Remove this Banner Ad

Draft/Trade Talk Only Thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Re: Josh Mahoney

Not naming names?

I don't need to name names for posters here to know who I might be talking about!! I mean in a coaching capacity.....BTW
 
Why would you trade a guy that was regular and valuable memeber of the 22 until this mid season together with a 2nd round pick all for a guy that doesn't get a regular game at a club aroud our level?

It reeks like the Montgomery/Eagleton trade where we paid too much and lost out big time.

Just a question - do you think our list needs to rebalance, if so who would you trade (who has any value, so don't say Power et al)
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Just a question - do you think our list needs to rebalance, if so who would you trade (who has any value, so don't say Power et al)
We need a rebalance for good players not trading good ones and our drafts picks for speculative guesses.
I'd didn't say don't trade McMahon just think he is worth more than the trades put here.
I have no idea who should be traded, I leave that with the club, just think anyone is tradable at the right price.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Freo get McMahon, 3rd/4th rd pick
Dogs get Murphy, 2nd round pick


Crows get two highish 2nd round picks
Dogs get McGregor and Meesen


Net outcome - Dogs get Meesen (developing ruck), Murphy (developing fwd) and McGregor (goal square contested mark)

???
 
Re: Time to part ways

2nd rounder. Has he fully recovered from the hip/leg injury?
Dowler shattered his pelvis 2 years ago I think. He may not be ready for afl yet but next year or the they year after he will be pretty good. kicked 7 for box hill last weekend:thumbsu:. what would you offer for tim boyle?
 
Re: Time to part ways

what would you offer for tim boyle?
Im not sure how Boyle would go in our forward line being the focal point. He has Roughead and Franklin taking the pressure off him whoich would mean he would be getting the no.3 at best backmen. He would struggle against the elite backmen which he would have to tackle if he came to the dogs.

Having said that i would give up a 2nd rounder and would perfer him over McGregor.
 
Freo get McMahon, 3rd/4th rd pick
Dogs get Murphy, 2nd round pick


Crows get two highish 2nd round picks
Dogs get McGregor and Meesen


Net outcome - Dogs get Meesen (developing ruck), Murphy (developing fwd) and McGregor (goal square contested mark)

???

Whats the net loss?
Sounds like we loss McMahon, 2nd,3rd and 4th round picks for 3 risky players! What a bargain.

Why would McMahon want to go WA instead of SA?
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

what are your thoughts after seeing Rusling play tonight?

pies have got 4 tall forwards 20yrs and under...might not be room for all of them

Yea, he's fairly injury prone...and can't kick, well he can...ok. Sounds like our type. 3rd round draft pick, because he can actually mark. But at 190cm he isn't what we are after. We have a lot of players around this height.
 
I think you guys could have an awesome forward line if you tried to get Boyle and Fev if you wanted them. It could go something like

Johnson-Fevola-Boyle
Giansiracusa-Mcdouggal-Akermanis

It would be a potent forward line.
 
I think you guys could have an awesome forward line if you tried to get Boyle and Fev if you wanted them. It could go something like

Johnson-Fevola-Boyle
Giansiracusa-Mcdouggal-Akermanis

It would be a potent forward line.

MMmmm... Johnno (superstar) Fev (idiot) Boyle (unsure/injury prone)
Gia (soft/inconsistant) Doogs (werribee) Aker (aging)

Yeah looks potent alright.
 
MMmmm... Johnno (superstar) Fev (idiot) Boyle (unsure/injury prone)
Gia (soft/inconsistant) Doogs (werribee) Aker (aging)

Yeah looks potent alright.
Woops forgot R.Murphy, sub him in for Mcdoguall. If you say that forward line isn't good then I'd hate to think of your opinion of your forward line now...
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Draft/Trade Talk Only Thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top