EDFL Premier Discussion 2025

[callmecrazy]

How about the Flag this year?

And relegation now that EK is out Greenvale finished 9th and Hillside are in premier?

 

[The Longblow]

Deer Park. Lock arms and cross check. Ready for take off. You heard it here first....

 

[torpfrom50]

How about the Flag this year?

As per above it will come from the same 3 / 4

 

[torpfrom50]

20+ years of premiers
Greenvale 4 but are now on a drought
Strathmore 6 + 1 Covid Cup, but dont win it or you'll get the lemonade and sars
Keilor 4, was 5, busted cheating, nothing to see here, chasing the western suburbs best 16 yr olds
Marby 2, but been to Div 1 since and look to be moving back to being competitive
Aberfeldie 3 - money doesn't guarantee you anything

2004	Greenvale
2005	Strathmore
2006	Strathmore
2007	Greenvale
2008	Keilor
2009	Maribyrnong Park
2010	Maribyrnong Park
2011	Strathmore
2012	Greenvale
2013	Greenvale
2014	Strathmore
2015	Aberfeldie
2016	Keilor
2017	Aberfeldie
2018	Aberfeldie
2019	Keilor
2021	Strathmore
2022	Strathmore
2023	BUSTED and REMOVED
2024	Keilor
2025	Strathmore

 

[callmecrazy]

Pascoe Vale seem like steaming ahead wit another BIG signing announcement last night. I have heard that Stillman and his mate Ranno are heading to Greenvale. Pascoe Vale would now be premiership contenders for sure.

 

[Pick it up]

Pascoe Vale seem like steaming ahead wit another BIG signing announcement last night. I have heard that Stillman and his mate Ranno are heading to Greenvale. Pascoe Vale would now be premiership contenders for sure.

Another 3 point player whilst losing 2 X 1 point players.. Unless they plan on playing with 55 points they wont be playing finals.

 

[callmecrazy]

Another 3 point player whilst losing 2 X 1 point players.. Unless they plan on playing with 55 points they wont be playing finals.

Very handy players if the list remains healthy. Where do you think they will finish up then? and how will the bottom half fair end of year?

6	Essendon Doutta Stars (SM)
7	Maribyrnong Park (SM)
8	Pascoe Vale (SM) replaced by Airport West
9	Greenvale (SM)
10	Hillside (SM)

 

[callmecrazy]

Very handy players if the list remains healthy. Where do you think they will finish up then? and how will the bottom half fair end of year?

6	Essendon Doutta Stars (SM)
7	Maribyrnong Park (SM)
8	Pascoe Vale (SM) replaced by Airport West
9	Greenvale (SM)
10	Hillside (SM)

Other than Pasco can you see any of these in the top 5?

 

[Gremlin77]

Other than Pasco can you see any of these in the top 5?

Probably won’t be much between Airport West, Douttas, Deer Park, Marby and Pascoe Vale and likely fight for 2 finals spots. Would expect the big 3 to be a lock for finals, then Greenvale, daylight, Hillside.

Deer Park & Pacco using the same strategy $$$, stacking top end with loaded points and gambling they’ll have enough one pointers good enough not to be exposed.

Marby, APW & EDS going a more sustainable model and attempting to build slowly with honegrowns and retention.

Might take Rocky a year or 2 at Greenvale to build a strong enough list to compete for finals. Gun coach though.

 

[callmecrazy]

Probably won’t be much between Airport West, Douttas, Deer Park, Marby and Pascoe Vale and likely fight for 2 finals spots. Would expect the big 3 to be a lock for finals, then Greenvale, daylight, Hillside.

Deer Park & Pacco using the same strategy $$$, stacking top end with loaded points and gambling they’ll have enough one pointers good enough not to be exposed.

Marby, APW & EDS going a more sustainable model and attempting to build slowly with homegrowns and retention.

Might take Rocky a year or 2 at Greenvale to build a strong enough list to compete for finals. Gun coach though.

