Stevi_Tigers
TheBrownDog
- Mar 2, 2013
- 55,058
- 116,841
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Manchester United
Gunston and Zac Merrett apparently
Prediction Future Free Agency Targets [aka the Petracca, Toby Greene & Thomas Green discussion]
- Thread starter Marcel Proust
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Stevi_Tigers
TheBrownDog
- Mar 2, 2013
- 55,058
- 116,841
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Manchester United
Same offer Gold Coast did to Ablett jnr they also gave Nathan a list spot after years not playing the game at all
- Mar 1, 2010
- 23,185
- 16,586
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Other clubs would have to be nuts to pick up Treloar, Phillips and Cox in the current scenario.
Can't see why Gold Coast would do it either when they have at least one generational player in Rowell if not more of a certain vintage they should be building around. Treloar would just wreck the Gold Coast build like GWS
- Mar 1, 2010
- 23,185
- 16,586
- AFL Club
- Richmond
OhhDeledio
Premiership Player
a know treloar gets clowned on this board, but ive grown to like him over the past couple of years seeing him on 360 with jack. theres no chance he comes to us but he would be a very good get and a good transition from cotchin.
- Mar 1, 2010
- 23,185
- 16,586
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Yes except too expensive with risk so its a no. from my perspective
There are better options for the Tigers anyway.
Treloar is a nice to have but its not really going to happen in the current circumstances I think putting team and club interests first. Might get Treloar in 3 years time under different circumstances which would make him 30, assuming he is still playing, but not now that I can see
Last edited:
- Mar 1, 2010
- 23,185
- 16,586
- AFL Club
- Richmond
I think we should trade for Tom Green.
The idea is we say we will trade for Tom Green and will not bid for Joshua Green, Tom's brother.
We trade CCJ to GWS who I think will find it tough with Nank, Balta and others like Chol(plus Soldo and others like Biggy) chipping in plus a first round and maybe we get something back.
Assuming Jeremy Cameron goes from GWS CCJ gets an opportunity in the ruck as well as forward in a GWS team with plenty of youth that is now building.
We play Tom who offers us something different. When it suits Tom we can trade him back to GWS to play with his brother and maybe get a premiership at GWS. GWS might have relocated to Canberra by then which is we the Greens where brought up. The other thing is CCJ gets his chance at GWS and then could get traded to Adelaide if he wants and Himmelberg of Adelaide has the chance to play with his brother at GWS. Otherwise CCJ might prove to be a gun and win a premiership at GWS.
We could even trade Tom Green and get CCJ back if it suited clubs and players especially if it suits each clubs quest for premierships at the time.
The reason GWS might go for this is they need to rebuild a little, not sure what Kelly and others doing next year so the trade gives GWS flexibility to re-shape the list and premiership window, still have a Green connection and get Tom back later assuming it suits Tom.
I can't see Nank going currently because he is too important to the brand apart from structure and embedded in the dynamic and fabric at least for a few years yet. Nank is too much of a heart and soul player for the club and team to be let go unless it suited him later on
The idea is we say we will trade for Tom Green and will not bid for Joshua Green, Tom's brother.
We trade CCJ to GWS who I think will find it tough with Nank, Balta and others like Chol(plus Soldo and others like Biggy) chipping in plus a first round and maybe we get something back.
Assuming Jeremy Cameron goes from GWS CCJ gets an opportunity in the ruck as well as forward in a GWS team with plenty of youth that is now building.
We play Tom who offers us something different. When it suits Tom we can trade him back to GWS to play with his brother and maybe get a premiership at GWS. GWS might have relocated to Canberra by then which is we the Greens where brought up. The other thing is CCJ gets his chance at GWS and then could get traded to Adelaide if he wants and Himmelberg of Adelaide has the chance to play with his brother at GWS. Otherwise CCJ might prove to be a gun and win a premiership at GWS.
We could even trade Tom Green and get CCJ back if it suited clubs and players especially if it suits each clubs quest for premierships at the time.
The reason GWS might go for this is they need to rebuild a little, not sure what Kelly and others doing next year so the trade gives GWS flexibility to re-shape the list and premiership window, still have a Green connection and get Tom back later assuming it suits Tom.
I can't see Nank going currently because he is too important to the brand apart from structure and embedded in the dynamic and fabric at least for a few years yet. Nank is too much of a heart and soul player for the club and team to be let go unless it suited him later on
Last edited:
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #9,408
If Collingwood pay his contract I'd take treloar. Jokes aside he is a very good player.
