monty1104
Premium Platinum
The fact he is still seen as a fringe player would set alarm bells ringing.
Opinion Essendon's 2013 List: Will/Won't Make It
- Thread starter Kong
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Banned
- #52
Agree Donsman... at the moment we have 15 guys fighting for about 6 spots in the 'bottom 16-22' and a guy like Baguley is going to be an excellent pick up (I think) to fill a need/gap for short term.. but not likely to turn that into a permanent position.. and that is the point of the list.. to put your thoughts out there.
Doug Tassell
Debutant
Some of you have never been to the footy have you?
- May 25, 2009
- 1,974
- 738
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Melb City, Man City, NY Giants
1 Michael Hibberd
2 Tom Bellchambers
3 Scott Gumbleton
4 Jobe Watson
5 Brent Stanton
6 Joe Daniher
7 Leroy Jetta
8 Jason Winderlich
9 Brendon Goddard
10 Nick O'Brien
11 David Zaharakis
12 Stewart Crameri (huge call but I think this could be the last big year for Stew if Gumby, Jo and NO'B come good)
14 Jason Ashby
15 Courtenay Dempsey
16 Tayte Pears
17 Jake Melksham
18 Michael Hurley
19 David Hille
20 Jackson Merrett
21 Dyson Heppell
22 Jake Carlisle
23 David Myers
24 Alex Browne
26 Cale Hooker
27 Luke Davis
28 Elliott Kavanagh
29 Alwyn Davey
30 Paddy Ryder
31 Dustin Fletcher
32 Travis Colyer
33 Dylan Van Unen
34 Kyle Hardingham
35 Martin Gleeson
37 Sean Gregory
38 Nicholas Kommer
39 Heath Hocking
40 Ben Howlett
41 Will Hams
42 Nathan Lovett-Murray
46 Mark Baguley
25 Ariel Steinberg
36 Lauchlan Dalgleish
45 Hal Hunter
47 Cory Dell'Olio
2 Tom Bellchambers
3 Scott Gumbleton
4 Jobe Watson
5 Brent Stanton
6 Joe Daniher
7 Leroy Jetta
8 Jason Winderlich
9 Brendon Goddard
10 Nick O'Brien
11 David Zaharakis
12 Stewart Crameri (huge call but I think this could be the last big year for Stew if Gumby, Jo and NO'B come good)
14 Jason Ashby
15 Courtenay Dempsey
16 Tayte Pears
17 Jake Melksham
18 Michael Hurley
19 David Hille
20 Jackson Merrett
21 Dyson Heppell
22 Jake Carlisle
23 David Myers
24 Alex Browne
26 Cale Hooker
27 Luke Davis
28 Elliott Kavanagh
29 Alwyn Davey
30 Paddy Ryder
31 Dustin Fletcher
32 Travis Colyer
33 Dylan Van Unen
34 Kyle Hardingham
35 Martin Gleeson
37 Sean Gregory
38 Nicholas Kommer
39 Heath Hocking
40 Ben Howlett
41 Will Hams
42 Nathan Lovett-Murray
46 Mark Baguley
25 Ariel Steinberg
36 Lauchlan Dalgleish
45 Hal Hunter
47 Cory Dell'Olio
yaco55
Hall of Famer
He can actually defend one-on-one - That is often missed on these boards.
Hardingham and Coyler won't make it. Not big calls.
NLM to be in his last year.
NLM to be in his last year.
ant555
The Oracle
- May 4, 2004
- 32,850
- 49,189
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Penrith Panthers
Some different views and different boundaries as to how you make it as well as a few fence sits.
Comments based on a good run with injury.
1 Michael Hibberd - really think he will play 150 plus games and make it.
2 Tom Bellchambers- will be one of the best in the game.
3 Scott Gumbleton- injuries worry me, not sure he will get past 60 games.
4 Jobe Watson-made it
5 Brent Stanton-made it
6 Joe Daniher-star in waiting
7 Leroy Jetta-may reach 100 games but do not think he will get past 120.
8 Jason Winderlich-injuries have finished his chances glad he made it to 100 games.
9 Brendon Goddard- will still be good.
10 Nick O'Brien-promising so far, still 50/50 for me but needs to continue to improve.
11 David Zaharakis-star.
12 Stewart Crameri-could be out of the side if Daniher and Gumby fire or even Obrien.
14 Jason Ashby-another 50/50 jury out at the moment.First year reprieve.
15 Courtenay Dempsey-should get 150 games
16 Tayte Pears- do not like his chances, very over rated IMO
17 Jake Melksham-coaches love him,plays every game so he looks like he will get 150 games.
18 Michael Hurley-star who has been restricted by various injuries.
19 David Hille- made it as a good player, in the twilight now.
20 Jackson Merrett- like him think he will play 100 plus.
21 Dyson Heppell- star
22 Jake Carlisle- nearly a star
23 David Myers- 50/50 has the ability, question on injury and how much it has taken its toll. Going to say probably not going to get past 100.
