Lachie Neale was just as good at Fremantle as he has been at Brisbane. Its just the media has decided to pay attention to him now.
Mayne's best football at Freo, back around 13-14 was far better than anything than he's produced at Collingwood.
I mean this really sums it up right? Josh Bruce has been servicable for the Dogs, while McCarthy has been non-existent.
That is being very generous.