In fairness to Carlton 11 of their 1st rounders are mostly rejects from other clubs.
3 of their 1st rounders are virtually cooked, Murphy Kreuzer Thomas
Allow for a couple to be average SOS selections probably Dow and O'Brien
Allow for a few to have injury riddled careers like Docherty
It only leaves a half a dozen serious 1st rounders being Cripps, Weitering, Curnow, SPS, McKay, Walsh.
That's why they are 1 & 4 and 4 from 35. Their depth of class is about as shallow as a kids wading pool.
Getting games into spuds is like giving crap wine more time to age.
In 2016 they had 1st rounders like Sumner, Gorringe, Everitt, Jaksch, Wood, Boekhorst, Lamb,
the only thing that has changed are a few names same spud recruiting policy of rejects or injury prone players