24 Alex Browne- shown a bit but has to step up now. Like him but chances are he may struggle.
26 Cale Hooker- will be a good defender, very very under rated by supporters.
27 Luke Davis-not sure promise will turn into results. Do not like his chances.
28 Elliott Kavanagh- will make it if he gets a good run with injury. Not far off it.
29 Alwyn Davey-close to the end.
30 Paddy Ryder- has made it yet could still find another level.
31 Dustin Fletcher- has made it 6 times over. Genuine super star.
32 Travis Colyer- no, think he has had his chance.
33 Dylan Van Unen- unlikely as a 100 plus player but i liked what i saw in the VFL and could play 50 to 100 if he handles the step up. My guess would be 20 to 50 at this stage.
34 Kyle Hardingham- think a few have caught him and he may struggle to play a lot more games.
35 Martin Gleeson-like Ashby jury is out for the next 12 months.
37 Sean Gregory- see above.
38 Nicholas Kommer- think he will do ok and play 100 odd games, maybe more.
39 Heath Hocking-has close to made it and if current attitude says anything he will be around for a bit longer.100 to 150 games.
40 Ben Howlett- if he improves his defense he will play 100 plus.
41 Will Hams- been really good in the VFL parccy games.
42 Nathan Lovett-Murray- nearing the end but has been a good average player.
46 Mark Baguley- think he will make it and play 100 plus games.
25 Ariel Steinberg- history says blokes dropped back to the rookie list rarely make it. Going to say no despite some promise.
36 Lauchlan Dalgleish-not sure, has done some good things so still 50/50 for me.
45 Hal Hunter- really like this bloke, will surprise a few people, with no injury i think he will make it to the senior list and play 50 plus games.
47 Cory Dell'Olio- would have said no at the end of last year but has had a really big pre season and has been working at 150%. Form really good in the last res match. Still unlikely but maybe more 60/40.
Comments based on a good run with injury.
1 Michael Hibberd - really think he will play 150 plus games and make it.
2 Tom Bellchambers- will be one of the best in the game.
3 Scott Gumbleton- injuries worry me, not sure he will get past 60 games.
4 Jobe Watson-made it
5 Brent Stanton-made it
6 Joe Daniher-star in waiting
7 Leroy Jetta-may reach 100 games but do not think he will get past 120.
8 Jason Winderlich-injuries have finished his chances glad he made it to 100 games.
9 Brendon Goddard- will still be good.
10 Nick O'Brien-promising so far, still 50/50 for me but needs to continue to improve.
11 David Zaharakis-star.
12 Stewart Crameri-could be out of the side if Daniher and Gumby fire or even Obrien.
14 Jason Ashby-another 50/50 jury out at the moment.First year reprieve.
15 Courtenay Dempsey-should get 150 games
16 Tayte Pears- do not like his chances, very over rated IMO
17 Jake Melksham-coaches love him,plays every game so he looks like he will get 150 games.
18 Michael Hurley-star who has been restricted by various injuries.
19 David Hille- made it as a good player, in the twilight now.
20 Jackson Merrett- like him think he will play 100 plus.
21 Dyson Heppell- star
22 Jake Carlisle- nearly a star
23 David Myers- 50/50 has the ability, question on injury and how much it has taken its toll. Going to say probably not going to get past 100.
24 Alex Browne- shown a bit but has to step up now. Like him but chances are he may struggle.
26 Cale Hooker- will be a good defender, very very under rated by supporters.
27 Luke Davis-not sure promise will turn into results. Do not like his chances.
28 Elliott Kavanagh- will make it if he gets a good run with injury. Not far off it.
29 Alwyn Davey-close to the end.
30 Paddy Ryder- has made it yet could still find another level.
31 Dustin Fletcher- has made it 6 times over. Genuine super star.
32 Travis Colyer- no, think he has had his chance.
33 Dylan Van Unen- unlikely as a 100 plus player but i liked what i saw in the VFL and could play 50 to 100 if he handles the step up. My guess would be 20 to 50 at this stage.
34 Kyle Hardingham- think a few have caught him and he may struggle to play a lot more games.
35 Martin Gleeson-like Ashby jury is out for the next 12 months.
37 Sean Gregory- see above.
38 Nicholas Kommer- think he will do ok and play 100 odd games, maybe more.
39 Heath Hocking-has close to made it and if current attitude says anything he will be around for a bit longer.100 to 150 games.
