I know you're not a fan, Longy. I think it's fair to say his time at Essendon could have been better, but I don't think he was that ordinary at Collingwood. He booted most goals for Williamstown's season in 2002 and I thought grew in stature, though I think had somewhat of an immature attitude. I think his leadership position at Werribee has helped him mature and think he goes about his footy differently from before. Sure, he isn't a Carey, but I think I have certainly seen worse and do believe there are some mediocre talls currently on AFL lists. I don't think Podsiadly falls into this category, and believe he may have something to offer. There is only one way of knowing if he could surprise, though - to draft him.
He has his chance to impress in Sydney this week, and if he fails then, sure, label him as simply a good VFL player. Until then, I am willing to give him one last chance, with his seemingly renewed positive attitude.