General Questions

[V23]

What are everyone's thoughts on selecting five rookies in the midfield and putting five premiums each in the back and forward line? I understand that the majority of scoring is obtained in the midfield but the reasoning is that the best cash cows are located in the midfield.

 

[rocker_oz33]

your funeral if you do that.

 

[B Train]

How do you classify a player as a premium? Do they have to be a minimum price?

 

[Deliverance]

Trying to pick the most effective players for SC obviously, so can someone tell me what disposal efficiency and clangers are? I thought I knew what they were, but how can a player have 100% DE but have 3 clangers?

 

[V23]

your funeral if you do that.

Well, implementing this strategy, it comes down to:

Dal Santo, Enright and Weedon (old strategy)
vs
Goodes, H. Shaw and Koby Stevens (new strategy)

Option two looks better on paper, so I'll go with that.

 

[under achievers]

your funeral if you do that.

Why would that be the case? If you have a group of strong midfield types and DPP in the forwards and backs, I don't see any problems with loading up with midfield cash cows. I'm only starting 3 premium mids this year with the rest rookies. I wouldn't want less than 3 premiums though.

 

[Boxhead_31]

How do you classify a player as a premium? Do they have to be a minimum price?

A premium is generally a player that will end the season as one of the top 6-10 top average scores for their position come the end of the year.

 

[dlanod]

This year I've seen a sudden spate of posts saying that players that aren't going to finish in the top six or seven in their position are a waste of space. I'd dispute that for a number of reasons:
- No one nails their whole team, so you have to make compromises somewhere.
- If a player is value for money and you think they'll finish in the top 15 to 20, I think you should go for it. That spare cash can be used elsewhere to bring up your overall team.
- This point is less applicable at the start of the year but still useful for planning upgrades - if a player does all his good scoring before you bring him in, it doesn't matter that he finishes in the top handful in the year if he was 50th in scoring for the weeks you brought him in.

Overall I think it's just too simple.

 

[Super Gusto]

This year I've seen a sudden spate of posts saying that players that aren't going to finish in the top six or seven in their position are a waste of space. I'd dispute that for a number of reasons:
- No one nails their whole team, so you have to make compromises somewhere.
- If a player is value for money and you think they'll finish in the top 15 to 20, I think you should go for it. That spare cash can be used elsewhere to bring up your overall team.
- This point is less applicable at the start of the year but still useful for planning upgrades - if a player does all his good scoring before you bring him in, it doesn't matter that he finishes in the top handful in the year if he was 50th in scoring for the weeks you brought him in.

Overall I think it's just too simple.

I agree. There are flaws with any strategy you adopt. A lot of people are taking the line of top 6 and gun/ rookie strategy to end up with the perfect team but it's not this simple. To win overall you need to be cranking out big scores from the get go so go for the guys who will score the best.

 

[Super Gusto]

Some interesting figures from last year
Top total Scorers from last year – less than 22 games in brackets
Def - Goddard,Scotland,Deledio,Gibbs, Fisher, Birchall (21), Bock (21)
Mid– Pendelbury, Dal Santo,Murphy, Swan (21) Judd, Ablett (20)
Ruck – Cox, Goldstein (21)
Fwd – Goodes, Fyfe (21), Okeefe, Harvey, Cloke, S Johnson (20) Pavlich (20)
Note – Mumford (17) and Franklin (19) would have made the top on averages but not total score.

Last Years Winner Impromtu’s team based on the above
Started with
Def 3 out of the top 7 overall defenders for the year
Mid 3 out of 6
Ruck 1 out of 2
Fwd 3 out of 7
Finished with
Def 5 out of the top 7 overall defenders for the year.
Mid 4 out of 6
Ruck 1 out of 2
Forward 4 out of 7

 

[Big Fozza]

does anyone know how to add people like Sheedy and Crawford to a personal league? i've got a league with some mates and instead of it getting filled with randoms would prefer to get some celebs in there...

edit - just found how to add Crawford. is there any other celebs we can add?

 

[V23]

What's the latest on Zorko?

 

[tstead]

Real random one,

Im looking at making a stubby holder for my father inlaw who won the league last year and I was hoping to get an image of the trophy that gets put in the 'Trophy cabinet' section. can anyone from last year who won their league please send me an image of the trophy. i can photoshop his team name over it.

Cheers

 

[under achievers]

Does anybody know if it is possible to get hold of all the Supercoach scores for round 2 NAB cup? If so, where can we find it?

 

[V23]

Does anybody know if it is possible to get hold of all the Supercoach scores for round 2 NAB cup? If so, where can we find it?

Not all of them, but here are the top performers for round 2 of the NAB Cup (credit to CrowsFan from FanFooty)

 

[Baker_for_PM]

Is it just me or is it alot harder to allocate MPP's this year then last. I have the two crows in my mids but may make me miss some of the unique cash cows that pop up.

 

[Test Tickle]

does anyone know how to add people like Sheedy and Crawford to a personal league? i've got a league with some mates and instead of it getting filled with randoms would prefer to get some celebs in there...

edit - just found how to add Crawford. is there any other celebs we can add?

so how do you add Crawford??

 

[Big Fozza]

so how do you add Crawford??

on the leagues screen view there is a tab on the right of where your leagues are listed and it says ADD CRAWFORD or something like that

 

[dontaskfev]

http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/introduction

has the point scoring formula been changed? Same as 2010??

 

[Arthur Mongrel]

ANyone looking for a league to join - 470020

 

[freddy mercury]

Hey fellas. Just after an answer. It's played on my mind all day.

I am thinking of down grading Stevie J for ROK. And upgrading Berger for Mumford. The other three ruckmen I have are Stephensen, Giles and Hall.

 

[Caek]

Hey fellas. Just after an answer. It's played on my mind all day.

I am thinking of down grading Stevie J for ROK. And upgrading Berger for Mumford. The other three ruckmen I have are Stephensen, Giles and Hall.

I would recommend downgrading Stevie J as I don't think he is worth forking out the cash for. If I recall correctly I think ROK is injured currently.. Not sure how bad tho. Other targets could be Pav, Cloke, Zaha, Lewis.

Another ruckman to consider is Jarrad Redden from Port - Not sure if Hall will get games in front of Smith and Fraser.

 

[Shibada123]

Has the scoring changed?

Al Paton from HS superfooty tweeted "Despite reports to the contrary #supercoach scoring is unchanged from 2011" https://twitter.com/#!/al_superfooty

 

[RIOLINWITPUNCHS]

Anyone know if you can name a league you created if you forgot to do it at start up?

At the moment it's just "public league" and I was hoping to change it.

 

[IDIG]

Anyone know if you can name a league you created if you forgot to do it at start up?

At the moment it's just "public league" and I was hoping to change it.

I'm sure you could edit the league name if you created it. Email them if u can't find it I'm sure they'll oblige.

Out of curiosity who has actually taken the byes into real consideration? I know last year prompts had every trade planned before round 1 working around each bye. This year word is 3 gtd donuts no matter what but in reality most will cop 2 or 3 times that. Could be the difference between 1st n 10th