He has signed with Freo for 2 years.
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Draft/Trade Talk Only Thread
- Thread starter OldSchool
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
He has signed with Freo for 2 years.
Dixie Flatline
Moderator
- Jun 3, 2005
- 39,884
- 41,372
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Cartagena C.F., NYJ, A's
- Moderator
- #1,152
No, but Roughead's family made it very clear to Hawthorn that they do not want to see him traded (Roughead was offered to West Coast as part of the deal to get Judd, but without his family's knowledge). Now that Hawthorn has no chance to get Judd, Roughead will be off the table.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Re: Pick 5
Hopefully Ben McEvoy. I'd much prefer to keep the pick than trade it.
Hopefully Ben McEvoy. I'd much prefer to keep the pick than trade it.
Mr Recruiter
Rookie
Stefan Martin 198cm 95kg 20y.o Versatile KKP/Ruckman
Newcomer to footy, basketball background. Started playing footy a yr ago in the under 19's amatuers and got best in the league after only playing 7games. Played for sandringham vfl firsts this yr and impressed kicking goals as well as winning in the ruck. Athletic, great leap, can play forward. Was also best on ground for Vic versus Allies last week. Would have been as good as Kreuzer if he had play from a young age. Will defiantly be rookied, or drafted from 30 onward. Ricky Nixon (player manager) gives him big raps.......will also be attending the Vic state screening tomorrow.
Newcomer to footy, basketball background. Started playing footy a yr ago in the under 19's amatuers and got best in the league after only playing 7games. Played for sandringham vfl firsts this yr and impressed kicking goals as well as winning in the ruck. Athletic, great leap, can play forward. Was also best on ground for Vic versus Allies last week. Would have been as good as Kreuzer if he had play from a young age. Will defiantly be rookied, or drafted from 30 onward. Ricky Nixon (player manager) gives him big raps.......will also be attending the Vic state screening tomorrow.
Re: Pick 5
So we take Palmer and not worry about tall forwards?
Take Kennedy and pick 20.
The idea is to build the best team, not have the best group of players.
So we take Palmer and not worry about tall forwards?
Take Kennedy and pick 20.
The idea is to build the best team, not have the best group of players.
Re: Pick 5
I'm sure there are better qualified people than me however I'm not convinced McEvoy is a no. 5 pick.
If I had to choose between Kennedy & 20 for 5 vs McEvoy. I'd go for JK, The President!!!
I'm sure there are better qualified people than me however I'm not convinced McEvoy is a no. 5 pick.
If I had to choose between Kennedy & 20 for 5 vs McEvoy. I'd go for JK, The President!!!
Re: Pick 5
Not too sure, I'm being guided here by mjp's views, so hopefully he'll be available at 5.
Not too sure, I'm being guided here by mjp's views, so hopefully he'll be available at 5.
- Banned
- #1,164
Re: Pick 5
I would swap pick 5 for Kennedy. If we got pick 20 as well, that is just a bonus.
I do not like Henderson for reasons I have previously stated.
I would swap pick 5 for Kennedy. If we got pick 20 as well, that is just a bonus.
I do not like Henderson for reasons I have previously stated.
Re: Pick 5
My understanding of Kennedy is he can take a pack mark, and has been starved of opportunity by a poor Fevola/Fisher/Waite focussed midfield.
Do you reckon he's better than McEvoy...?
And what about the idea of getting WC's first pick instead of 20?
WC get 3, 5 and 20 - lose Judd and 13?
carl get Judd for 3,20 and Kennedy?
Dogs get 13 and Kennedy for 5?
My understanding of Kennedy is he can take a pack mark, and has been starved of opportunity by a poor Fevola/Fisher/Waite focussed midfield.
Do you reckon he's better than McEvoy...?
And what about the idea of getting WC's first pick instead of 20?
WC get 3, 5 and 20 - lose Judd and 13?
carl get Judd for 3,20 and Kennedy?
Dogs get 13 and Kennedy for 5?
Re: Pick 5
i like kennedy and also already has a good size about him around the arms. will devolp even more in the off-season. he or fev would be great. plus throw in damon white alone with either tiller or skip and we are lookign alright for talls.
i like kennedy and also already has a good size about him around the arms. will devolp even more in the off-season. he or fev would be great. plus throw in damon white alone with either tiller or skip and we are lookign alright for talls.
Ive been thinking about it today, and I reckon we should go for Josh Kennedy if the trade comes up with Car/WC and they need our pick 5.
He has been in the system for 2 years, and has played senior footy.
If we go down the track of drafting a young tall, they are probably going to need a season or 2 to come on.
Seeing as he only 20, it looks a lot better than a Damon White / Ken McGregor who are 5 or 6 years older.
Hes tall and already has a decent build.
He was pick #4 a couple of years ago, which means he was highly rated by them. (I dont know if anyone else did)
I reckon hes got a huge upside. Due to Carltons reliance on Fevola they didnt kick to his leads very often.
He could slot straight into the team..
We could either use the pick 20 to draft or on trade it.
He has been in the system for 2 years, and has played senior footy.
If we go down the track of drafting a young tall, they are probably going to need a season or 2 to come on.
Seeing as he only 20, it looks a lot better than a Damon White / Ken McGregor who are 5 or 6 years older.
Hes tall and already has a decent build.
He was pick #4 a couple of years ago, which means he was highly rated by them. (I dont know if anyone else did)
I reckon hes got a huge upside. Due to Carltons reliance on Fevola they didnt kick to his leads very often.
He could slot straight into the team..
We could either use the pick 20 to draft or on trade it.
yeah but kennedy has a bit of a doogs vibe (he might come good), pick 4-5, criticised by supporters. The fact they are so willing to trade him.
It all suggests to me he isn't worth pick 5.
It all suggests to me he isn't worth pick 5.
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
W.Bulldogs_Aus_WC06
All Australian
a caller on OWAAT just suggested Sam Power staright swap for Miller from Melbourne. I'd do it, not sure if they would though.
But he also mentioned Pick 5 + Gia as a swap for Kennedy lol
But he also mentioned Pick 5 + Gia as a swap for Kennedy lol
http://www.news.com.au/mercury/story/0,22884,22541998-13222,00.html
Says that we haven't offered McMahon a new contract and that he is likely to be moved on.
I thought that Eade said he Jordie wanted to stay and we'd be keeping him?
Says that we haven't offered McMahon a new contract and that he is likely to be moved on.
I thought that Eade said he Jordie wanted to stay and we'd be keeping him?
Someone said player x is being traded, someone said player x is staying. I'll be glad when trade week is over, then at least we'll know for sure. In the meantime lots of speculation. I suppose it's fun for journo's & school kids with computers!
Someone said player x is being traded, someone said player x is staying. I'll be glad when trade week is over, then at least we'll know for sure. In the meantime lots of speculation. I suppose it's fun for journo's & school kids with computers!
Its almost here now, lets just get it done with.
I was out this morning & was chatting with the local butcher about footy. I said I hated the lead up to trade week with all the innuendo & speculation. He had a contrary view, saying he loved it. In his view it is 'Days Of Our Lives' for men!
With all the speculation, I think that we'll only get Hudson as anyone of significance. Maybe lose Power for nothing in particular. McMahon will probably stay. The draft picks will play out straight. Let's just hope they don't do anything stupid this week.
Trade week isn't necessarily the best path to building a championship team - something we should have learnt from past mistakes. I think we have a solid group that could overcome the setbacks of the past season.
Trade week isn't necessarily the best path to building a championship team - something we should have learnt from past mistakes. I think we have a solid group that could overcome the setbacks of the past season.
