Recommitted Eric Mackenzie

[eDPS]

I saw somewhere possibly Twitter via SEN that a straight swap for Luenberger was on the cards.

No way in hell would Essendon do that or would Leunberger want to. Stupid Denham had the idea what an idiot.

 

[Suma Magic]

Third rounder enough?

He's contracted so I don't think so.

 

[luckysaint48]

He's contracted so I don't think so.

What about with a swap of firsts as well?

 

[Suma Magic]

What about with a swap of firsts as well?

I think we will want to keep him to be honest.

I think brown will leave, meaning that Mackenzie would be our only KPD outside of Gov, Schofield and Barrass.

 

[coxy149]

I think we will want to keep him to be honest.

I think brown will leave, meaning that Mackenzie would be our only KPD outside of Gov, Schofield and Barrass.

Surely brown will stay, doesn't his missus play netball or something in WA?

 

[Suma Magic]

Surely brown will stay, doesn't his missus play netball or something in WA?

They have netty teams in other states. I'd say it would be more likely that they would want to stay because they like Perth, rather than due to a lack of opportunities for her elsewhere.

 

[blueiris]

Surely brown will stay, doesn't his missus play netball or something in WA?

There's a great Netball team in Queensland Brisbane could do with Mitch Brown

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

There's a great Netball team in Queensland Brisbane could do with Mitch Brown

After you gave us that dud Redden give us the same pick back then

 

[blueiris]

After you gave us that dud Redden give us the same pick back then

Free agent mate you got Yeo for basically nothing so you shouldn't really complain

 

[bUCKET__]

Free agent mate you got Yeo for basically nothing so you shouldn't really complain

Did you see him play last night? Or at all this year? Looking more and more like a fair trade, Yeo for Lewy Taylor...

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

Free agent mate you got Yeo for basically nothing so you shouldn't really complain

We could of given you 32 but ended up being nice and giving you 28.
That was a fair trade at the time. WCE never hammer oppo clubs when we have a chance to.
Wish we would.
I had my worries last year we where way over paying for Redden like we did.
Being dropped my Leppa should of been a signal for us, not to overpay.
We got burnt big time.
That has to be one of the worst trades in the last 5 years.

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

There's a great Netball team in Queensland Brisbane could do with Mitch Brown

Hand over pick 24 then
And we will give you 49 and Mitch Brown.
Or we give you Eric straight for pick 20.

 

[Sweet Jesus]

Did you see him play last night? Or at all this year? Looking more and more like a fair trade, Yeo for Lewy Taylor...

Did WC trade out Lewis Taylor?

 

[Sweet Jesus]

Hand over pick 24 then
And we will give you 49 and Mitch Brown.
Or we give you Eric straight for pick 20.

Why are you acting like you actually do the deals?

 

[blueiris]

Hand over pick 24 then
And we will give you 49 and Mitch Brown.
Or we give you Eric straight for pick 20.

What part of he's a free agent are you missing? Brisbane wouldn't have to give up anything to get Mitch Brown if we are interested in him

 

[Obeanie1]

No way in hell would Essendon do that or would Leunberger want to. Stupid Denham had the idea what an idiot.

Agreed that sounds silly. Unless Leu has injury issues or has some desperate need to head back to WA.

Very, very strange.

 

[Obeanie1]

Free agent mate you got Yeo for basically nothing so you shouldn't really complain

And what has Yeo delivered? Very inconsistent and failed in finals.

Pick 28 isn't nothing, it landed you Taylor.

I'd be happy to send Yeo back for pick 28 or Taylor.

 

[Obeanie1]

Third rounder enough?

Not when he's contracted.

 

[bUCKET__]

Did WC trade out Lewis Taylor?

The general point of the comment was that Lions weren't completely ripped off in trading Yeo, as what they brought in with the pick they got looks around the mark of what Yeo can bring.

This was merely implied though, and left out many details of what actually happened. Luckily you were able to make such an astute observation and ask a clarifying question. Apologies if this wasn't phrased in a literal enough manner for you to comprehend though. I know you often desire that things are spelled out explicitly. It is wonderful that your meaningful contributions to trade discussions continue to be augmented by such an inquisitive attitude to the finer details of discussion. You have surely saved a lot of confusion here. Good work!

 

[Kram]

Not when he's contracted.

He also can't get a game at WC and played poorly in the 2nds.

 

[bodazoka]

We wouldnt trade him for anything outside a late first.

Worth more on our list than a pick in the thirties

 

[JG22]

We wouldnt trade him for anything outside a late first.

Worth more on our list than a pick in the thirties

That's unrealistic.
2nd the best you would get

 

[DAWESOME!!]

If I've figured correctly, our second pick would be around pick 25. Would that get a deal for McKenzie across the line?

 

[Kram]

If I've figured correctly, our second pick would be around pick 25. Would that get a deal for McKenzie across the line?

They would be stupid not to take that. He's looked very, very ordinary since coming back from injury.

 

[DAWESOME!!]

They would be stupid not to take that. He's looked very, very ordinary since coming back from injury.

Haven't seen much of him this year, hence the question.

Ok, so then the offer is pick 43!