Player Watch Ed Allan

[Jelly Bean]

FFS with all this Ed Allan shite. He a Collingwood player and he's only a kid.
I'll keep backing him in.
Go and tell Fly he's not up to it.

You've been a huge vocal fan of Ed's all year FJ. Was it you that said you wouldn't trade him in a direct swap for Matt Rowell before the season started? Or was that someone else?

 

[JuniorB]

You've been a huge vocal fan of Ed's all year FJ. Was it you that said you wouldn't trade him in a direct swap for Matt Rowell before the season started? Or was that someone else?

I'm sticking fat with Fat.

 

[Fat Jesus]

You've been a huge vocal fan of Ed's all year FJ. Was it you that said you wouldn't trade him in a direct swap for Matt Rowell before the season started? Or was that someone else?

Someone else brother. Direct swap would be impossible. As much as I love Edward, that deal would be a win for us.

Rather keep Edward though. Good feeling about him. Get Butters instead. 555

 

[jmac70]

I think that would be a mistake because he’ll go to water in a finals environment. That’s not to say Lipinski is any better in the contest (and I’m tipping him to be the sub), but at least can be a difference maker by foot alongside his running. I fully respect that there’s people amongst us who will preach time I just don’t think we’re in that phase as a club.

I think Lipinski will get dropped. Steele or Pendles as sub with Allan to start.

 

[Rorzza]

Yeah, I'm in Allan's corner too. Obviously, to make Fly's team as a mid and you're not Nic, you need to be accountable at the source in congestion which Allan needs to work on....Allan's outside game is neat!

 

[TradeDraft]

He is a Massive Tease

Does the Odd Really Promising Thing but outside of that been Average at Best

 

[Sea fog]

Yeah, I'm in Allan's corner too. Obviously, to make Fly's team as a mid and you're not Nic, you need to be accountable at the source in congestion which Allan needs to work on....Allan's outside game is neat!

When he plays seniors they do not always look for him. Getting it to N and J Daicos seems to be the biggest priority,

 

[Granit1962]

When he plays seniors they do not always look for him. Getting it to N and J Daicos seems to be the biggest priority,

This is the problem with the last 6 weeks, kick a long bomb, get it to a Daicous, nothing else in the back pack. That changed in Q1 vs Crows and 4Q vs Dee’s.

 

[Rorzza]

Ed!

 

[TradeDraft]

 

[Rorzza]

Projection....Jet!

 

[FatherTime]

Let's be frank, he didn't have a lot of competition.

 

[Rorzza]

Let's be frank, he didn't have a lot of competition.

Yes, correct, being able to kick you would have thought was a primary skill for AFL, not anymore!

 

[granniewolf]

Harry Collier Trophy over the years

Year	Harry Collier Trophy winner
1927	Harry Rumney
1928	Bruce Andrew
1929	George Gibbs
1935	Bervin Woods
1936	Ron Dowling
1937	Des Fothergill
1960	Peter Rosenbrock
1961	John Mahon
1962	Mick Bone
1963	Terry Waters
1964	Paul Wadham
1965	Colin Tully
1966	Wayne Richardson
1967	Ross Dunne
1968	Denis O'Callaghan
1969	Max Richardson
1970	Peter Eakins
1971	Mike Delahunty
1972	Rod Oborne
1973	Paul Cranage
1974	Ray Shaw
1975	Andrew Ireland
1976	Chris Perry
1977	Ricky Barham
1978	Craig Stewart
1979	Denis Banks
1980	Terry Domburg
1981	Noel Lovell
1982	Chris Dalkin
1983	Phillip Walsh
1984	Darren Millane
1985	Gordon Sumner
1986	Dannie Seow
1987	Craig Starcevich
1988	Graham Wright
1989	Colin Alexander
1990	Tony Francis/ Scott Russell
1991	Paul Williams
1992	Mark Fraser
1993	Kent Butcher
1994	Jon Hassall
1995	Scott Burns
1996	Simon Prestigiacomo
1997	Mal Michael
1998	Clinton King
1999	Rupert Betheras
2000	Josh Fraser
2001	Ryan Lonie
2002	Jason Cloke
2003	Matthew Lokan
2004	Guy Richards
2005	Travis Cloke
2006	Dale Thomas
2007	Tyson Goldsack
2008	Nathan Brown
2009	Dayne Beams
2010	Jarryd Blair
2011	Alex Fasolo
2012	Jamie Elliott
2013	Josh Thomas
2014	Tom Langdon
2015	Jordan De Goey
2016	Josh Smith
2017	Callum Brown
2018	Jaidyn Stephenson
2019	John Noble
2020	Isaac Quaynor
2021	Oliver Henry
2022	Nick Daicos
2023	Jakob Ryan
2024	Joe Richards

 

[Kappa]

