EDFL Div 1 2019

[Turbos mail]

You do know that your club must refund you if you ask them for one - the EDFL indorse you doing so

What do you mean? Junior players don’t pay and usually coaches are admitted free..

 

[Turbos mail]

Yet again the EDFL get it wrong

Tullamarine Coach gets away with it just shows how the EDFL are soft and are a push over

Got a fine that was suspended
A club fine which is suspended
Got 6 weeks Suspended
And publicly apologie that the EDFL are going to write on his behalf that he has to sign

What a load of s**t either do something or leave coaches and clubs alone - if your going to make an example out of someone then hand this s**t down don’t bother wasting the clubs time

The bloke said what everyone was thinking and there was nothing they could do or would do they are soft and weak and need some one in charge that’s going to come down hard on players officials and clubs

They want to had out $250 fines for abusing umpires to supporters but do nothing when coach’s or officials say something lol

The EDFL are embarrassed by what occurred early season and would be silly to fine DC for his truthful comments. The EDFL will have egg all over there faces if EK get a top2 spot. It’s bloody embarrassing. Sack the lot of them.

Btw- It’s not supporters who get fined $250 its club officials who speak to umpires. Even this hasn’t been done properly to my knowledge. Show some courage and fine these idiot officials and any other official who is doing the wrong thing.

 

[Swans15]

Was told on the weekend both finals next week are at windy hill. Saturday and Sunday. Not sure how good the source though.

Greenvale 1st semi. Windy hill 2nd semi

 

[JDequed]

So unfortunately it's very much a possibility that East Keilors accidental 'cheating' of breaking the total player points may effect the finals.

If EK lose this week they could still get a top 2 spot from the % gained in those games. What an absolute joke. Let's hope they win, otherwise this is a big big stuff up by the EDFL. They should have the % removed of the games that they accidentally broke the rules in.

I think the best thing the EDFL can do is wipe the scores from those games that they were over but East Keilor still get the 4 points for the win. That is the only way that would seem fair to me, and then the issue can be put to rest.
TL lost by 135 points
Roxy lost by 185 points
Hillside by 16 points
OP by 123 points

If the EDFL did that, I can still understand that HS might be upset because those extra player points could've changed the result but the others teams that played against EK when they were over points at least don't get the % hit of those games.

Yes its still a slap on the wrist for EK but if ladder positions are decided later in the year and these games affect the % of teams that will cause a big big issue, and the whole thing will be brought back into the spotlight.

Keep the wins, wipe the FOR and AGAINST for both sides and lets move on.

EK 13-2 159.93 FOR 1716 AGAINST 1073
CBurn 12-3 171.27
Tulla 12-3 150.77

If you take out the % gained of the games that EK accidentally cheated in...
EK 13-2 120.98 FOR 1067 AGAINST 882
CB 12-3 171.27
Tulla 12-3 150.77

 

[Bissa3]

Greenvale 1st semi. Windy hill 2nd semi

One is an elimination Swan which game is where? Greenvale are at home next Saturday could only play there on Sunday. We might just be guessing EDFL may not know yet. Windy hill should be available both days next week no VFL will be there.

 

[Swans15]

One is an elimination Swan which game is where? Greenvale are at home next Saturday could only play there on Sunday. We might just be guessing EDFL may not know yet. Windy hill should be available both days next week no VFL will be there.

Sat windy hiill. Sunday Greenvale

 

[The Defender]

One is an elimination Swan which game is where? Greenvale are at home next Saturday could only play there on Sunday. We might just be guessing EDFL may not know yet. Windy hill should be available both days next week no VFL will be there.

Would they schedule Div 2 prelim at Windy Hill next weekend?

 

[Hugo Lloris]

Yet again the EDFL get it wrong

Tullamarine Coach gets away with it just shows how the EDFL are soft and are a push over

Got a fine that was suspended
A club fine which is suspended
Got 6 weeks Suspended
And publicly apologie that the EDFL are going to write on his behalf that he has to sign

What a load of s**t either do something or leave coaches and clubs alone - if your going to make an example out of someone then hand this s**t down don’t bother wasting the clubs time

The bloke said what everyone was thinking and there was nothing they could do or would do they are soft and weak and need some one in charge that’s going to come down hard on players officials and clubs

They want to had out $250 fines for abusing umpires to supporters but do nothing when coach’s or officials say something lol

Well said - spot on.. Joke of a competition

 

[Turbos mail]

Would they schedule Div 2 prelim at Windy Hill next weekend?

This is how they have done it in previous years. Personally don’t understand why but who knows what they think at league headquarters.

 

[Bissa3]

Would they schedule Div 2 prelim at Windy Hill next weekend?

Wouldn't think so, div 1 will get preference. Div 2 prelim likely at Coburg.

 

[nothingbut_thetruth]

The EDFL are embarrassed by what occurred early season and would be silly to fine DC for his truthful comments. The EDFL will have egg all over there faces if EK get a top2 spot. It’s bloody embarrassing. Sack the lot of them.

