EDFL moves

[Deefer4]

The ruckmen in the edfl are not great atm. The best ruckline would be at greenvale with bloomfield, garbutt and kent. And as much crap a Moonee Valley get they have good rucks too in Kemp and Donny. Abers rucks are ok too with that tall kid, farrely and no 2 (cant think of his name atm, the one at full foward thats about 6'6''). But apart from those clubs its lean picking for the ruckmen.

Peter Tatter, is the guy you cannot remember. Leigh Fishendon from Sunbury is Abers addition to their ruck last year. Tall, but ordinary skills.

 

[Aussie_dude]

Peter Tatter, is the guy you cannot remember. Leigh Fishendon from Sunbury is Abers addition to their ruck last year. Tall, but ordinary skills.

Agreed Fishendon is good in the tap, but is a little bit soft and doesnt do things around the ground. Much the same as tatters.

 

[Aussie_dude]

What do people think of this edfl top 10.

1. bloomfield- green
2. paxman- green
3. winter- strath
4. misiti- k. park
5. bicer- green
6. holman- strath
7. barnard- strath
8. dennis- abers
9. budge- green
10. chalmers- oak park

unlucky: whitmar- e keilor, glusenko- keil, long- keil, frazier- keil, weston- avondale (injured), cox- abers. maggorie- strath, hassel- green, Houcheour- keilor (injured)

 

[Grandale]

What do people think of this edfl top 10.

1. bloomfield- green
2. paxman- green
3. winter- strath
4. misiti- k. park
5. bicer- green
6. holman- strath
7. barnard- strath
8. dennis- abers
9. budge- green
10. chalmers- oak park

unlucky: whitmar- e keilor, glusenko- keil, long- keil, frazier- keil, weston- avondale (injured), cox- abers. maggorie- strath, hassel- green, Houcheour- keilor (injured)

I'd have Bicer top three.

 

[rioli brownlow]

I'd have Bicer top three.

long is a reciever very overrated(thinks he is a pretty boy of the comp), hope that isn't the 2006 list cause there will be no misiti or chalmers.

 

[Dwight]

I'd have Bicer top three.

is bicer any good? Describe him? Where is he playing in 2006?

 

[Grandale]

is bicer any good? Describe him? Where is he playing in 2006?

Absolute gun goalkicking rover. Was the catalyst behind Greenvale final-quarter resurgence in this year's Grand Final.
I assume he's lining up for the Jets again.

 

[blues12]

Unfortunately there are very few quality ruckman in the EDFL. In fact, I don't think there's one.

Probably 4-5 years back there was Eaton from Airport West, Cuffy at Keilor and Winkel at Doutta Stars. These guys were Ruck Rovers rather than tap ruckman though.

I believe Cuffy had a knee reco mid year and is thinking about playing back at keilor next year is the man still upto it. or is he past his use by date

 

[tige19]

I'd have Bicer top three.

Bicer is a gun, however i wouldnt have Bloomfield in my top 300, if he is the best player running around in the EDFL then the league is complete utter crap. Bloomfield would struggle to get senior games in the O&M,GV,EFL,GFL.

EDFL top 10:

1.Paxman (Green)
2.Winter (Strath)
3.Haoucher (Keil)
4.Bicer (Green)
5.Dennis (Abers)
6.Misiti (KP)
7.Budge (Green)
8.Laverde (Doutta)
9.Turbo (Oak)
10.Weston (AH)

 

[Deefer4]

Bicer is a gun, however i wouldnt have Bloomfield in my top 300, if he is the best player running around in the EDFL then the league is complete utter crap. Bloomfield would struggle to get senior games in the O&M,GV,EFL,GFL.

