggle, but they want 10 teams in each division. My thoughts are they will continue to take in teams in 4th Divvy and eventually feed teams from there up to higher divisions until they reach 10 teams per Division.
Click to expand...
North Croydon would initially be suited to division two YVMDFL or Outer East,
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Apologies to the EFL, I presumed they put East Burwood U19's into 2nd Division under their so called grading system. The Rams U19's coach requested/wanted them in there. They beat Mitcham comfortably yesterday in their first game.
 
eflreceiver said:
Apologies to the EFL, I presumed they put East Burwood U19's into 2nd Division under their so called grading system. The Rams U19's coach requested/wanted them in there. They beat Mitcham comfortably yesterday in their first game.
Click to expand...

Should it make a difference whether the club wanted to be moved there or the EFL made them move there? The end result is teams playing in their right grade.
 
adock said:
Should it make a difference whether the club wanted to be moved there or the EFL made them move there? The end result is teams playing in their right grade.
Click to expand...
The end result? lol. What we should have is all teams fielding a team in each division. What we have is U19's playing everywhere else but with their seniors. The calamity of following what the Ammo's do has clearly been detrimental to many clubs.
 
eflreceiver said:
The end result? lol. What we should have is all teams fielding a team in each division. What we have is U19's playing everywhere else but with their seniors. The calamity of following what the Ammo's do has clearly been detrimental to many clubs.
Click to expand...

At least 50% of games would be with the seniors.We do not want one sided U19 games or like last year in D1 where the battling sides forfeited when they played the strong Vermont,Doncaster, Norwood sides
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

eflreceiver said:
The end result? lol. What we should have is all teams fielding a team in each division. What we have is U19's playing everywhere else but with their seniors. The calamity of following what the Ammo's do has clearly been detrimental to many clubs.
Click to expand...

What we need is Under 19s teams playing against similar teams. It makes no sense to have a 17s A grade or Premier side in 2018 essentially playing Under 19s in 2019 against a 17s D grade side from 2018. No players will develop from 200 point wins or losses. It looks like the East Burwood 19s coach has worked out what is best for the team anyway.
 
adock said:
What we need is Under 19s teams playing against similar teams. It makes no sense to have a 17s A grade or Premier side in 2018 essentially playing Under 19s in 2019 against a 17s D grade side from 2018. No players will develop from 200 point wins or losses. It looks like the East Burwood 19s coach has worked out what is best for the team anyway.
Click to expand...
Amazingly the EFL have advised U19 teams not to win by so much. May have to make it like Juniors and not have scoring involved. Farcical.
 
No, the coach Stuart Wynd kicked 19, but that was in First Div. Some talk about that if he got to 18 he might have been moved to the backline.;)
 
The highlight for me looking at those results is Nunawading's win in the 2's and the improvement in the club despite their 1's loss today.The lowlight will be East Burwood will dominate this grade and personally I can see them going through the season un beaten."BUT" only early days,lol.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom