'Dress it up as women's sport': the new pork barrel

Remove this Banner Ad

The_Wookie

Queenslander
Jul 2, 2010
33,203
30,915
Launceston
AFL Club
Carlton
'Dress it up as women's sport': the new pork barrel
John Kehoe
By John Kehoe
Updated Feb 15, 2019 — 4.22pm,
first published at 1.58pm
https://www.afr.com/business/sport/...hcry-for-the-sports-lobbyists-20190215-h1bawl


"Dress it up as women's sport." Those are the words of a football code lobbyist trudging the corridors of parliament house in Canberra this week, seeking millions of dollars of taxpayer money to build an elite sport facility to be used predominantly by men.

There was one problem – the original construction plan at the rugby venue in Sydney had omitted to include women's change rooms.

Better fix that before talking to the politicians!

Women's sport is the new catchcry for sports organisations lobbying for taxpayer money.

If women are involved, how can a politician say no?

Treasurer Josh Frydenberg played along earlier this week on a different project, unveiling $15 million to turn Melbourne's iconic Princes Park into the new "home of women's AFL" in Victoria – the training ground of the Carlton Blues men's team.

Frydenberg, a Carlton football tragic and sport fanatic, trotted out in front of the television cameras for a kick of the Sherrin with the female Blues players.

Victorian Labor premier Daniel Andrews chipped in $20 million – not a bad contribution of other people's money considering he barracks for arch rival Essendon.

Pleasingly, women's elite sport such as AFLW and cricket is finally blossoming – and as the sports-loving father of two young daughters this is a fantastic development for female sports participants who for too long have been neglected for their male counterparts. We've really enjoyed recently attending women's AFL and basketball matches.


Bill Shorten and his Melbourne associate, Collingwood President Eddie McGuire, did a deal on the government giving $10 million for the Magpies training facility in 2012. Darrian Traynor

Yet lobbyists from the sporting codes have latched on to the female sports boom to suck more money out of the federal and state governments – often for related professional men's organisations.

The public is entitled to know that politicians and sports leagues may be gilding the lily on which genders are really benefiting.

The average Australian taxpayer who earns $84,600 is effectively cross-subsidising millionaire sportsmen.

The average AFL player earns $371,000.

AFL boss Gillon McLachlan is paid more than $1.7 million a year.

It's not like the AFL should be desperate for public money.

The AFL earns a record $2.5 billion from a record six-year broadcasting contract with Seven West Media, Foxtel and Telstra that began in 2017.

It is tipping $25 million annually into a sinking Gold Coast Suns men's franchise.

The AFL reported a net profit of $48.8 million in 2017.

Frydenberg's Carlton posted a net operating profit of $2.6 million – despite finishing 2018 as wooden spooners.

Both sides of politics have been happy to indulge head honchos of the sporting codes.

Then-minister for employment and Collingwood supporter, Bill Shorten, stood shoulder-to-shoulder with his friend and Collingwood President Eddie McGuire in 2012, to give $10 million to the redevelopment of Collingwood's Westpac Centre facilities at the Olympic Park Precinct in Melbourne.

McGuire is an influential voice in Melbourne media. His brother Frank McGuire is a Labor member in the Victorian parliament.

Of course, the concerned parties insisted at the time the federal government's commitment of $10 million would go "directly to the Community Centre facilities" at the venue.

The AFL is not alone. Rugby, rugby league, soccer and cricket are all in the ears of federal and state governments, getting their share of taxpayer funds.

The AFL is simply better organised and more effective.

Its annual schmoozing of politicians and journalists in Canberra has bought goodwill.

Former prime minister Tony Abbott's one-time adviser Jude Donnelly is now head of AFL government relations.

Positively, the AFL is very good at driving participation of women, children and Indigenous people in the game, including giving away team paraphernalia and footballs to young Auskick participants.

Such stadium spending doesn't always end well.

The NSW government wants to outlay $730 million to knock down and rebuild the Sydney Football Stadium at Moore Park, but was forced to backflip on a related plan to demolish Sydney Olympic stadium.

The NSW building certifier, Watson Oldco, part of the Lendlease-led consortium that is building the new Western Sydney Stadium in Parramatta and redeveloping the Allianz Stadium next to the Sydney Cricket Ground, has gone into voluntary administration after involvement in buildings with combustible cladding.

