Prediction DRAFT POLL_PICK #5_FINAL

[Tambourine]

Changed my vote again :/ i think brodie is the man we need. Competitive beast, clearence machine, yes please.

 

[TheHeatleyStand]

Scrimshaw not the man.

 

[GoBlues!]

Scrimshaw Bio reads:

QUERY

Scrimshaw can hurt opposition teams when given time and space, but he will need to work hard on improving the contested side of his game – especially if clubs view him as a midfielder.

Hip surgery that ruled him out in 2015, followed by a foot injury he suffered while on tour with the NAB AFL Academy in the United States in January, may also be a cause for concern.

Anyone know how bad the hip and foot injuries were? He seemed to move okay in the 2016 highlights snippets.

 

[BluesRule]

Scrimshaw is being seriously considered at our pick 5. McCluggage will be gone before our pick.

Sounds good to me as Scrimshaw is a defender and we are building a team from the back line.

Still cannot believe that Brodie has fallen so far. His stats look average but his game impact was immense? And I loved that sidestep.

Would be very happy with any one of:
Taranto (or Mcluggagge, Ainsworth, McGrath)
Brodie
Scrimshaw
SPS
or even the less likely Hayward

Each offers something we do not have.

 

[BluesRule]

Would not surprise me. Can play forward, back and outside mid. Kicking skills are good, which I think will be a prerequisite in this draft. Still reckon on SPS, think he's a Bolton type and is elite, but Scrimshaw isn't far behind.

BRI and GCS won't pass on Hugh. Still reckon he might go #1. Hearing Jobe Watson is a big chance to retire. His head is no longer in it and the Brownlow saga is the final straw. Hugh fills that hole.

If Jobe retires do the Dons need Brodie again?

 

[AndyLucimitis]

So it's one of 4 or 5 (using Rex Hunt nicknames)

- The Director - Quentin Taranto

- The Suitcase - McLuggage

- The Redemption - Shawshank

- Multi-Cultural TV - SPS

- Glenn McGrath

 

[Azul]

So it's one of 4 or 5 (using Rex Hunt nicknames)

- The Director - Quentin Taranto

- The Suitcase - McLuggage

- The Redemption - Shawshank

- Multi-Cultural TV - SPS

- Glenn McGrath

TV chef Ainsley Harriot?

 

[AndyLucimitis]

TV chef Ainsley Harriot?

The Condiment- Salt & Pepper Powell


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[I bleed Blue]

Kill me now

 

[Lace_Out]

Kill me now - McLuggage after being taken by *

EFA

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

 

[ferrisb]

Kill me now

Is that a play on words on Josh Battle?

 

[1981]

I bet you we won't take PP if there because Bolts won't want dodge kicks

Interestingly RE all the names being touted as being at the pointy end, there's about 11 of them, so maybe that's why SOS rejected Adelaide's bid of 13 -- maybe he felt that pick was just outside the range of the top prospects

 

[1981]

I reckon the club are leaking names so as to put off GC

First it was SPS
Then Hayward
Now The Scrim

Maybe we want GC to take one of these so a Ainsworth type slides to us

 

[Soapy V]

I reckon the club are leaking names so as to put off GC

First it was SPS
Then Hayward
Now The Scrim

Maybe we want GC to take one of these so a Ainsworth type slides to us

It's always been the Scrim. Best player in the draft

 

[MileHigh]

Scrimshaw Bio reads:

QUERY

Scrimshaw can hurt opposition teams when given time and space, but he will need to work hard on improving the contested side of his game – especially if clubs view him as a midfielder.

Hip surgery that ruled him out in 2015, followed by a foot injury he suffered while on tour with the NAB AFL Academy in the United States in January, may also be a cause for concern.

Anyone know how bad the hip and foot injuries were? He seemed to move okay in the 2016 highlights snippets.

Will definitely draft him based on having previous injuries. Its a pre-requisite at the new look Carlton under SOS.

I can imagine SOS down at the flea market every weekend looking for damaged goods he can pick up for a bargain to fix up.

 

[TheHeatleyStand]

Scrimshaw could just as easily run off the wing and be the outsider we need. I'm happy for SOS to make the right call, especially in such as even draft. Have faith.

Precisely why shouldn't take him....

 

[HBF]

Scrimshaw not the man.

Gotta be SPS.
Too much noise from various people who are all predicting SPS.

 

[DavidRJonus]

I dont think SPS has the outside mid flanker style play that bolts likes

 

[Bic]

Gotta be SPS.
Too much noise from various people who are all predicting SPS.

Lock it in, Eddy!

 

[BluesRule]

So it's one of 4 or 5 (using Rex Hunt nicknames)

- The Director - Quentin Taranto

- The Suitcase - McLuggage

- The Redemption - Shawshank

- Multi-Cultural TV - SPS

- Glenn McGrath

The Governor General - (Sir John) Kerr

 

[HBF]

Lock it in, Eddy!

The combination of Cripps and SPS could be frightening for other clubs in years to come.

 

[Nori]

SPS just makes sense on so many levels. I'd be super surprised if he didn't become a Blue.

Also, question marks on Taranto's leg speed and Scrimshaw's body and ability to move into the midfield.

 

[Navara79]

My YouTube most watched videos tells me I'm sticking with Brodie.

 

[Bic]

The combination of Cripps and SPS could be frightening for other clubs in years to come.

Some quality WA boys, that is for sure.

Really hope the rubbish (harsh, but my opinion) of Kerr at 25 is just pure romance, because we could add another quality midfielder at this pick.

 

[Red Bull]

At least Petrevski-Seton & McCluggage have more total views.

A far cry from the days when Richmond selected JON in the draft sight unseen ...