List Mgmt. Do we go all in for Jack?

[Linekers Ears]

3 x ass jokes coming up

Angus Brayyyshaw

And a long dong comment

Hehaw-ways tells that joke

 

[Linekers Ears]

Yeah, Luko to Carlton then we get him back as a Cat C rookie in a few years.

Is Cat C is a special category for rehabilitating players who've been on Carlton's list?

 

[BrissyCrow]

Not that I can think of...

And he certainly tried to do a number on Tex last night as well.

What we pay will be determined on how determined we are on getting pickm one or even pick two. I feel that by dealing with SOS we will be paying more than we should but how badly do we want pick one.

Some on here are also talking about giving up our 2018 and 2019 first rounders. We need to be mindful that there are some players from the under 16's National Comp that excelled for South Australia. Luke Edwards was one but there was a guy called Durdin who won the overall medal for the comp. So 2019 may also offer some excellent SA talent.

 

[LC40]

And he certainly tried to do a number on Tex last night as well.

What we pay will be determined on how determined we are on getting pickm one or even pick two. I feel that by dealing with SOS we will be paying more than we should but how badly do we want pick one.

Some on here are also talking about giving up our 2018 and 2019 first rounders. We need to be mindful that there are some players from the under 16's National Comp that excelled for South Australia. Luke Edwards was one but there was a guy called Durdin who won the overall medal for the comp. So 2019 may also offer some excellent SA talent.

The SA under 16's have some excellent talent, we want picks for them. Durdin is a real talent from Centrals and he has a bit of time to grow but he is very small.

 

[Golumless]

2016 first round pick - 15
2017 first round pick - 16

We gave up 10 and 16.

We did get back pick 19 for 16 which i'm also assuming was a key part of this deal as well seeing the strength of SA players in the 2018 draft.

 

[Cleric]

We did get back pick 19 for 16 which i'm also assuming was a key part of this deal as well seeing the strength of SA players in the 2018 draft.

We would have got their second back last year as well.
However, we gave them our second as well.

 

[Donkey Magoo]

Betts are off GreyCrow Linekers Ears

 

[Glenny83]

Carlton doesn’t have pick 33.

It’s from Carlton and then on-traded.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Betts are off]

Betts are off GreyCrow Linekers Ears
View attachment 528934

 

[Sanders]

We would have got their second back last year as well.

Stop passing off as fact things you make up from nothing

 

[Cleric]

Stop passing off as fact things you make up from nothing

Stop being Sanders. That schtick is old.

 

[Sanders]

Stop being Sanders. That schtick is old.

Nice shirk

Luke Jericho would be proud

 

[Rear Admiral]

I would give up just about anyone on our list and package with a handful of first rounders in order to be in a position to get Lukosius and Rankine.

But we may only be able to get one, so we need to prioritise. What we need is pace. Absolute scorching, blistering pace. And the ability to win the ball in contests/stoppages/scrimmages...and break away from the congestion. At present, we do not have this.

Would Lukosius be a good get? Absolutely, but not at the expense of Rankine and some others. We have an absolute forest of contested/tall timber, where we do not need to add to this at the moment. We need serious pace between the Arcs, and more than just one addition.

 

[stefoid]

pick 5 for 13, 19 and McGovern.

Is this a win win?

 

[BunjiMC]

pick 5 for 13, 19 and McGovern.

Is this a win win?

No.

 

[Crowked]

pick 5 for 13, 19 and McGovern.

Is this a win win?

5 for 13 & 19

Or

5 for McGovern

 

[Betts are off]

pick 5 for 13, 19 and McGovern.

Is this a win win?

That deal is about as good as the one Donald Trump proposed to the Mexicans regarding their fence....

 

[stefoid]

yeah, its not 'fair' but a fair deal wont get made for a top 5 pick, particularly in this draft. You will have to offer sweetheart deals to prise those picks out of clubs hands

 

[Scorpus]

yeah, its not 'fair' but a fair deal wont get made for a top 5 pick, particularly in this draft. You will have to offer sweetheart deals to prise those picks out of clubs hands

We'll keep our picks and players then thanks

 

[Bicks]

pick 5 for 13, 19 and McGovern.

Is this a win win?

LOL

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

pick 5 for 13, 19 and McGovern.

Is this a win win?

By a long way... for the Bulldogs!

No chance we would offer anything like this in your favour.

 

[Tex200]

yeah, its not 'fair' but a fair deal wont get made for a top 5 pick, particularly in this draft. You will have to offer sweetheart deals to prise those picks out of clubs hands

I agree.

No one holding top 5 picks are there to assist with the easy passage of either Luko or Rankine to us, as nice a story as it may be.

If we go down that path I wouldn't expect any favours in the deals

 

[Crowked]

I agree.

No one holding top 5 picks are there to assist with the easy passage of either Luko or Rankine to us, as nice a story as it may be.

If we go down that path I wouldn't expect any favours in the deals

There is a limit to what can be demanded too though if they genuinely want to go down the path of trading a top pick out. The trade outlined earlier is well over the line. If they came with that proposal, we wouldn’t even consider it. I reckon that was just about double what I’d think is realistic. You might go a bit over to get it done, but not double.

 

[Tex200]

There is a limit to what can be demanded too though if they genuinely want to go down the path of trading a top pick out. The trade outlined earlier is well over the line. If they came with that proposal, we wouldn’t even consider it. I reckon that was just about double what I’d think is realistic. You might go a bit over to get it done, but not double.

Yep fair enough.

All boils down to what we are prepared to give up. Similar to the Gibbs trade in so far as they have what we want, therefore it's a sellers market.

No point scoffing at unreasonable demands. They don't have to give us anything.

 

[LiamPickering]

yeah, its not 'fair' but a fair deal wont get made for a top 5 pick, particularly in this draft. You will have to offer sweetheart deals to prise those picks out of clubs hands

Guess Rhylee West will be playing elsewhere while you wait for your deal.