40 Ben Howlett- if he improves his defense he will play 100 plus.
41 Will Hams- been really good in the VFL parccy games.
42 Nathan Lovett-Murray- nearing the end but has been a good average player.
46 Mark Baguley- think he will make it and play 100 plus games.
25 Ariel Steinberg- history says blokes dropped back to the rookie list rarely make it. Going to say no despite some promise.
36 Lauchlan Dalgleish-not sure, has done some good things so still 50/50 for me.
45 Hal Hunter- really like this bloke, will surprise a few people, with no injury i think he will make it to the senior list and play 50 plus games.
47 Cory Dell'Olio- would have said no at the end of last year but has had a really big pre season and has been working at 150%. Form really good in the last res match. Still unlikely but maybe more 60/40.
1 Michael Hibberd - Will.
2 Tom Bellchambers - Will.
3 Scott Gumbleton - Can, pending injuries.
4 Jobe Watson - Has.
5 Brent Stanton - Sort-of has, but will kick on in a better team.
6 Joe Daniher - Will.
7 Leroy Jetta - Won't, but will get to 100.
8 Jason Winderlich - Has done what his body allowed, but will retire through injury soon I fear.
9 Brendon Goddard - Has.
10 Nick O'Brien - Might, depends on competition.
11 David Zaharakis - Will.
12 Stewart Crameri - Will.
14 Jason Ashby - Haven't seen enough.
15 Courtenay Dempsey - Will.
16 Tayte Pears - Will, just needs to stay fit and get his confidence back.
17 Jake Melksham - Will.
18 Michael Hurley - Will, but where?
19 David Hille - Has.
20 Jackson Merrett Haven't seen enough.
21 Dyson Heppell - Will.
22 Jake Carlisle - Will.
23 David Myers - Will.
24 Alex Browne - Might, depends on competition.
26 Cale Hooker - Might, depends on competition.
27 Luke Davis - Won't.
28 Elliott Kavanagh - Will.
29 Alwyn Davey - Will get to 100.
30 Paddy Ryder - Will.
31 Dustin Fletcher - Has.
32 Travis Colyer - Won't.
33 Dylan Van Unen - Haven't seen enough.
34 Kyle Hardingham - Won't.
35 Martin Gleeson - Will.
37 Sean Gregory - Haven't seen enough.
38 Nicholas Kommer - Will.
39 Heath Hocking - Sort-of has, but will kick on in a better team.
40 Ben Howlett - Will.
41 Will Hams - Will.
42 Nathan Lovett-Murray - Has, given his ability.
46 Mark Baguley - Won't. Think sooner or later another of Hibberd's quality will push both Bags and Hardy out.
25 Ariel Steinberg - Won't.
36 Lauchlan Dalgleish - Won't.
45 Hal Hunter - Won't.
47 Cory Dell'Olio - Might, depends on competition.
2 Tom Bellchambers - Will.
3 Scott Gumbleton - Can, pending injuries.
4 Jobe Watson - Has.
5 Brent Stanton - Sort-of has, but will kick on in a better team.
6 Joe Daniher - Will.
7 Leroy Jetta - Won't, but will get to 100.
8 Jason Winderlich - Has done what his body allowed, but will retire through injury soon I fear.
9 Brendon Goddard - Has.
10 Nick O'Brien - Might, depends on competition.
11 David Zaharakis - Will.
12 Stewart Crameri - Will.
14 Jason Ashby - Haven't seen enough.
15 Courtenay Dempsey - Will.
16 Tayte Pears - Will, just needs to stay fit and get his confidence back.
17 Jake Melksham - Will.
18 Michael Hurley - Will, but where?
19 David Hille - Has.
20 Jackson Merrett Haven't seen enough.
21 Dyson Heppell - Will.
22 Jake Carlisle - Will.
23 David Myers - Will.
24 Alex Browne - Might, depends on competition.
26 Cale Hooker - Might, depends on competition.
27 Luke Davis - Won't.
28 Elliott Kavanagh - Will.
29 Alwyn Davey - Will get to 100.
30 Paddy Ryder - Will.
31 Dustin Fletcher - Has.
32 Travis Colyer - Won't.
33 Dylan Van Unen - Haven't seen enough.
34 Kyle Hardingham - Won't.
35 Martin Gleeson - Will.
37 Sean Gregory - Haven't seen enough.
38 Nicholas Kommer - Will.
39 Heath Hocking - Sort-of has, but will kick on in a better team.
40 Ben Howlett - Will.
41 Will Hams - Will.
42 Nathan Lovett-Murray - Has, given his ability.
46 Mark Baguley - Won't. Think sooner or later another of Hibberd's quality will push both Bags and Hardy out.
25 Ariel Steinberg - Won't.
36 Lauchlan Dalgleish - Won't.
45 Hal Hunter - Won't.
47 Cory Dell'Olio - Might, depends on competition.