EDFL top 10:

1.Paxman (Green)
2.Winter (Strath)
3.Haoucher (Keil)
4.Bicer (Green)
5.Dennis (Abers)
6.Misiti (KP)
7.Budge (Green)
8.Laverde (Doutta)
9.Turbo (Oak)
10.Weston (AH)

Have seen a few O&M games and GV games in 2005, and whilst I am not a fan of Bloomfield, he would walk into Wang Rovers, Yarrawonga, Corowa-Rutherglen, Raiders at a minimum. Also into Most GV teams. Sorry tige19, the guy playing in the ruck for Yarrawonga, is in line for the pension and sadly lacking in skills. Have you seen the O&M in 2005?
Laverde, not a top ten. Got under the radar early, but needs more than one season to convince me that he is up to that mark.

 

[roge_3]

I believe Cuffy had a knee reco mid year and is thinking about playing back at keilor next year is the man still upto it. or is he past his use by date

If his knee comes up, could Jamie and his body handle a season in top grade EDFL?

 

[tige19]

Have seen a few O&M games and GV games in 2005, and whilst I am not a fan of Bloomfield, he would walk into Wang Rovers, Yarrawonga, Corowa-Rutherglen, Raiders at a minimum. Also into Most GV teams. Sorry tige19, the guy playing in the ruck for Yarrawonga, is in line for the pension and sadly lacking in skills. Have you seen the O&M in 2005?
Laverde, not a top ten. Got under the radar early, but needs more than one season to convince me that he is up to that mark.

Yeah mate your probably on the ball with the O&M, as i didnt see any games or any teams plsy this year it would be hard tell, im just going by what is said from guys who play in the league and they seem to think that the standard is very similiur to GV.

Bloomfield would struggle in the GV, the grounds are alot bigger and the game is alot more free flowing than the EDFL. He is slow and doesnt have great fitness, is also about 15kgs overweight so i would really struggle to see him have any sort of impact in the league. Bloomfield would get dominated by the likes of Kirby (in fairness is the interleague ruckman though).

On Laverde, i rate the guy, played around 3 seasons against him and always thought he had class. Maybe if he was that tad quicker and had more of an X factor he would have gone further than VFL scoobies. Laverde is a good version of the GV footballer.

cheers

 

[gazza12]

any news if the williamstown boys will be fronting up at douttas again
next year laverde,knight,ramsey etc

 

[Deefer4]

If his knee comes up, could Jamie and his body handle a season in top grade EDFL?

Could be handy sitting in the goal square!

 

[caveman]

Guys, I am looking at making an EDFL website that is for us supporters and have a place dedicated just to the EDFL. Does someone know where I can get all the team logos or can someone please help me by drawing up all the jumpers.

I think the team jumpers or logos will be great on the website but I need help.

Thanks

 

[Aussie_dude]

Yeah mate your probably on the ball with the O&M, as i didnt see any games or any teams plsy this year it would be hard tell, im just going by what is said from guys who play in the league and they seem to think that the standard is very similiur to GV.

Bloomfield would struggle in the GV, the grounds are alot bigger and the game is alot more free flowing than the EDFL. He is slow and doesnt have great fitness, is also about 15kgs overweight so i would really struggle to see him have any sort of impact in the league. Bloomfield would get dominated by the likes of Kirby (in fairness is the interleague ruckman though).

On Laverde, i rate the guy, played around 3 seasons against him and always thought he had class. Maybe if he was that tad quicker and had more of an X factor he would have gone further than VFL scoobies. Laverde is a good version of the GV footballer.

cheers

Tige,

your info is outdated. I know that you are a massive GVFL fan so ill excuse you for any mistakes. Bloomfield is not the shaddow of the player he once was. He has improved remarkedly. To say he wouldnt get a game for any local side is a joke. He is currently training for the essendon rookie list squad. He will be playing VFL firsts next year, not as a rookie, no doubt about it. I watch alot of edfl. Adam i know you are an old coburg head but Rarbee is not in the top 10 edfl players. He once was but now he is not.

Laverde= good player. not great just good.

Also Knight and Gathercole have left Doutta Stars

 

[The Big Pineapple]

Tige,

your info is outdated. I know that you are a massive GVFL fan so ill excuse you for any mistakes. Bloomfield is not the shaddow of the player he once was. He has improved remarkedly. To say he wouldnt get a game for any local side is a joke. He is currently training for the essendon rookie list squad. He will be playing VFL firsts next year, not as a rookie, no doubt about it. I watch alot of edfl. Adam i know you are an old coburg head but Rarbee is not in the top 10 edfl players. He once was but now he is not.

