Mega Thread General MFC Discussion Part III

[Dory_77]

Lamumba and Dawes from Collingwood too.

 

[mrmonkey]

Brett grgic to Geelong, maric and miller to the tigers

 

[TheCount]

Joel McDonald came from Brisbane as well.
Would be a solid laugh for all of us to say Petracca came from St Kilda ...

 

[TheCount]

Brett grgic to Geelong, maric and miller to the tigers

Petterd to Richmond as well.

 

[LeverPuller]

There’s another one from Port in the Roos era too

 

[mrmonkey]

Petterd to Richmond as well.

Yeah but he already had that.

 

[mrmonkey]

Chris Johnson walked out of the club after being father/son trengove watts to Port. Powell from wb then to St kilda. Shannon motlop from North and Simon Buckley to Collingwood. Jolly to swans jamar to bombers. McDonald to gws

 

[AmericanAFL]

Watts to PA

 

[Dory_77]

Ben Ken from Collingwood

There’s another one from Port in the Roos era too

Ben Newton?
Does Dom Barry to Port count?

 

[Max Power 83]

Rodan also from port
Shannon motlop from North
Marcus Seacamp from Fitzroy
Scott Chisholm from Freo

 

[PerfectFooty]

Newton from port

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Sylvia, Pedersen, Gysberts, Balic, Ben Ken, Miller, Maric, J McDonald, J MacDonald, Bruce, McKenna, Dawes, Clark, Moloney, Frawley, J Rivers, KK, Morton, Toumpas, Watts, Trengove, Oscar, McLean, Powell, Preuss, TJ, Simmonds, Terlich, Cheney, Blease, Longmuir, Wowoedin, Bennell, Fitzpatrick, Grgic, Sellar, Meesen, Clarko, Cross, Barry, Garlett, Wagner, Buckley, Petterd, Jolly...

Also, do you mean McKenna rather than McNamara?

EDIT: okay lol I did not see all of the replies beyond the first two

 

[Max Power 83]

Andy Lovell to WC

 

[JP2]

Updated list. Told you I missed some easy ones.

Adel -> Melb: Lever, Ingerson, Vince, Vardy, Meesen, Sellar
Bris -> Melb: Clark, McDonald
Carl -> Melb: Garlett
Coll -> Melb: Lumumba, Dawes, Kennedy
Ess -> Melb: Heffernan, Moorcroft, Hibberd, Melksham, M.Brown
Freo -> Melb: White, Michie, Langdon, Chisholm, Balic
GC -> Melb: May, KK
Geel -> Melb: Byrnes, Gillies , Bizzell, Moloney
GWS -> Melb: Frost, Bugg, McKenna, Tyson, Tomlinson
Haw -> Melb: Lewis, Campbell
NM -> Melb: B.Brown, Daw, S. Motlop, Pedersen, Pruess, Clarkson, Wagner
PA -> Melb: B.Pickett, Newton, Rodan
Rich -> Melb: ???
St.K -> Melb: ???
Syd -> Melb: ???
WC -> Melb: Irving, Turley
WB -> Melb: Powell, Cross

Melb -> Adel: Thompson
Melb -> Bris: Owen, Moloney, Johnstone, Martin
Melb -> Carl: Heaver, Spalding, Bugg, C. Johnson, OMac, McLean
Melb -> Coll: Howe, Dunn, Buckley, Wowoedin
Melb -> Ess: Jamar
Melb -> Freo: Hogan, Farmer, Sylvia, Longmuir
Melb -> GC: Warnock
Melb -> Geel: Clark, Grgic, Rivers
Melb -> GWS: McDonald , Scully , Pruess
Melb -> Haw: Frost, Bruce, Frawley, Cheney, Fitzpatrick
Melb -> NM: Tyson, Gysberts
Melb -> PA: Bishop, Walsh, Watts, Toumpas, Trengove
Melb -> Rich: Miller, Pettard
Melb -> St.K: Kent, Powell
Melb -> Syd: Tingay, Jolly
Melb -> WC: Armstrong, Bennell, Morton, Lovell
Melb -> WB: Hannan

Just missing players that went from Carl, Rich, St.K and Sydney to Melbourne, and from Melbourne to Essendon.

EDIT: Added Gysberts2Bate's extra suggestions, and just remembered Jamar as a player who went from Melb -> Ess in the ASADA year.

Drawing a blank on where Simmonds (Rich?) and Blease ended up, though?

 

[Theseventhhamster]

Andy Lovell to WC

This still hurts as does Dyson to Sydney.

 

[Blackas87]

Chris Heffernan went back to Essendon from Melbourne, does that count?

 

[KickLongTackleHard]

Troy Simmonds to Freo
Aiden Riley from Adelaide
Phil Read from WC
Sam Blease to Geelong pretty sure

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

For anyone that's interested in squiggle interesting to see how much we've moved this year. As can be seen from the general clustering of the last five premiers on the y-axis it's unlikely that any side is ever going to reach particularly lofty heights in offensive potential ever again. Only the Crows and Swans have shown marked difference on the y this year, and have regressed since the early rounds to the middle of the pack. But our movement along the x-axis from after R1 to the Richmond game is extremely pronounced - potentially sharper than any other short term movement I've ever seen from us on either axis before. Whatever we were doing was some serious improvement. Very curious to see if it continues after the dropoff in the team defence v North and now Tomlinson out.

 

[Topkent]

Jamie Shanahan came from StKilda
Pike to North
Nick Gill to Adelaide
Ellis from WB

I can't think of any Tigers or Swans players that have played for us

 

[dazzledavey36]

Jamie Shanahan came from StKilda
Pike to North
Nick Gill to Adelaide
Ellis from WB

I can't think of any Tigers or Swans players that have played for us

We had Ben Holland. And if you cast back a tad further we had a bloke named Ezra Poyas on our rookie list I think in 2003? Stayed at Sandy and was an absolute gun at VFL level when Sandy were winning all those flags.

 

[Topkent]

We had Ben Holland. And if you cast back a tad further we had a bloke named Ezra Poyas on our rookie list I think in 2003? Stayed at Sandy and was an absolute gun at VFL level when Sandy were winning all those flags.

Right of course Dutchy.
Yeah I remember Ezra, bald bloke who we specifically took to captain Sandy

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Jamie Shanahan came from StKilda
Pike to North
Nick Gill to Adelaide
Ellis from WB

I can't think of any Tigers or Swans players that have played for us

Terlich was listed at the Swans, but never played a game for them. That's the closest I reckon.

Yeah the Tigers have picked up quite a few of our rejects, and we haven't taken many of theirs.

 

[Topkent]

Terlich was listed at the Swans, but never played a game for them. That's the closest I reckon.

Yeah the Tigers have picked up quite a few of our rejects, and we haven't taken many of theirs.

Thats right there was that joke that Roosy had sacked Terlich twice.

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Thats right there was that joke that Roosy had sacked Terlich twice.

I like to imagine Roosy turning up at the Dees on day 1 and being like 'wtf Dean I thought I told you I never want to see your face again'

 

[Topkent]

I like to imagine Roosy turning up at the Dees on day 1 and being like 'wtf Dean I thought I told you I never want to see your face again'

I thought I told you to shave those sideburns!