Sporting largesse is undoubtedly good politics. But is doling out public money to elite sporting organisations the most judicious use of finite taxpayer money?

Arguably, underfunded grassroots sports would provide better value for money to encourage community participation, health and fitness.

Yet with a federal election looming, women's sport looks like the newest pork barrel.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

telsor

Hall of Famer
Aug 29, 2004
31,776
29,571
Here
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Habs
It's a fair topic to have a crack at, but by gee it's really poorly written.
Agreed.


For the other shoe dropping...Susie O'Brien wrote a piece in the Herald Sun (and doubtless other newscorp papers) 2 days ago about how female athletes should have pay equality.
 

Kwality

Brownlow Medallist
Aug 14, 2011
25,243
9,047
Tootgarook
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Renault F1

Kwality

Brownlow Medallist
Aug 14, 2011
25,243
9,047
Tootgarook
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Renault F1
Pleasingly, women's elite sport such as AFLW and cricket is finally blossoming – and as the sports-loving father of two young daughters this is a fantastic development for female sports participants who for too long have been neglected for their male counterparts. We've really enjoyed recently attending women's AFL and basketball matches.
All given the reality that just because you play a game you attend that sport at the top level,:thumbsdown:, blokes or girls its a fact NOT . I acknowledge for many :thumbsu: thats not their view aka its bloody nonsense.
Next time you see a post claiming junior participation is a guide to attendances at the highest level .... :'(
 
Last edited:

SaltPeter

"I’m a professional bullshitter"
Jan 6, 2018
8,844
10,009
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Norwood
'Dress it up as women's sport': the new pork barrel
John Kehoe
By John Kehoe
Updated Feb 15, 2019 — 4.22pm,
first published at 1.58pm
https://www.afr.com/business/sport/...hcry-for-the-sports-lobbyists-20190215-h1bawl


"Dress it up as women's sport." Those are the words of a football code lobbyist trudging the corridors of parliament house in Canberra this week, seeking millions of dollars of taxpayer money to build an elite sport facility to be used predominantly by men.

There was one problem – the original construction plan at the rugby venue in Sydney had omitted to include women's change rooms.

Better fix that before talking to the politicians!

Women's sport is the new catchcry for sports organisations lobbying for taxpayer money.

If women are involved, how can a politician say no?

Treasurer Josh Frydenberg played along earlier this week on a different project, unveiling $15 million to turn Melbourne's iconic Princes Park into the new "home of women's AFL" in Victoria – the training ground of the Carlton Blues men's team.

Frydenberg, a Carlton football tragic and sport fanatic, trotted out in front of the television cameras for a kick of the Sherrin with the female Blues players.

Victorian Labor premier Daniel Andrews chipped in $20 million – not a bad contribution of other people's money considering he barracks for arch rival Essendon.

Pleasingly, women's elite sport such as AFLW and cricket is finally blossoming – and as the sports-loving father of two young daughters this is a fantastic development for female sports participants who for too long have been neglected for their male counterparts. We've really enjoyed recently attending women's AFL and basketball matches.


Bill Shorten and his Melbourne associate, Collingwood President Eddie McGuire, did a deal on the government giving $10 million for the Magpies training facility in 2012. Darrian Traynor

Yet lobbyists from the sporting codes have latched on to the female sports boom to suck more money out of the federal and state governments – often for related professional men's organisations.

The public is entitled to know that politicians and sports leagues may be gilding the lily on which genders are really benefiting.

The average Australian taxpayer who earns $84,600 is effectively cross-subsidising millionaire sportsmen.

The average AFL player earns $371,000.

AFL boss Gillon McLachlan is paid more than $1.7 million a year.

It's not like the AFL should be desperate for public money.

The AFL earns a record $2.5 billion from a record six-year broadcasting contract with Seven West Media, Foxtel and Telstra that began in 2017.

It is tipping $25 million annually into a sinking Gold Coast Suns men's franchise.

The AFL reported a net profit of $48.8 million in 2017.

Frydenberg's Carlton posted a net operating profit of $2.6 million – despite finishing 2018 as wooden spooners.

