Finals Week 2

[Satan]

Selwood, simpson, murphy, bews tonight

Only interested in points this week
2 trades left. Suckling and mcgovern to go after this week

 

[Spanish Sahara]

Thanks, my other option was to keep him in DEF and trade him for H.Shaw?

What you think?

So basically it comes down to MUNDY v SHAW

Mundy over Shaw imo

 

[Spanish Sahara]

heck off Selwood

 

[PowerForGood]

Jelwood yay (so far)
Mackie yay (so far)
Murphy yay (so far)
Kersten boo (covering for Roughie, anyway who cares, I've got the week off in the league!)

 

[PoopingHindi]

everyone performing as expected
...including Simpson unfortunately

 

[Donakebab]

Simpson, why you do this....?


Carlton

15 Sam Docherty 41
35 Ed Curnow 34
44 Andrew Carrazzo 28
3 Marc Murphy 26
2 Troy Menzel 26
46 David Ellard 24
17 Sam Rowe 22
4 Bryce Gibbs 17
5 Chris Judd 17
30 Jarrad Waite 17
28 Tom Bell 16
42 Zach Tuohy 16
32 Nick Graham 15
13 Chris Yarran 14
36 Cameron Wood 11
41 Levi Casboult 11
43 Simon White 10
40 Michael Jamison 9
47 Ciaran Sheehan 8
39 Dale Thomas 3
6 Kade Simpson 3
27 Dennis Armfield 0

Geelong

46 Mark Blicavs 44
14 Joel Selwood 39
7 Harry Taylor 37
4 Andrew Mackie 32
23 Josh Caddy 31
33 George Horlin-Smith 27
9 James Kelly 25
2 Billie Smedts 21
44 Corey Enright 21
32 Steven Motlop 21
28 Allen Christensen 19
17 Hamish McIntosh 19
27 Mathew Stokes 19
22 Mitch Duncan 18
26 Tom Hawkins 17
5 Travis Varcoe 16
24 Jed Bews 15
29 Cameron Guthrie 9
13 Tom Lonergan 8
39 Shane Kersten 7
40 Jackson Thurlow 0
25 Jared Rivers -3

 

[SureBuddy]

Have an existing midfield of: Rockliff, Pendles, Beams, Fyfe, Jelwood, JPK, SJ, NDS.

Have got $620k to replace SJ...so which mid out of:

Ward
Sloane
Boomer
Heppell
Parker
Murphy
Cotchin

Or someone else??

Boak

 

[Hairy Lager]

Have an existing midfield of: Rockliff, Pendles, Beams, Fyfe, Jelwood, JPK, SJ, NDS.

Have got $620k to replace SJ...so which mid out of:

Ward
Sloane
Boomer
Heppell
Parker
Murphy
Cotchin

Or someone else??

Priddis

 

[toxic]

I hate carlton but these umpires need multiple bullets in their nuts. Complete bloody bias and joke.

 

[leng jai]

So frustrating watching Selwood and his free kicks when you don't have him.

 

[GOAUS!]

Why aren't they tagging Jelwood? Surely with SJ out you would go to him, looks like I missed out here.

 

[karaoke]

Why aren't they tagging Jelwood? Surely with SJ out you would go to him, looks like I missed out here.

Carrots is on him?

 

[Hairy Lager]

Why aren't they tagging Jelwood? Surely with SJ out you would go to him, looks like I missed out here.

Same where is this Malthouse defensive game gone?

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Have an existing midfield of: Rockliff, Pendles, Beams, Fyfe, Jelwood, JPK, SJ, NDS.

Have got $620k to replace SJ...so which mid out of:

Ward
Sloane
Boomer
Heppell
Parker
Murphy
Cotchin

Or someone else??

One month ago I would have said Ward but he looks to be running out of puff.

Go for the Sloane Ranger

FWIW I have both

 

[bato]

LIFT SIMMO!!!

 

[joop]

Avoid Friday VC

Wait as long as you can.

