Dom Sheed vs Lachie Neale

[Mincho]

Who is the better player, who will be the better player?

 

[eth-dog]

How is this a question? Neale every time

 

[Mincho]

Eaglespur Was just saying he/she thinks Dom Sheed would be/is the better player - I disagree - thought the football public could decide.

 

[Eaglespur]

Haha Mincho triggered orrr

Sheed will have a better 2018

 

[Mincho]

Haha Mincho triggered orrr

Sheed will have a better 2018

"triggered" lol.

 

[Eaglespur]

"triggered" lol.

Triggered AF brah

 

[blitzer]

Sheed would have to improve a lot to pass Neale.

Neale didn't have his best 2017 but I rate him very highly.

 

[RobbyRoy]

Sheed came on well this season but Neale is way ahead.

 

[Kram]

Not one of Pav4AA's best efforts.

 

[avishka5]

Neale by that far that its not funny and im one of Sheeds biggest fans.

That said Sheed has barely played on ball over the last few years. Interesting to see what he delivers with greater opportunity.


He also needs to build a tank.

 

[Xhoquelin]

Sheed could have a Lyons/Cunnington type season, racking up the pill in a s**t side.

That’s the only way he’s outplays Neale next season. Neale is quicker, has way more runs on the board.

 

[avishka5]

Sheed could have a Lyons/Cunnington type season, racking up the pill in a s**t side.

That’s the only way he’s outplays Neale next season. Neale is quicker, has way more runs on the board.

Agree on both points but i think Sheed has other traits that Neale doesn't possess.

Anyhow Both are different type of players, Neale's a contested beast while Sheed is an inside/outside player.

 

[Mico89]

Unfortunately Neale currently is the better and more consistent player..... But who knows, some players take longer to develop and get to there best Dane Swan, Luke Hodge and Garry Ablett are perfect examples

 

[Mitchell54]

Neale is already a star. Sheed is an ok player.

What’s the argument?