Btw- It’s not supporters who get fined $250 its club officials who speak to umpires. Even this hasn’t been done properly to my knowledge. Show some courage and fine these idiot officials and any other official who is doing the wrong thing.

Sorry but your wrong

The EDFL issued a warning to all clubs that officials players and SUPPORTERS would be issued fines

They would be sent to the club the club would have to pay it but supporters where told that they could cause there clubs getting fined !

 

[nothingbut_thetruth]

What do you mean? Junior players don’t pay and usually coaches are admitted free..

Talking about helpers if there ain’t enough tickets and parents that can not afford it

 

[Turbos mail]

Sorry but your wrong

The EDFL issued a warning to all clubs that officials players and SUPPORTERS would be issued fines

They would be sent to the club the club would have to pay it but supporters where told that they could cause there clubs getting fined !

Not true. How can they fine supporters. It was so Club respect the umpires.

 

[Newatthis]

Sorry but your wrong

The EDFL issued a warning to all clubs that officials players and SUPPORTERS would be issued fines

They would be sent to the club the club would have to pay it but supporters where told that they could cause there clubs getting fined !

So if you just want to go watch a game and you don’t support either club, how are they going to fine you and what they fine the club that they think you are supporting because you bag out the umpire...

 

[topheavy]

So if you just want to go watch a game and you don’t support either club, how are they going to fine you and what they fine the club that they think you are supporting because you bag out the umpire...

Or if you really hated a certain club, go dressed up in their colours and abuse the umpires...
I get the philosophy and applaud the EDFL for trying to stamp umpire bashing out of the game, but you can’t penalise the supporters.

 

[Sports_Support]

Well worth a read

The Teenage Tumble: Why Teenagers are Leaving Sport - New Sport

Kids everywhere are walking away from traditional competitive sports. The most rapid decline is seen in teenagers aged 15-16 years. Why the Teenage Tumble?

newsportfuture.com

 

[Snake_Baker]

Not true. How can they fine supporters. It was so Club respect the umpires.

How do you even prove than x person supports x club?

It's a ridiculous premise.

 

[Turbos mail]

How do you even prove than x person supports x club?

It's a ridiculous premise.

Yeah exactly. I guess the idea has some merit to try and get the message across and you would hope all clubs have had meetings with junior parents to explain this. But fines to supporters wouldn’t happen. However some club volunteer officials are out of control and blantanly trying to push boundaries.

-Runners constantly on the ground. Some are coaching.. The role of a runner is to give 1 coaches message, by going directly on and off. Not loitering on the ground. These idiots are ruining it..

-Club boundary umpires now a way to get an idiot parent on the ground running around talking to kids and at times umpires and opposition kids. Some in the middle of the ground. What happened to a young kid doing it for a pie & Coke or $10.

-Water person in the older grades. Yes some are doing it for the right reasons, however some see it as a way to get involved in the game.

 

[Oldtimesceptic]

Yeah exactly. I guess the idea has some merit to try and get the message across and you would hope all clubs have had meetings with junior parents to explain this. But fines to supporters wouldn’t happen. However some club volunteer officials are out of control and blantanly trying to push boundaries.

-Runners constantly on the ground. Some are coaching.. The role of a runner is to give 1 coaches message, by going directly on and off. Not loitering on the ground. These idiots are ruining it..

-Club boundary umpires now a way to get an idiot parent on the ground running around talking to kids and at times umpires and opposition kids. Some in the middle of the ground. What happened to a young kid doing it for a pie & Coke or $10.

-Water person in the older grades. Yes some are doing it for the right reasons, however some see it as a way to get involved in the game.

Main problems are that there are also a lot more parents that never played the game at any level themselves and live their lives through their kids careers.

 

[nothingbut_thetruth]

Not true. How can they fine supporters. It was so Club respect the umpires.

 

[Turbos mail]

View attachment 731983

So I agree that umpires at the junior levels shouldn’t have to wear abuse especially post game. Most likely by some weak minded individuals.

Employ security for umpires at these clubs and invoices those clubs to teach them a lesson. That will be more than $250.

 

[the horse whisper]

Oak park to debut Paul Pascu this Saturday. Brother and son of club legends Paul snr and Jack.
Still only 15 yr old.
Hopefully WC play in the spirit of the game this weekend

 

[Willow76]

Oak park to debut Paul Pascu this Saturday. Brother and son of club legends Paul snr and Jack.
Still only 15 yr old.
Hopefully WC play in the spirit of the game this weekend

Basically putting a target on him calling it out

 

[Newatthis]

View attachment 731983

Says officials, says nothing about spectators

 

[the horse whisper]

Basically putting a target on him calling it out

That’s a stupid comment. All I’m asking is to play footy hard but fair. No off the ball tactics which WC are known for in the past especially to young kids.
Plus if they do so anything I’d be watching out for big brother. He will go nuts.