If you know who he is making C make him your VC

Gives you a free Captain shot if required

Can you explain this to me? Why do you hold on as long as you can? If selwood goes 160 tonight then you miss out..? I don't get the difference just pick who you think will score the most

 

[Mercuri Rising]

Doc has vanished into the ether.

 

[Hairy Lager]

Can you explain this to me? Why do you hold on as long as you can? If selwood goes 160 tonight then you miss out..? I don't get the difference just pick who you think will score the most

Do you have a punt? Because that is effectively what you are doing. Not going Friday night gives you a bigger bite at the cherry. All Guess work really.

 

[PowerForGood]

Can you explain this to me? Why do you hold on as long as you can? If selwood goes 160 tonight then you miss out..? I don't get the difference just pick who you think will score the most

In a match play, you are looking for the advantage over your opponent for the week.
So if you make your VC equal to their C, and have a C later in the round, you have the following options.
1) if your VC, their C scores high, then you can match them at the very least.
2) if your VC , their C scores low, you can then get the advantage by going for a C that will almost certainly score higher.

Risk of losing is minimised.

 

[PoopingHindi]

In a match play, you are looking for the advantage over your opponent for the week.
So if you make your VC equal to their C, and have a C later in the round, you have the following options.
1) if your VC, their C scores high, then you can match them at the very least.
2) if your VC , their C scores low, you can then get the advantage by going for a C that will almost certainly score higher.

Risk of losing is minimised.

unless their VC scores 160...then what?

 

[Spanish Sahara]

unless their VC scores 160...then what?

Then you still get two shots at trying to get 160

 

[Donakebab]

Carlton

3 Marc Murphy 58
44 Andrew Carrazzo 56
4 Bryce Gibbs 56
15 Sam Docherty 56
35 Ed Curnow 53
17 Sam Rowe 51
2 Troy Menzel 45
28 Tom Bell 44
43 Simon White 37
5 Chris Judd 33
13 Chris Yarran 33
41 Levi Casboult 31
36 Cameron Wood 29
39 Dale Thomas 28
47 Ciaran Sheehan 27
30 Jarrad Waite 27
46 David Ellard 26 (Subbed Out)
6 Kade Simpson 25
40 Michael Jamison 24
32 Nick Graham 24
42 Zach Tuohy 24
27 Dennis Armfield 2 (Subbed In)

Geelong

46 Mark Blicavs 74
14 Joel Selwood 69
7 Harry Taylor 65
17 Hamish McIntosh 58
33 George Horlin-Smith 52
9 James Kelly 49
26 Tom Hawkins 48
4 Andrew Mackie 45
23 Josh Caddy 42
22 Mitch Duncan 38
5 Travis Varcoe 38
27 Mathew Stokes 36
32 Steven Motlop 36
44 Corey Enright 34
13 Tom Lonergan 28
28 Allen Christensen 26
29 Cameron Guthrie 26
2 Billie Smedts 24
39 Shane Kersten 21
24 Jed Bews 17
25 Jared Rivers 16
40 Jackson Thurlow 0

 

[joop]

In a match play, you are looking for the advantage over your opponent for the week.
So if you make your VC equal to their C, and have a C later in the round, you have the following options.
1) if your VC, their C scores high, then you can match them at the very least.
2) if your VC , their C scores low, you can then get the advantage by going for a C that will almost certainly score higher.

Risk of losing is minimised.

Ahhok I get ya! So it also depends on what your opponent is doing, we'll hopefully selwood keeps killing it for me!

 

[Hairy Lager]

In a match play, you are looking for the advantage over your opponent for the week.
So if you make your VC equal to their C, and have a C later in the round, you have the following options.
1) if your VC, their C scores high, then you can match them at the very least.
2) if your VC , their C scores low, you can then get the advantage by going for a C that will almost certainly score higher.

Risk of losing is minimised.

That there is the deal sealer, all speculative.

 

[Super Hans]

Boooooooo Simpson and Bews. Boooooooo.