Brodie has always been my boy at #1.
We need a Cripps-type prolific clearance-winning inside midfielder and Brodie is exactly that. Parish, Merrett, Heppell... yeah these guys can win the contested ball when called upon, but it isn't the hallmark of any of their games. We need a bustling clearance specialist to replace Jobe and Brodie looks to be the perfect candidate. Inside mids are the best players in the game (Dangerfield, Ablett, Fyfe, Selwood, Kennedy, Sloane all noted contested ball winners) and also the safest draft choices in my opinion. Think Brodie will be able to better translate his game to the AFL than McCluggage and will also be ready to play senior games quicker than most other draftees (potentially from Round 1 2017 even).
Draft watchers will know better, but unless McCluggage has shown a serious aptitude for winning the contested ball and isn't just a flashy outside type, then I'd be going for Brodie.