Discussion Ducks best 20 players he's seen.

[St Kilda Death]

From SEN.
Below are Wayne Carey’s top 20 players:

1. Jason Dunstall
2. Michael Voss
3. James Hird
4. Tony Lockett
5. Chris Judd
6. Robert Harvey
7. Greg Williams
8. Lance Franklin
9. Gary Ablett Snr
10. Nathan Buckley
11. Mark Ricciuto
12. Adam Goodes
13. Glen Jakovich
14. Andrew McLeod
15. Dustin Martin
16. Jonathan Brown
17. Stephen Silvagni
18. Matthew Richardson
19. Gary Ablett Jnr
20. Paul Kelly

....
Dunstall at 1?
Dunstall over Plugger?
Judd over Harvey?
Brown/Cho over Roo?
No Roo?
No respect for junior either.

Am I a biased Saint or is this list trash?

 

[Keg on legs]

From SEN.
Below are Wayne Carey’s top 20 players:

1. Jason Dunstall
2. Michael Voss
3. James Hird
4. Tony Lockett
5. Chris Judd
6. Robert Harvey
7. Greg Williams
8. Lance Franklin
9. Gary Ablett Snr
10. Nathan Buckley
11. Mark Ricciuto
12. Adam Goodes
13. Glen Jakovich
14. Andrew McLeod
15. Dustin Martin
16. Jonathan Brown
17. Stephen Silvagni
18. Matthew Richardson
19. Gary Ablett Jnr
20. Paul Kelly

....
Dunstall at 1?
Dunstall over Plugger?
Judd over Harvey?
Brown/Cho over Roo?
No Roo?
No respect for junior either.

Am I a biased Saint or is this list trash?

At least Banger has a more rightful place amongst his contemporaries

How anyone ever rates Buckley above him is mindboggling

But yeah, plugger is number 1. And has Dunstall covered by a fair stretch

 

[Mowman]

From SEN.
Below are Wayne Carey’s top 20 players:

1. Jason Dunstall
2. Michael Voss
3. James Hird
4. Tony Lockett
5. Chris Judd
6. Robert Harvey
7. Greg Williams
8. Lance Franklin
9. Gary Ablett Snr
10. Nathan Buckley
11. Mark Ricciuto
12. Adam Goodes
13. Glen Jakovich
14. Andrew McLeod
15. Dustin Martin
16. Jonathan Brown
17. Stephen Silvagni
18. Matthew Richardson
19. Gary Ablett Jnr
20. Paul Kelly

....
Dunstall at 1?
Dunstall over Plugger?
Judd over Harvey?
Brown/Cho over Roo?
No Roo?
No respect for junior either.

Am I a biased Saint or is this list trash?

The list is trash just like the pig that made the list
Carey pfft scum

 

[triggering bro]

It’s not a bad list.

He’s more generous than most having Harvey at 6. Judd above him is no disrespect.

Brown was a great player however overrated due to premiership medals in his younger years. I’d have Roo & Pavlich above him.

Jackovich too high but chosen there because of his battles with Carey. Scarlett & Rance better defenders & players.

Ablett jnr & Dusty are too low. Dusty will be top 5 of all time when his career ends. Alongside Carey he is the most influential player I’ve watched.

There have been far better players than Paul Kelly over the last 30 years or however far back this top 20 goes.

Agree, Plugger should be ahead of Dunstall.

Kouta unlucky.

A top 20 is difficult. My top 5 would include Plugger, Dusty, Duck (I know he didn’t vote for himself), Ablett jnr & Goodes.

 

[plugger66]

His opinion. I don’t agree. No interest in having a go at his life outside of footy because some of us mightn’t agree.

 

[Mowman]

LOL

 

[Crusty Undies]

Anyone who doesn't have GAJ at one is out of their mind tbh. Once in a lifetime player. He won a brownlow in the absolute worst team in the league and he really should be the only 4 time winner. Best player to play the game and in the most competitive era to date.