Good call Gremlin77 Rock good for the club and he's got work to do. Greenvale has been losing good local players for 2-3 years and lacked local depth from an aging team. Hillside have actually lost Covelli and Whynam to Tullamarine, it'll be tough to compete out of 10th spot. I guess the list will be more visible over the next 2-3 weeks and see who has moved where that remains under wraps. It'll be tighter for 4th and 5th spots than top 3

 

[Pick it up]

Very handy players if the list remains healthy. Where do you think they will finish up then? and how will the bottom half fair end of year?

6	Essendon Doutta Stars (SM)
7	Maribyrnong Park (SM)
8	Pascoe Vale (SM) replaced by Airport West
9	Greenvale (SM)
10	Hillside (SM)

5th,6th or 7th. Douttas may come in, they've built a very good young list.

 

[FootyNuff123]

Is Abers still a certainty for top 3 with the losses of Moore and Newman?

 

[fair crack]

Pascoe Vale seem like steaming ahead wit another BIG signing announcement last night. I have heard that Stillman and his mate Ranno are heading to Greenvale. Pascoe Vale would now be premiership contenders for sure.

Why would they want to leave Pasco vale now? Finals contenders at this stage. Greenvale will struggle to make any impact you would think.
Stillman getting on, they should get a few 23-24 year olds to recruit for the next few years.
Thoughts ??

 

[Gremlin77]

Is Abers still a certainty for top 3 with the losses of Moore and Newman?

No, they might not be. Heard they have picked up 2 quality players this week yet to be announced but Paea I believe is back at VFL, Middleton gone and JLV gone to Banyule. They have depth and will heaps of points to bring more in, which they will.

 

[chickenonachain]

Pascoe Vale seem like steaming ahead wit another BIG signing announcement last night. I have heard that Stillman and his mate Ranno are heading to Greenvale. Pascoe Vale would now be premiership contenders for sure.

Mate Pacco have been doing this for years and what’s it got them nothing. 5/6 players left last year at least 5/7 players leaving this year what does that tell you?

 

[callmecrazy]

Why would they want to leave Pasco vale now? Finals contenders at this stage. Greenvale will struggle to make any impact you would think.
Stillman getting on, they should get a few 23-24 year olds to recruit for the next few years.
Thoughts ??

they do have an aging list of players and i agree needs young blood recruiting quickly. from what they have lost last 2 years and this year, they need many more players and no different to Pasco APW and Doutta which they seem to be recruiting well.

 

[jessop]

Deer Park. Lock arms and cross check. Ready for take off. You heard it here first....

Too many departures,lucky if they make the 5

 

[Turbos mail]

Pacco with another good one by the looks. Gee they are going hard.

 

[callmecrazy]

Pacco with another good one by the looks. Gee they are going hard.

I see another signing post last night a 22 yr old from the country with high credentials

 

[fair crack]

I see another signing post last night a 22 yr old from the country with high credentials

Apparently related to the coach cousin/nephew or something.

 

[weapons#again]

No, they might not be. Heard they have picked up 2 quality players this week yet to be announced but Paea I believe is back at VFL, Middleton gone and JLV gone to Banyule. They have depth and will heaps of points to bring more in, which they will.

Correct 2 quality signings

2 hunt boys ex Willy and Footscray vfl players posted on socials

 

[The Sandman]

Goldstein links to Pascoe Vale, very good mates with coach Daniel Harris

Daniel Harris

Age

43

Ht

180cm

Wt

82kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

16.9

4star

K

7.7

3star

HB

9.2

5star

M

2.9

3star

T

4.0

5star

CL

4.2

5star

No current season stats available

D

10.2

3star

K

7.8

3star

HB

2.4

3star

M

0.8

1star

T

2.2

4star

, obviously they played together at North but still remain close allies . Goldstein and Dennis as a ruck/resting Forward combo would be unstoppable. Imagine coming up against the Record leader of the most tapouts in the AFL and another ruckman who gets 30 disposals a game.

 

[Shinboner Supremacy]

Goldstein links to Pascoe Vale, very good mates with coach Daniel Harris, obviously they played together at North but still remain close allies . Goldstein and Dennis as a ruck/resting Forward combo would be unstoppable. Imagine coming up against the Record leader of the most tapouts in the AFL and another ruckman who gets 30 disposals a game.

Twin towers