RossFC
Moderator
- Joined
- May 23, 2012
- Posts
- 97,312
- Reaction score
- 157,610
- Location
- Alberton Oval
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, MetroStars
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

It looks like the least appealing Saturday night game of the season on paper.Sunday 7am is primetime viewing. Love it.
Should be pumping Wolves.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Marquee Game of the Week:
I feel like everyone says this about their club.Handing Wolves their first win of the season would be the most Arsenal thing I've ever seen just quietly
Spoken like a Spurs fan.Handing Wolves their first win of the season would be the most Arsenal thing I've ever seen just quietly
Not everyone's club is known as Bottlers FC in all fairnessI feel like everyone says this about their club.
No, but I wager almost every fanbase would bemoan slipping up against weak sides as "typical them". There's typical city, doctor Tottenham, etc that all come up. End of the day losing to bad sides happens, but I don't think you'll be losing to wolvesNot everyone's club is known as Bottlers FC in all fairness
True.No, but I wager almost every fanbase would bemoan slipping up against weak sides as "typical them". There's typical city, doctor Tottenham, etc that all come up. End of the day losing to bad sides happens, but I don't think you'll be losing to wolves
True.
Geelong supporters insist that we drop games to terrible opposition semi-regularly and most seasons there's very little truth to it.

Not really. We have less talent on the list than Brisbane currently. Talent-wise it's recognised that we can hold our own against most clubs. Our consistency over 15 seasons largely comes down to Scott and his support staff, yes.Geelong supporters also claim your list is bottom 4 and only Chris Scott’s genius coaching sees you finish top 4 regularly.
![]()
Not really. We have less talent on the list than Brisbane currently. Talent-wise it's recognised that we can hold our own against most clubs. Our consistency over 15 seasons largely comes down to Scott and his support staff, yes.
So it's not a ridiculous thing for Geelong supporters to say? Nobody is saying that West Coast has a better list. But it is true that usually 1-3 clubs have a bit more firepower and depth. If they didn't, Geelong would have 5+ flags under Scott. Brisbane 2024-2025, Richmond 2017-2020 and Hawthorn 2013-2014 in particular had stronger teams, that's all.Every club in the competition has less talent than Brisbane tbf.
So it's not a ridiculous thing for Geelong supporters to say? Nobody is saying that West Coast has a better list. But it is true that usually 1-3 clubs have a bit more firepower and depth. If they didn't, Geelong would have 5+ flags under Scott. Brisbane 2024-2025, Richmond 2017-2020 and Hawthorn 2013-2014 in particular had stronger teams, that's all.
I agree with this, Geelong always has a handful of guys who if drafted by us or another club would have been delisted already and they squeeze a use out of themNot really. We have less talent on the list than Brisbane currently. Talent-wise it's recognised that we can hold our own against most clubs. Our consistency over 15 seasons largely comes down to Scott and his support staff, yes.
Keeping a list top 4/6 worthy for 15 years will usually come down to coaching and management. Especially in the AFL. In the PL money comes into it a lot more, unless you're modern-day Man United.Your list is good enough to make top 4/6 every year and you do.