- Joined
- Mar 26, 2008
- Posts
- 11,696
- Likes
- 8,284
- Location
- Behind You...
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Justice League
Thread starter
#1
Fisher, Bentick, Saddington or Houlihan.
Ok here are a few players who might make a good trade package if a contracted player was wanting to leave a club and come to Carlton.
Fisher: Finds the footy and can take a good mark but can't kick. Is ruining good passages of play by kicking behinds and is contributing to our teams goal kicking inaccuracy problem. I think that Edwards would contribute more to the score, wouldn't need to have as many shots to do so.
Bentick:
Is a good inside player with a strong body but is too slow and not skilled enough to get a game in our side. We don't need 1 big strong body in the center anymore as we have Judd and Stevo and Murph, Gibbs, Grigg and Browne are filling out nicely.
Saddington:
Is a good player on an opponent smaller than him, runs off half back and can find the footy well. Not good enough to get a game in our best side when Bower is fit and Austin in ready and who ever we draft is ready.
Houlihan:
Very skillful, and can play forward, midfield or back. Can kick goals. Lacks forward pressure as a forward and lacks pace and his tackling is terrible. Not what is required in a premership contender side. Probably wouldn't get a game in our best side.
There is a strong rumour that Daniel Kerr wants to leave West Coast and the rumour is that his club of choice is Carlton. If this was the case I'm sure West Coast would take these options instead of nothing. If not Kerr, perhaps another player. Kerr would be a great get, he's a complete player who can play anywhere and would have teams with no idea of who to tag.
We may not need a KPP if Kreuze keeps going the way he is and Cloke improves a little as he might.
Carlton is a club with money to spend, a bright future of finals and possible premerships, quality club personal and fairly good (soon to be awesome) facilities. We are in the box seat to get any good players who want out. I believe we have more to offer than any other AFL side in the comp.
Ok here are a few players who might make a good trade package if a contracted player was wanting to leave a club and come to Carlton.
Fisher: Finds the footy and can take a good mark but can't kick. Is ruining good passages of play by kicking behinds and is contributing to our teams goal kicking inaccuracy problem. I think that Edwards would contribute more to the score, wouldn't need to have as many shots to do so.
Bentick:
Is a good inside player with a strong body but is too slow and not skilled enough to get a game in our side. We don't need 1 big strong body in the center anymore as we have Judd and Stevo and Murph, Gibbs, Grigg and Browne are filling out nicely.
Saddington:
Is a good player on an opponent smaller than him, runs off half back and can find the footy well. Not good enough to get a game in our best side when Bower is fit and Austin in ready and who ever we draft is ready.
Houlihan:
Very skillful, and can play forward, midfield or back. Can kick goals. Lacks forward pressure as a forward and lacks pace and his tackling is terrible. Not what is required in a premership contender side. Probably wouldn't get a game in our best side.
There is a strong rumour that Daniel Kerr wants to leave West Coast and the rumour is that his club of choice is Carlton. If this was the case I'm sure West Coast would take these options instead of nothing. If not Kerr, perhaps another player. Kerr would be a great get, he's a complete player who can play anywhere and would have teams with no idea of who to tag.
We may not need a KPP if Kreuze keeps going the way he is and Cloke improves a little as he might.
Carlton is a club with money to spend, a bright future of finals and possible premerships, quality club personal and fairly good (soon to be awesome) facilities. We are in the box seat to get any good players who want out. I believe we have more to offer than any other AFL side in the comp.

