Draft/Trade Talk Only Thread

[Pigdog]

I have no idea at all, just found them on the net. I must say tho, it is difficult to take in what you post when those lovely ladies keep appearing.

Did you delete them before The Coon Pup found them?

I might have change the avatar when the season starts as no one will take me serious, not that anyone does now..

 

[rapidshave]

Did you delete them before The Coon Pup found them?

I might have change the avatar when the season starts as no one will take me serious, not that anyone does now..

The problem is that almost everyone is looking at your avatar instead of what you say....it's hypnotic.

 

[DogsRuleWstNoBul]

Re: Draft/Trade Talk Only Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by scooter600x
It's really not that difficult.

If you want Judd, you need pick 5 - no-one else is going to help you out with an early pick. Pick 5 will cost you Reid.

As you know Judd is down to 4 clubs.
Carlton ?
Collingwood Most likely
Melbourne Sentimental Fav
Essendon ? No coach Board in up upheaval.

I think it will be Collingwood who is firming as Favorite with Judd. Remember it is his decision where he wants to go. Melbourne could pull a coo if they pull something out today but I don't think so.

So Collingwood will have the box seat with WCE. Good players will be on the table for him. It will come down to if WCE want the draft pick for something they see in the draft they want or they are happy with the player they want.

Reid for pick 5 could be up their but we may find that one of Reid, Pendulbery, or Thomas is heading West. I don't think he will cost anymore than one of these players and maybe a draft pick

Thoughts

 

[stefoid]

Sorry to go off on a tangent a bit here.
This whole Judd thing is a farce. His manager ruled the Saints basically because of the board issues but doesn't rule out Essendon?
Won't go to us becuase of Aker, coming from drug heaven club and doesn't rule out Collingwood who have terrible discipline.

Leigh Matthew's is right. Judd is just a whore and the club that gets to sleep with him will be the one that pays the most.
I hope it all backfires for Judd and his new club.

WCE supporters are calling him Juddas

 

[Gridlock'd]

Re: Draft/Trade Talk Only Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by scooter600x
It's really not that difficult.

If you want Judd, you need pick 5 - no-one else is going to help you out with an early pick. Pick 5 will cost you Reid.

As you know Judd is down to 4 clubs.
Carlton ?
Collingwood Most likely
Melbourne Sentimental Fav
Essendon ? No coach Board in up upheaval.

I think it will be Collingwood who is firming as Favorite with Judd. Remember it is his decision where he wants to go. Melbourne could pull a coo if they pull something out today but I don't think so.

So Collingwood will have the box seat with WCE. Good players will be on the table for him. It will come down to if WCE want the draft pick for something they see in the draft they want or they are happy with the player they want.

Reid for pick 5 could be up their but we may find that one of Reid, Pendulbery, or Thomas is heading West. I don't think he will cost anymore than one of these players and maybe a draft pick

Thoughts

Have I read this 3 times or am I going mad?

 

[DogsRuleWstNoBul]

Yep.

 

[mjp]

Melbourne could pull a coo if they pull something out today but I don't think so.

Is that some kind of native bird call specific to the Junction Oval area?

 

[DogsRuleWstNoBul]

Is that some kind of native bird call specific to the Junction Oval area?

Ok I give up!

Its a lovely day may as well go for a walk.

 

[mjp]

Ok I give up!

Its a lovely day may as well go for a walk.

Sorry - I couldn't resist. Even you would have to admit spelling errors of this magnitude cannot remain unpunished (or at least they cannot be allowed through to the keeper without some sledging! )

 

[borgy]

Chris Masten reportedly has OP.

Could he slip to our 5th pick?

Is he worth it and does he fit our needs?

Who could you compare him to?

 

[lindsay_bulldogs]

Chris Masten reportedly has OP.

Could he slip to our 5th pick?

Is he worth it and does he fit our needs?

Who could you compare him to?

Could go anywhere from 5 onwards but should be picked up in top 20.

Found this review on the Draft board. This person thinks he will be 4th Draft pick.

4. Chris Masten (Rover)

Rovers tends not to go too early but Masten is simply too good to pass on. Might not be as sharp as Murphy or as dynamic as McLean but deserves to be in that same sort of early pick company. Pace is OK, wins huge amounts of the ball in tight, uses it well and brings teammates into the game. Can flat-out play and clubs will regret getting too clever and letting him slide. Got an armchair ride from Leuenberger last year - not this time where Palmer owes him a bevvy.

 

[Rade Gordy]

Chris Masten reportedly has OP.

Could he slip to our 5th pick?

Is he worth it and does he fit our needs?

Who could you compare him to?

There is a number of players that will go around the 4 to 10 mark and he is one of them. A slower version of Peter Bell might be a decent comparison. He is only 179 or 180 cm though but he works hard and has skills. One of those player that could play some senior football straight away if needed.

 

[borgy]

Cheers guys.

 

[Gooka]

Easton Wood. Remember the name. He will be on your list come draft day.

Sounds like a pornstar name for some asian guy.

