List Mgmt. Draft Discussion 2016

[Fyfe2Shenton]

What do people think of KM's idea that StKilda would bid on , and get a half back flanker "Cumming" that they can't be bothered with?

At least we can't say KM is afraid to back himself.
I haven't seen anyone else predict Florent or Cox as early as he has, or Battle and Rotham as late.
He also seems to list a few guys who aren't on other peoples radar.

He is certainly not like the rest of the copycat media, but I don't rate his knowledge of our list needs.

 

[Melksham2Siposs]

We should be able to get him at 61.

If he turned out like a Brandon White style slider and we pinch him...

Good shit. Real good shit.

It was you who posted this in another thread, yeah..



26 seconds in. That is a nice!

 

[Fyfe2Shenton]

If he turned out like a Brandon White style slider and we pinch him...

Good shit. Real good shit.

It was you who posted this in another thread, yeah..



26 seconds in. That is a nice!

I don't remember posting about him.

But I really like what I see in that video.

 

[JG22]

We should be able to get him at 61.

61 would seem the chance.
Hearing Trout on the podcast the other day looks like size will be prioritsied first

 

[Mighty_sainter]

Do you think he's helped Wright?

Yeah probably, some people can learn some can't, just depends wether they think they can fix, his kicking is inconsistent it isn't shit, in the all stars game he didn't miss a target

 

[Impatient Saint]

61 would seem the chance.
Hearing Trout on the podcast the other day looks like size will be prioritsied first

Tend to agree and we know he loves the kids with great character. So 23 probably looks like Berry, Dylan Clarke or Griffin Logue, size versatile and known strong characters.

If I had seen SPP play midfield which he obviously does at WAFL Colts level, I may be more settled on chosing him. But isnt the WAFL Colts like the TAC B grade?

 

[Kilroy]

Yeah probably, some people can learn some can't, just depends wether they think they can fix, his kicking is inconsistent it isn't shit, in the all stars game he didn't miss a target

I realise the combine has limitations regarding it's relationship to actual games but Powell-Pepper killed it in the beep test, agility and clean hands (all top 10), but the most stunning result was in the goal kicking where he got a perfect score of 30/30, five clear of the next best.

The all-stars game backed up that performance on the big stage.

If nothing else it shows he can learn and is probably even motivated to prove the naysayers wrong.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

I realise the combine has limitations regarding it's relationship to actual games but Powell-Pepper killed it in the beep test, agility and clean hands (all top 10), but the most stunning result was in the goal kicking where he got a perfect score of 30/30, five clear of the next best.

The all-stars game backed up that performance on the big stage.

If nothing else it shows he can learn and is probably even motivated to prove the naysayers wrong.

CJ did OK at goal kicking. 6 goals 1 behind in 2013 ( though maybe there were 12 out on the full's ).

 

[Mighty_sainter]

CJ did OK at goal kicking. 6 goals 1 behind in 2013 ( though maybe there were 12 out on the full's ).

Your missing the point

 

[Barrels]

Your missing the point

You're missing an apostrophe and an E.

 

[Mighty_sainter]

You're missing an apostrophe and an E.

And you get bullied

 

[Barrels]

And you get bullied

First I've heard of it...

 

[Glen Buterol]

Lmao

 

[StCicatriz]

I realise the combine has limitations regarding it's relationship to actual games but Powell-Pepper killed it in the beep test, agility and clean hands (all top 10), but the most stunning result was in the goal kicking where he got a perfect score of 30/30, five clear of the next best.

The all-stars game backed up that performance on the big stage.

If nothing else it shows he can learn and is probably even motivated to prove the naysayers wrong.

Or the other option is people over state the disposal issues....

 

[St Pauls]

I think I'll go:

23: Rotham or Ridley , developing skillfull third tall

36: Begley Gorward Midfield depth

61: Jack Maibaum (sounds unlikely) or developing key defender for depth

 

[crasha301]

And you get bullied

Bloody campaigner sitting on his high horse! How dare he look down on our grammar and spelling

 

[Barrels]

Bloody campaigner, sitting on his high horse! How dare he look down on our grammar and spelling!

Fixed.

 

[dogs105]

Quentin Narkle any relation to this campaigner?

If so then get him.

Wow. Scanlens did Roller Derby cards??!

 

[Impatient Saint]

We know Trout loves the kids with great character. So 23 probably looks like Berry, Dylan Clarke or Griffin Logue, size versatile and known strong characters.

If I had seen SPP play midfield, which he obviously does at WAFL Colts level, I may be more settled on chosing him. But isnt the WAFL Colts like the TAC B grade?

He played HBF in both the U18's & All Stars game, unless he can become a full midfielder we dont need more flankers.

 

[Mighty_sainter]

We know Trout loves the kids with great character. So 23 probably looks like Berry, Dylan Clarke or Griffin Logue, size versatile and known strong characters.

If I had seen SPP play midfield, which he obviously does at WAFL Colts level, I may be more settled on chosing him. But isnt the WAFL Colts like the TAC B grade?

He played HBF in both the U18's & All Stars game, unless he can become a full midfielder we dont need more flankers.

His best spot this year was hff

 

[Jade Buddha]

We now have muscle, we need class with 23.

 

[Persevering Saint]

We now have muscle, we need class with 23.

Do you get much class at 23?

 

[#1_pigeonracer]

Caleb Daniel walked past 23 and then some.

 

[Jade Buddha]

Do you get much class at 23?

History would suggest yes but you need a little vision.

Depends on how much faith you have in our talent scouts, recruiters.

 

[Impatient Saint]

Do you get much class at 23?

I tend to agree we need that outside speed and class so players like Florent, Bolton, Gallucci or Villis would be great but I reckon they will go with the best available slider at #23. Berry has had an interrupted year after playing well last year and Trout loves him. Griffin Logue or Rotham are both classy defensive intecept marking defenders who have spent some time in the middle, may slide through.

Dylan Clarke and Bonke and are both ball magnet contested goal kickers whom I rate. SPP provides a hard edge with a huge boot. I like the look of the GWS versatile t
all Zac Sproule just reckon there is something about him and wouldnt be upset if we bid on him. Then today I read clubs are looking at another GWS academy kid named Isaac Cummings moving into the top 30.

Its a tough choice all round for Trout and his team, but trust they will get it right!