Both sides of politics have been happy to indulge head honchos of the sporting codes.

Then-minister for employment and Collingwood supporter, Bill Shorten, stood shoulder-to-shoulder with his friend and Collingwood President Eddie McGuire in 2012, to give $10 million to the redevelopment of Collingwood's Westpac Centre facilities at the Olympic Park Precinct in Melbourne.

McGuire is an influential voice in Melbourne media. His brother Frank McGuire is a Labor member in the Victorian parliament.

Of course, the concerned parties insisted at the time the federal government's commitment of $10 million would go "directly to the Community Centre facilities" at the venue.

The AFL is not alone. Rugby, rugby league, soccer and cricket are all in the ears of federal and state governments, getting their share of taxpayer funds.

The AFL is simply better organised and more effective.

Its annual schmoozing of politicians and journalists in Canberra has bought goodwill.

Former prime minister Tony Abbott's one-time adviser Jude Donnelly is now head of AFL government relations.

Positively, the AFL is very good at driving participation of women, children and Indigenous people in the game, including giving away team paraphernalia and footballs to young Auskick participants.

Such stadium spending doesn't always end well.

The NSW government wants to outlay $730 million to knock down and rebuild the Sydney Football Stadium at Moore Park, but was forced to backflip on a related plan to demolish Sydney Olympic stadium.

The NSW building certifier, Watson Oldco, part of the Lendlease-led consortium that is building the new Western Sydney Stadium in Parramatta and redeveloping the Allianz Stadium next to the Sydney Cricket Ground, has gone into voluntary administration after involvement in buildings with combustible cladding.

Sporting largesse is undoubtedly good politics. But is doling out public money to elite sporting organisations the most judicious use of finite taxpayer money?

Arguably, underfunded grassroots sports would provide better value for money to encourage community participation, health and fitness.

Yet with a federal election looming, women's sport looks like the newest pork barrel.
Too true, add a touch of indigenous culture/wellbeing & the purses flop open ... cynical or just reality 2018 style, no change in sight.
:)
https://www.afc.com.au/news/2019-03-30/ceo-statement

Throw in another $15M here
 

Kwality

Brownlow Medallist
Aug 14, 2011
25,243
9,047
Tootgarook
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Renault F1
heard Bombers el presidente Lindsay Tanner talking up* further developing Tullamarine & looking to maintain Windy Hill, both admirable aims.
* one of the pregame radio stations here in Melbourne.

The former member of the Gillard kitchen cabinet is well versed in extracting taxpayer funds, the Feds & State Govts for Tulla & local govt for Windy Hill all on the hit list, go Bombers !!

Everyone got a mention, womens footy, community footy, indigenous kids & even the ordinary bloke.

Well done Lindsay & all purse holders will be guests of the club, again ?
 

Our Game

Club Legend
Sep 30, 2014
2,370
1,361
Sandringham
AFL Club
Geelong
Great to see the old dill Roy Masters having a whinge about AFLW receiving some decent funding.

AOC fears exodus of female talent as cash goes to professional codes
By Roy Masters
April 7, 2019 — 12.43pm

  • An exodus of female athletes to the professional football codes will follow the announcement of nearly $100 million in unpublicised grants in the recent Federal Budget, including $65m to clubs associated with AFLW, warns gold medal-winning Olympian Glynis Nunn.
“My issue is that the more that is spent for AFLW, that’s where the girls will go,” said Nunn, the first Australian to win a gold medal in track-and-field’s multi-skilled heptathlon event.


Up for grabs: The Federal budget awarded grants totalling $65m to clubs associated with the AFLW competition. CREDIT:AAP
The $65m given to AFL clubs Carlton, Richmond, Adelaide and the Brisbane Lions was part of
an $88m grant to football clubs that was not funnelled through Sport Australia and received almost zero publicity following last Tuesday’s budget.
While congratulating the Federal Government on providing $54m in pathway funding for young athletes, AOC chief executive Matt Carroll said: “This funding pales in comparison to the
$100m directly allocated to a handful of professional clubs in two football codes.”
 

NoobPie

Norm Smith Medallist
Sep 21, 2016
5,914
4,018
AFL Club
Collingwood
Great to see the old dill Roy Masters having a whinge about AFLW receiving some decent funding.

