EA's Early phantom Draft 2009 (top 6)

[Agetigers]

PP Melb- Scully
1# Melb- Butcher
2# Freo- Lucas
3# NM- Trengove
4# Rich- Martin
5# WC- Morabito

 

[bjlucas]

Pp#melb-tom scully
1#melb-jack trengrove
2#nm-john butcher
3#rich-koby stevens
4#frem-anthony morabito
5#wce-kane lucas
6#syd-nathan vardy

any thoughts

 

[enoenoeno]

Freo will take Trengrove if he is available, Morabito if not, as they both fit the style of player that Harvey is bringing into the squad

 

[Whispers]

Pp#melb-tom scully
1#melb-jack trengrove
2#nm-john butcher
3#rich-koby stevens
4#frem-anthony morabito
5#wce-kane lucas
6#syd-nathan vardy

any thoughts

I'm glad someone has finally thrown up Koby's name but not top three...

Vardy interesting at six. I reckon he will be first ruckman to go but more around the 10 - 14 pick.

 

[saladin]

if lucas could slip through to essendon (probably around pick 7 or 8 with the way we are falling away), i would be very happy.

 

[bjlucas]

if lucas could slip through to essendon (probably around pick 7 or 8 with the way we are falling away), i would be very happy.

Lucas won't slide that much cause i reckon that one of the WA sides will get him

 

[saladin]

Lucas won't slide that much cause i reckon that one of the WA sides will get him

doesn't seem likely, but then it might depend on what the wa sides are looking for. this time last year, rich was top two.

 

[Demonheart]

Pp#melb-tom scully
1#melb-jack trengrove
2#nm-john butcher
3#rich-koby stevens
4#frem-anthony morabito
5#wce-kane lucas
6#syd-nathan vardy

any thoughts

Looks good from Melbourne's perspective. Trengobe is really putting in some top preformances, Butcher will still go relatively early being the best KPP around. Stevens, Morabito & Lucas get to stay at home.

I personally really rate Lucas, no solid evidence to back it up, just a feeling I get when watching him play. I'd have him 3rd behind Scully and Trengove.

 

[Wizard]

Pick 1 & 2 are Melbournes after their loss and Fremantles win on the weekend.
Picks 3, 4 & 5 are a bit of a raffle now. Hopefully the skippes and tigers can win a game each to keep us in pick 3 calculations.

 

[Big Bad Buddy]

I Think the ladder will pan out like this:
1. PP Melbourne - T. Scully - Best Avab
2. Melbourne - J. Butcher - Take a quality foward to go with Jack Watts
3. Richmond - J. Trengrove - Next Best Midfielder
4. North Melbourne - A throw up between D.Martin and K.Stevens
5. Freo - A. Morabito - Freos man.
6. WCE - K.Lucas - Get there Local boy.

I can't see Melbourne winning any more games.
I have Freo beating Melbourne and Essendon 2 Matches that i see Freo winning.
I have Richmond losing to Collingwood, Hawks and WCE, Can't see richmond winning any more games this year.
I have North winning one more game which is this weeks game against WCE.
And i have WCE Beating Richmond.

 

[Trav 20]

I Think the ladder will pan out like this:
1. PP Melbourne - T. Scully - Best Avab
2. Melbourne - J. Butcher - Take a quality foward to go with Jack Watts
3. Richmond - J. Trengrove - Next Best Midfielder
4. North Melbourne - A throw up between D.Martin and K.Stevens
5. Freo - A. Morabito - Freos man.
6. WCE - K.Lucas - Get there Local boy.

I can't see Melbourne winning any more games.
I have Freo beating Melbourne and Essendon 2 Matches that i see Freo winning.

Back to the drawing board.

 

[FD2646]

Trav your team will still come last, but hey laugh it up and rub it in while you can - see ya at Subi next year when your guys go down by 60+

 

[Anjahads]

Trav your team will still come last, but hey laugh it up and rub it in while you can - see ya at Subi next year when your guys go down by 60+

What's people's thoughts on Gary Rohan?Possibly could go top 5 maybe?Sounds very promising

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

What's people's thoughts on Gary Rohan?Possibly could go top 5 maybe?Sounds very promising

Definate Top 5 I think

 

[King Hansen]

What's people's thoughts on Gary Rohan?Possibly could go top 5 maybe?Sounds very promising

yeah, sounds like a very good player and exciting, hopefully to the kangas with pick 5

 

[SugarHealey]

Ladder @ end of Rnd 21

Saints 21 19 2 0 76
Cats 21 17 4 0 68
Magpies 21 15 6 0 60
Bulldogs 21 14 7 0 56
Blues 21 13 8 0 52
Crows 21 13 8 0 52
Lions 21 12 8 1 50
Bombers 21 9 11 1 38
Hawks 21 9 12 0 36
Power 21 9 12 0 36
Swans 21 8 13 0 32
Eagles 21 7 14 0 28
Kangaroos 21 6 14 1 26
Dockers 21 6 15 0 24
Tigers 21 5 15 1 22
Demons 21 4 17 0 16