 

[lindsay_bulldogs]

Also found these reviews

W.A;
- Chris Masten, 178 cm. Classic B+ inside midfielder. Chad fletecher with a better head and pace. I'll get criticised for this but his kicking is to be desired on occasions. Kicked efficiency over the U18s was average, and his impact was not to that he had in his U15 and U16 national carnivals. Definate first round but possible slider.

Chris Masten – 180cm, 78kg – East Fremantle. A genuine in and under rover who can run all day and is very good at getting his team mates into the game. His skills are very good and creative on both sides of his body and knows how to block for his mates in the middle. He isn’t a jet as far as pace goes but his vision and composure make up for that. Finds plenty of the footy and is very good at the stoppages and clearances. He has had a pretty consistent year playing mainly in the seniors for East Fremantle in the WAFL. Had an excellent under 18 championship series where he was captain of WA and really delivered on field with his work rate and one precenters. Played really consistent footy over four quarters in all three champ matches. Work rate is very good. Doesn’t mind going forward and kicking a goal.
Top 15 pick.

 

[Bulldog Banana]

WCE supporters are calling him Juddas

I know they are not in the same class, but it was ok for Tyson Stenglein to go "home" to WA from the Crows.
Dont like the boot on the other foot.....

 

[Viva la Mattner]

Ben Hudson to the WB

As you are probably well aware AFC ruckmen Ben Hudson is seeking a trade to the Western Bulldogs.
What are you expectations on what the WB would offer in return.

My idea is this:

Hudson + McGregor (also seeking a trade) + 1st Round pick + 3rd Round pick

for

McMahon + 1st Round pick

or

Cooney + McMahon + 2nd Round pick

 

[scooter600x]

Re: Ben Hudson to the WB

As you are probably well aware AFC ruckmen Ben Hudson is seeking a trade to the Western Bulldogs.
What are you expectations on what the WB would offer in return.

My idea is this:

Hudson + McGregor (also seeking a trade) + 1st Round pick + 3rd Round pick

for

McMahon + 1st Round pick

or

Cooney + McMahon + 2nd Round pick

Go away

 

[Viva la Mattner]

Re: Ben Hudson to the WB

Go away

ok what are your thoughts, what would you offer for a top class ruckmen and a decent kpp forward/backman??

 

[Bulldogs_6]

Re: Ben Hudson to the WB

ok what are your thoughts, what would you offer for a top class ruckmen and a decent kpp forward/backman??

Nothing. hes not top class and ken is just decent, mcmahon for both at most

 

[Gridlock'd]

Re: Ben Hudson to the WB

As you are probably well aware AFC ruckmen Ben Hudson is seeking a trade to the Western Bulldogs.
What are you expectations on what the WB would offer in return.

My idea is this:

Hudson + McGregor (also seeking a trade) + 1st Round pick + 3rd Round pick

for

McMahon + 1st Round pick

or

Cooney + McMahon + 2nd Round pick

Hudson for our second round pick. Fair deal.

If its Hudson and Mcgregor then our second round pick and Eagleton.

 

[Viva la Mattner]

Re: Ben Hudson to the WB

Nothing. hes not top class and ken is just decent, mcmahon for both at most

i'd take that

 

[scooter600x]

Re: Ben Hudson to the WB

ok what are your thoughts, what would you offer for a top class ruckmen and a decent kpp forward/backman??

I wasn't going to reply because it's pat your bedtime and I don't want you to get in trouble off your mum, but I will.

You clearly didn't hear 5AA report today that NO-ONE is interested in McGregor. He's a dud - slow, one-dimentional. You will delist him and if he's really lucky someone will give him another go in the PSD.

Hudson is an adequate ruckman, no Dean Cox, but adequate. He's also 29 and has asked to be traded - to us. Clubs aren't emotional like fans. Like all professional organisation, the Crows will want to get rid of him with as little distraction as possible.

Expect Hudson & pick 27 for Picks 22 & 38.

Cooney signed a new contract a month ago. McMahon will only be traded if he requests to go back to Adelaide which is looking less and less likely.

 

[scooter600x]

Re: Ben Hudson to the WB

i'd take that

Of course you would, you'd be getting away with daylight robbery.

 

[Viva la Mattner]

Re: Ben Hudson to the WB

I wasn't going to reply because it's pat your bedtime and I don't want you to get in trouble off your mum, but I will.

You clearly didn't hear 5AA report today that NO-ONE is interested in McGregor. He's a dud - slow, one-dimentional. You will delist him and if he's really lucky someone will give him another go in the PSD.

Hudson is an adequate ruckman, no Dean Cox, but adequate. He's also 29 and has asked to be traded - to us. Clubs aren't emotional like fans. Like all professional organisation, the Crows will want to get rid of him with as little distraction as possible.

Expect Hudson & pick 27 for Picks 22 & 38.

Cooney signed a new contract a month ago. McMahon will only be traded if he requests to go back to Adelaide which is looking less and less likely.

well, look to the left at my location, ENGLAND its 2pm here and last time i checked 5AA is an Adelaide station........