Hogan is interesting too. Can play
- Mar 1, 2010
- 23,185
- 16,586
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Treloar could ask for an early pay out could he not? Pies pay me 3 million and I will move on. Obviously Pies regard other targets far more than Treloar and want Treloar out which is terrible for Treloar from apparent mismanagement.
Jarrod Brander could be a left field option. I was looking at his highlights, I know its highlights but his vision looks better when he was younger than recent play. I think he might be better value than Hogan being younger to, could be a hidden smokey due to positioning. You know what I found interesting. Geelong was chasing Brander as part of Kelly trade last year apparently and West Coast held out. Geelong also looking at Brander for Jordan Clark now to.
Here is another scenario assuming can't get Tom Green.
Trade CCJ to GWS, Jordan Clark to West Coast, Jarrod Brander to RFC, first rounder to GWS from Geelong as part of matched trade for Jeremy Cameron to Geelong
Last edited:
Geez if Treloar landed here we'd have to all go back through our posting history and do a fair bit of scrubbing...
Treloar s hammy’s are ****ed and he suffers severely from anxiety .
Hogan is unfortunately struggling to function and for his own well being might be best off out of football , concentrating on his mental well being .
RFC has been quite diligent in its recruiting of late ( post fine eyes).
Hogan is unfortunately struggling to function and for his own well being might be best off out of football , concentrating on his mental well being .
RFC has been quite diligent in its recruiting of late ( post fine eyes).
I see CCJ as a ruckman / forward .
We have Balta and wouldn’t surprise me if Chol is transformed into a defender.
- Aug 15, 2015
- 9,646
- 31,261
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Treloar on 900k !! So even if the Pies were to pay 200-300k still wouldn’t go there.
Just don’t see the need after witnessing our midfield domination during the finals and knowing we have some quality kids in the wings.
And a long term replacement for Cotch who is still contracted til 22!?
Don’t think Blair would view it that way. He has a history of serious hamstring injury.
Real ? on his longevity which may be one of the reasons Pies are trying to offload him.
We’ll win it again next year, save our coin for when JR hangs up the boots end of 21.
Just don’t see the need after witnessing our midfield domination during the finals and knowing we have some quality kids in the wings.
And a long term replacement for Cotch who is still contracted til 22!?
Don’t think Blair would view it that way. He has a history of serious hamstring injury.
Real ? on his longevity which may be one of the reasons Pies are trying to offload him.
We’ll win it again next year, save our coin for when JR hangs up the boots end of 21.
Rifles
All Australian
- Apr 11, 2017
- 959
- 3,445
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Dreaming if they think that gets them to a premiership. Delicious
Wacky Tiger
Parmy
Bucks is frantically skimming Konrad books trying to find the chapter on how to do with s**t culture.
Won't find it in these books mate
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Won't find it in these books mate
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Barunga Bullet
The GOAT
- May 8, 2019
- 1,016
- 4,295
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Need to get rid of the players with sh*t character first
yes good point
and standing next to Dusty anxiety will only rise
the fear of not being good enough
Anxiety about both his hammies pinging again...
Reckon Wright and Brayshaw are gettable. Tom McDonald I am not sure, his price will definitely be high.
Not a huge fan of Hogan, but his forms highly questionable as well as his off-field behaviour...... If there is one team that can rebuild his footy hunger and focus, it's us. I don't think he would cost the world, its high risk high reward, and would definitely bring versatility. To be honest I am 50-50, more leaning towards no. Pretty sure he is keen on heading to NSW however.
Need to make sure we try keep Broad and Markov, money will be the factor. Higgo, as much as I love him, he is expendable. We have a lot of similar types on our list, and for what he has been through he needs an opportunity.
Anyway, watching the replay (again)......
Not the craziest idea to try poach him on the cheap. Pies paying a chunky part of his salary, his preference is to stay in Melbourne.Disrespectful to be honest.
Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk
Just how does he fit into the side......
Who are the Pies chasing? TMcDonald?
I'm trying to think who on earth they are building the war-chest for..... one of the Kings?
I just struggle to think how he fits in our team, sure he's a decent mid when firing, however injury riddled recently, who comes our of our midfield for him?
Agree on the cheap a good pick up, question marks over his health and how he slots in to the team......
- Status
Similar threads