Laverde= good player. not great just good.

Also Knight and Gathercole have left Doutta Stars

Ausie dude,

Take your head out of your arse, your word is not gospel.

 

[Aussie_dude]

Ausie dude,

Take your head out of your arse, your word is not gospel.

What part of my post do you disagree with. everything i said was true

 

[gazza12]

thanks aussie dude knight and gathercole will be big losses is laverde
staying?

 

[bomber5]

Xavier Codd from Pascoe Vale Panthers to Strathmore, filling the void at Half Bank Flank

Interesting to know extactly which void Codd will be filling in the Strathmore backline, given that the Mores Back 6 were clearly the best defence in the EDFL this year and some might say, led them to a grand final.

 

[gazza12]

maybe he will be the general of the reserves backline

 

[bomber5]

Bicer is a gun, however i wouldnt have Bloomfield in my top 300, if he is the best player running around in the EDFL then the league is complete utter crap. Bloomfield would struggle to get senior games in the O&M,GV,EFL,GFL.

EDFL top 10:

1.Paxman (Green)
2.Winter (Strath)
3.Haoucher (Keil)
4.Bicer (Green)
5.Dennis (Abers)
6.Misiti (KP)
7.Budge (Green)
8.Laverde (Doutta)
9.Turbo (Oak)
10.Weston (AH)

Agree with Bloomfield not being in the top 10. I'm hoping that your non inclusion of Grant Holman in the Leagues Top 10 was an oversight. He is clearly one of the best players going round. 2005 League Medal winner and had a great finals series with the Mores. Haoucher is not in the top 10, Fraser is a much more important player in their line up.

 

[tige19]

Tige,

your info is outdated. I know that you are a massive GVFL fan so ill excuse you for any mistakes. Bloomfield is not the shaddow of the player he once was. He has improved remarkedly. To say he wouldnt get a game for any local side is a joke. He is currently training for the essendon rookie list squad. He will be playing VFL firsts next year, not as a rookie, no doubt about it. I watch alot of edfl. Adam i know you are an old coburg head but Rarbee is not in the top 10 edfl players. He once was but now he is not.

Laverde= good player. not great just good.

Also Knight and Gathercole have left Doutta Stars

Mate you have no idea what so ever, you make your self look like an out and out tossa with what you say.

There is no chance in this world that Essendon or ANY VFL club would ever list Bloomfield. For starters he is overweight badly, he is not tall enough to hold down a ruck position and is not mobile enough to play KPP againts athletic quick KPP.

Mate refrain your self from talking complete nonsense ok, you lose credability very quickly on here and if i was you since you i would want to keep a hold of what credability you have left if any at all.

On Doutta Stars they look likely to sign Heath Lawry from Williamstown and possibly 2 ex Coburg Tiger lads in Jason Dorazio and Alan Faraj. I believe that Dorazio will sign with a country club in the GV if Douttas dont make a descent offer. Terry Knight will play with Southport next season but i have no idea about Gathercole.

cheers

 

[caveman]

Guys I have just made a webpage dedicated to the EDFL. Can you guys have a look and let me know what you think. It is in its early stages but I have setup a forum just for EDFL!

Address is http://au.geocities.com/edflfooty/

Look forward to your comments.

 

[Aussie_dude]

Mate you have no idea what so ever, you make your self look like an out and out tossa with what you say.

There is no chance in this world that Essendon or ANY VFL club would ever list Bloomfield. For starters he is overweight badly, he is not tall enough to hold down a ruck position and is not mobile enough to play KPP againts athletic quick KPP.

Mate refrain your self from talking complete nonsense ok, you lose credability very quickly on here and if i was you since you i would want to keep a hold of what credability you have left if any at all.

cheers

Yet he is training with the essendon rookie list.