eagles many weak links

[west_eagle]

Hey eagles fans

Just interested in ur thoughts on some of the not so able eagles players.
We have some great youngsters coming up such as kerr, gasper cox and even gardiner is only obout 21 or 22.
And i cant forget the veterans such as matera Kemp and some of them.

But in the middle somewhere are people like wooden collica williams and players like that who need to stand up as the team needs every bit of help they can get

GIVE ME UR THOUGHTS PLEASE

amen

 

[jod23]

Hmm well i voted to keep Judge. I expected to have a bad year, maybe not this bad but more wins will come.

I think Wooden and pardon the pun, is dead Wood. Williams is very good, i think he has done quite well for us this year, he would be an automatic selection if i was the match committee. Collica i also rate highly, has played well down back and provided a bit of quickness and run off half back.

I think the players that really need to stand up and be counted right now are Fletcher, Jakovich, Braun and a few others.

 

[WCE2000]

Keep him, but maybe allow McKenna to have more of an impact on game day.

Judge has a very good eye for young talent, but for some reason, makes some very strange decisions on game day.

 

[Frodo]

Sack the incompetent guy NOW

 

[daddy_4_eyes]

I definately would like Judge to be kept on for his full term. However, i believe it is the eagles boards(not us, the directors ) duty to inform him that his attitude to the players and weird tactics will not be tolerated for long, and that his assistant coaches should be given a bigger role in the running of the team.

He is a great talent developer, and even though some people have mentioned that it is not his job to recruit, he might be great at teaching young players skills or how to get adjusted to AFL footy or whatever. So he will be vital in the eagles resuraction, and sacking him would be a mistake.

I do often critisize him, and rightfully so. He makes REALLY stupid decisions during matches. This is why i believe Wiley and McKenna should be given bigger roles in running the team.