AOC fears exodus of female talent as cash goes to professional codes
By Roy Masters
April 7, 2019 — 12.43pm

  • An exodus of female athletes to the professional football codes will follow the announcement of nearly $100 million in unpublicised grants in the recent Federal Budget, including $65m to clubs associated with AFLW, warns gold medal-winning Olympian Glynis Nunn.
“My issue is that the more that is spent for AFLW, that’s where the girls will go,” said Nunn, the first Australian to win a gold medal in track-and-field’s multi-skilled heptathlon event.


Up for grabs: The Federal budget awarded grants totalling $65m to clubs associated with the AFLW competition. CREDIT:AAP
The $65m given to AFL clubs Carlton, Richmond, Adelaide and the Brisbane Lions was part of
an $88m grant to football clubs that was not funnelled through Sport Australia and received almost zero publicity following last Tuesday’s budget.
While congratulating the Federal Government on providing $54m in pathway funding for young athletes, AOC chief executive Matt Carroll said: “This funding pales in comparison to the
$100m directly allocated to a handful of professional clubs in two football codes.”
Roy Masters the go-to for anyone with a gripe against the AFL
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

telsor

Hall of Famer
Aug 29, 2004
31,776
29,571
Here
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Habs
It is curious that this hasn't had more play in the media though.

~$100M on women's sport in an election budget isn't something that wouldn't get pushed. Perhaps the Libs are saving the PR spin for the campaign.
 

Bostonian

Brownlow Medallist
Sep 9, 2015
12,528
11,890
AFL Club
Carlton
If definitely a mindset.

We're trying to secure funding for better facilities and most of the talk is about how the present facilities aren't fit for women.

Would be no funding potential if it was just male players involved.
 

Kwality

Brownlow Medallist
Aug 14, 2011
25,243
9,047
Tootgarook
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Renault F1
It is curious that this hasn't had more play in the media though.

~$100M on women's sport in an election budget isn't something that wouldn't get pushed. Perhaps the Libs are saving the PR spin for the campaign.
Interesting to see how either side try to use it, for every winner here .... lots of losers !!
 

Kwality

Brownlow Medallist
Aug 14, 2011
25,243
9,047
Tootgarook
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Renault F1
Great to see the old dill Roy Masters having a whinge about AFLW receiving some decent funding.

AOC fears exodus of female talent as cash goes to professional codes
By Roy Masters
April 7, 2019 — 12.43pm

  • An exodus of female athletes to the professional football codes will follow the announcement of nearly $100 million in unpublicised grants in the recent Federal Budget, including $65m to clubs associated with AFLW, warns gold medal-winning Olympian Glynis Nunn.
“My issue is that the more that is spent for AFLW, that’s where the girls will go,” said Nunn, the first Australian to win a gold medal in track-and-field’s multi-skilled heptathlon event.


Up for grabs: The Federal budget awarded grants totalling $65m to clubs associated with the AFLW competition. CREDIT:AAP
The $65m given to AFL clubs Carlton, Richmond, Adelaide and the Brisbane Lions was part of
an $88m grant to football clubs that was not funnelled through Sport Australia and received almost zero publicity following last Tuesday’s budget.
While congratulating the Federal Government on providing $54m in pathway funding for young athletes, AOC chief executive Matt Carroll said: “This funding pales in comparison to the
$100m directly allocated to a handful of professional clubs in two football codes.”
 

quotemokc

Brownlow Medallist
Jul 19, 2008
15,047
16,446
Perth
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Atlanta Falcons/Winnipeg Jets
Players almost always go where to money is if they can excel at multiple sports.

Being an Olympian doesn't earn you jack unless you are able to market yourself well.
 

jatz14

Norm Smith Medallist
Dec 13, 2011
7,015
7,681
WA
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Perth Glory W-League
Players almost always go where to money is if they can excel at multiple sports.

Being an Olympian doesn't earn you jack unless you are able to market yourself well.
Unless your in the top handful in the world, in a prominent event, you are not going to make jack sh*t, even if you are a good marketer. It amazes me that people get upset that someone who may have been a middling good heptathlete decides to play a sport with more rewards for them.
 

Top Bottom