Toast Duigan and Scotland

[murph4charlie]

Congrats to Scotland, gives his all week in week out - great to see him get the clubman award and fantastic to see Duigan get the best first year player, really added another dimension down back. Love his attack on the ball, amazing we got him for peanuts.

Three cheers for both

 

[Dramoth]

Congrats to both of the boys. Awesome to see Duigs get the nod when it could easily have been Laids who picked up the award.

Scotland had a pearler of a year and I reckon that he was robbed of an AA this year.

 

[Malifice]

Congrats to both of the boys. Awesome to see Duigs get the nod when it could easily have been Laids who picked up the award.

Scotland had a pearler of a year and I reckon that he was robbed of an AA this year.

Echo these sentiments.

 

[Bronx Bomber]

Great to see Scotto displaying the form that he did in 2011, IIRC it was last year or the year before that he was dropped to the VFL for a few games and it looked as though, to me anyway, that his career was coming to an end, the way he has not only managed to hang in their but be a fantastic contributor every week is a credit to the bloke.

 

[rampar]

The Top Ten in the 2011 John Nicholls Medal:
1st Marc Murphy 678
2nd Chris Judd 469
3rd Bryce Gibbs 448
4th Heath Scotland 408
5th Kade Simpson 376


Scotland and Simpson had better years than Gibbs. Congrats to both.

 

[Stamos]

3rd Bryce Gibbs 448
4th Heath Scotland 408
5th Kade Simpson 376


Scotland and Simpson had better years than Gibbs. Congrats to both.

How do you figure?

 

[Sublime]

The Top Ten in the 2011 John Nicholls Medal:
1st Marc Murphy 678
2nd Chris Judd 469
3rd Bryce Gibbs 448
4th Heath Scotland 408
5th Kade Simpson 376


Scotland and Simpson had better years than Gibbs. Congrats to both.

Top 10 seems to be lacking.....











You know, containing 10 people.

 

[rampar]

Well scotland was tough to miss out on all australian selection and I'm a biased fan of Simpson .

They both go when it is their turn and both have been smashed backing into contests. I'm not having a go a gibbs, just that I thought those two had better years.

cheers

ps the top 10 is a copy and paste from the website... i just copied the top 5.

 

[BlueJet]

How do you figure?

I agree with him,
they have greater impact week in week out for mine.

 

[Stamos]

Well scotland was tough to miss out on all australian selection and I'm a biased fan of Simpson .

They both go when it is their turn and both have been smashed backing into contests. I'm not having a go a gibbs, just that I thought those two had better years.

cheers

I agree with him,
they have greater impact week in week out for mine.

MC Votes say otherwise.

 

[BlueJet]

Obviously..
We were just giving our opinions on that.