I actually rate Dustin Martin very highly but i still said disagree because in order to say yes, that means you have to rate Dustin Martin equal or better to every single young player out there. I'd personally prefer Rioli, Hill and Hurley just off the top of my head.
I guess the question is what's a "young" player. Obviously guys drafted before him will have had a longer time to show more (Rioli, Hill, Hurley).
If the OP was more specific comparing Martin to guys from his draft or younger than that would be a more compelling case.
I think Martin will be a 250 game star, but Dee's fans would argue the same for their first two picks, as would any club, pretty sure the gold coast boys wouldn't trade Swallow either, etc etc.
I wouldn't trade Martin (as a tiger fan), but other clubs fans would argue the same thing so its fairly irrelevant. Let's just wait and see how good he'l be rather than pump up his tyres with words, I think Martin is the type of player where his performance will do the talking.