Game Day GDT The CS Edition: Round 11 Vs Adelaide Crows(H) 19:10ACST(1940AEST) @TIO Stadium- Lets Start from the Top-end that is.

[Cannon82]

Don't get me started on Oscar.

What are your thoughts on Oscar?

 

[Robos]

Why have you always backed in Oscar? He has literally never done one good thing in his career. I’m not joking. Not one. He is weak, he is a poor decision maker, he is uncoordinated and by far the least intimidating defender to ever pull on a Melbourne jumper. I actually feel sorry for him that he keeps getting selected at AFL level, it must just be so embarrassing watching the reviews each week. Send him back to see out his days as a very poor VFL footballer.

100% agree. I would love to be a forward playing on him . He hasn’t a mean streak in him and to having the mat man in defence I sweat every time . Please bring in May !

 

[schmuttt]

I have no doubt about that, my initial argument is he isn't going to make it, time to get some games into the young blokes like sparrow and chandler, surely they couldnt perform any worse.

Don't get me started on Oscar.

We tried sparrow at the start of the year and everyone was pissed we played him clearly out of position up forward. We’ve drafted far too many inside mids and we’re paying the price for it.

 

[blitznu]

He is a whipping boy because he is ****, has not played a good game in the afl and has had enough time on the list.

Enlighten me and tell me what his natural position is?

You are defending jkh because he has been played out of position and having a go at brayshaw who is also being played out of position? Not sure what your argument is?

JKH came in played his role pretty good off of 1 game in the VFL and as a late in. Had 18 touches 6 marks and our leading tackler and was 1 of our hardest defensive runners. Not arguing s**t just saying its easy to bash the same players every week and i reckon JKH did his job

 

[demondavey]

We care because the season wouldn’t have been done if we won. Pretty simple.

It was done when we lost to WC mate

 

[CWaffles]

JKH came in played his role pretty good off of 1 game in the VFL and as a late in. Had 18 touches 6 marks and our leading tackler and was 1 of our hardest defensive runners. Not arguing **** just saying its easy to bash the same players every week and i reckon JKH did his job

18 touches with 6 turnovers, he was going at 61% only 2 other players had a worse efficiency.

 

[demondavey]

Collingwood next week lads! Collingwood after an upset loss at home!

I am not surprised we lost, nor devastated. We kicked ourselves out of it. Standard.

 

[Cannon82]

18 touches with 6 turnovers, he was going at 61% only 2 other players had a worse efficiency.

Would be good if someone could splice a quick highlights package together of his kicking. Maybe half of his efforts would have been along the ground.

 

[CWaffles]

Would be good if someone could splice a quick highlights package together of his kicking. Maybe half of his efforts would have been along the ground.

Im not sure anyone wants to put them through having to watch that vision again.

 

[AmericanAFL]

Just finished watching.

As usual I’m left wondering if I should be laughing or crying.

FFS

 

[stabler]

Just finished watching.

As usual I’m left wondering if I should be laughing or crying.

FFS

Crying. Laughing was last week

 

[AmericanAFL]

Crying. Laughing was last week

One thing is for sure. I will never question anyone’s negative mindset around here ever again.

MFCSS deserves an entry in the DSM-V.

 

[stretcharmstrong]

JKH came in played his role pretty good off of 1 game in the VFL and as a late in. Had 18 touches 6 marks and our leading tackler and was 1 of our hardest defensive runners. Not arguing **** just saying its easy to bash the same players every week and i reckon JKH did his job

Decision making and disposal were both shocking.

 

[stretcharmstrong]

18 touches with 6 turnovers, he was going at 61% only 2 other players had a worse efficiency.

Even when he disposed of it without turning it over it was usually a poor choice to a team mate who couldn’t mark it or just got wrapped up immediately. Killer a few counter attacks by stopping and propping instead of keeping up the burst/running momentum.

 

[blitznu]

Decision making and disposal were both shocking.

Thats the melbourne way. Every campaigner all game was doing the same s**t. Could re watch game and focus on 1 player and youd want them out of the team bar Baker

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Collingwood next week lads! Collingwood after an upset loss at home!

I am not surprised we lost, nor devastated. We kicked ourselves out of it. Standard.

Collingwood have almost been upset in their last six games

 

[demondavey]

Collingwood have almost been upset in their last six games

 

[demondavey]

Won’t be against the DEEEEEEEES