Harry Collier Trophy over the years

Year	Harry Collier Trophy winner
1927	Harry Rumney
1928	Bruce Andrew
1929	George Gibbs
1935	Bervin Woods
1936	Ron Dowling
1937	Des Fothergill
1960	Peter Rosenbrock
1961	John Mahon
1962	Mick Bone
1963	Terry Waters
1964	Paul Wadham
1965	Colin Tully
1966	Wayne Richardson
1967	Ross Dunne
1968	Denis O'Callaghan
1969	Max Richardson
1970	Peter Eakins
1971	Mike Delahunty
1972	Rod Oborne
1973	Paul Cranage
1974	Ray Shaw
1975	Andrew Ireland
1976	Chris Perry
1977	Ricky Barham
1978	Craig Stewart
1979	Denis Banks
1980	Terry Domburg
1981	Noel Lovell
1982	Chris Dalkin
1983	Phillip Walsh
1984	Darren Millane
1985	Gordon Sumner
1986	Dannie Seow
1987	Craig Starcevich
1988	Graham Wright
1989	Colin Alexander
1990	Tony Francis/ Scott Russell
1991	Paul Williams
1992	Mark Fraser
1993	Kent Butcher
1994	Jon Hassall
1995	Scott Burns
1996	Simon Prestigiacomo
1997	Mal Michael
1998	Clinton King
1999	Rupert Betheras
2000	Josh Fraser
2001	Ryan Lonie
2002	Jason Cloke
2003	Matthew Lokan
2004	Guy Richards
2005	Travis Cloke
2006	Dale Thomas
2007	Tyson Goldsack
2008	Nathan Brown
2009	Dayne Beams
2010	Jarryd Blair
2011	Alex Fasolo
2012	Jamie Elliott
2013	Josh Thomas
2014	Tom Langdon
2015	Jordan De Goey
2016	Josh Smith
2017	Callum Brown
2018	Jaidyn Stephenson
2019	John Noble
2020	Isaac Quaynor
2021	Oliver Henry
2022	Nick Daicos
2023	Jakob Ryan
2024	Joe Richards

Jakob Ryan????

 

[stormskye]

Jakob Ryan????

Callum brown in 2017
Fasolo 2011.. I had high hopes for him…

 

[Rorzza]

Wow...Nic Daicos won the same award!

 

[Granit1962]

High lights looked good - exactly what we need if he can continue to improve. A line breaking ‘bull’ (yes I know he has a long way to go on the bull department), yetI still have high hopes for Ed and feel he will continue to improve to be at least B to B+ player. Just a bit more of the bull please and no, not of the shit variety

 

[granniewolf]

Wow...Nic Daicos won the same award!

Denis Banks
Darren Millane
Craig Starcevich
Graham Wright
Tony Francis/Scott Russell
Winners from our 1990 Premiership team.

 

[domus]

I'm sticking fat with Fat.

I like him. I think he has shown great potential in his senior games, contrary to popular opinion.

 

[magpiewarrior]

Harry Collier Trophy over the years

Year	Harry Collier Trophy winner
1927	Harry Rumney
1928	Bruce Andrew
1929	George Gibbs
1935	Bervin Woods
1936	Ron Dowling
1937	Des Fothergill
1960	Peter Rosenbrock
1961	John Mahon
1962	Mick Bone
1963	Terry Waters
1964	Paul Wadham
1965	Colin Tully
1966	Wayne Richardson
1967	Ross Dunne
1968	Denis O'Callaghan
1969	Max Richardson
1970	Peter Eakins
1971	Mike Delahunty
1972	Rod Oborne
1973	Paul Cranage
1974	Ray Shaw
1975	Andrew Ireland
1976	Chris Perry
1977	Ricky Barham
1978	Craig Stewart
1979	Denis Banks
1980	Terry Domburg
1981	Noel Lovell
1982	Chris Dalkin
1983	Phillip Walsh
1984	Darren Millane
1985	Gordon Sumner
1986	Dannie Seow
1987	Craig Starcevich
1988	Graham Wright
1989	Colin Alexander
1990	Tony Francis/ Scott Russell
1991	Paul Williams
1992	Mark Fraser
1993	Kent Butcher
1994	Jon Hassall
1995	Scott Burns
1996	Simon Prestigiacomo
1997	Mal Michael
1998	Clinton King
1999	Rupert Betheras
2000	Josh Fraser
2001	Ryan Lonie
2002	Jason Cloke
2003	Matthew Lokan
2004	Guy Richards
2005	Travis Cloke
2006	Dale Thomas
2007	Tyson Goldsack
2008	Nathan Brown
2009	Dayne Beams
2010	Jarryd Blair
2011	Alex Fasolo
2012	Jamie Elliott
2013	Josh Thomas
2014	Tom Langdon
2015	Jordan De Goey
2016	Josh Smith
2017	Callum Brown
2018	Jaidyn Stephenson
2019	John Noble
2020	Isaac Quaynor
2021	Oliver Henry
2022	Nick Daicos
2023	Jakob Ryan
2024	Joe Richards

WOW 2012 Jamie Elliott.

 

[manicpie]

I think Ed will be a regular next year. As long as he has a good pre season

 

[JuniorB]

I think Ed will be a regular next year. As long as he has a good pre season

Has anyone seen a post by Fat recently?
I hope he's OK.

 

[manicpie]

Has anyone seen a post by Fat recently?
I hope he's OK.

He's having a bit of a sabbatical. He'll be back

 

[granniewolf]

Has anyone seen a post by Fat recently?
I hope he's OK.

Nope, maybe he's become bored with us. I think his posts have been gradually tapering off for some time.