Rumour GFC 2017 Player Trading, Drafting, FA, Rumours, and Wish lists.

Who would you rather at the Cats?


  • Total voters
    253
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

He's no dud. He is someone who needs to be managed and pushed, a bit like Motlop, except that he is more versatile. We've seen glimpses of this, but not consistently enough. Let's not forget Melbourne was a basket case for Watts first 5 or 6 seasons. Wherever he goes will be his last chance, and he will be acutely aware of that.
He'll excel at his next club I think.

This will be the motivation he needs.
 
He's no dud. He is someone who needs to be managed and pushed, a bit like Motlop, except that he is more versatile. We've seen glimpses of this, but not consistently enough. Let's not forget Melbourne was a basket case for Watts first 5 or 6 seasons. Wherever he goes will be his last chance, and he will be acutely aware of that.
He's a Mitch Brown/Shane Kersten type who is playing to the limit of his potential,give him a wide berth,perfect hand bag material.
 
Thats more than he is worth
A) You often need to pay more than a player is worth to get them, especially if contracted and/or another club also wants them
B) He's an AA mid sized forward. Do not grow on trees.
C) We need more quality forward firepower.

600k and 2018 R1/ 2017 Pick 20. Get it done cats.
 
A) You often need to pay more than a player is worth to get them, especially if contracted and/or another club also wants them
B) He's an AA mid sized forward. Do not grow on trees.
C) We need more quality forward firepower.

600k and 2018 R1/ 2017 Pick 20. Get it done cats.

This. Do it.
 
A) You often need to pay more than a player is worth to get them, especially if contracted and/or another club also wants them
B) He's an AA mid sized forward. Do not grow on trees.
C) We need more quality forward firepower.

600k and 2018 R1/ 2017 Pick 20. Get it done cats.
I'd start a 4/2.4m and the 2018 first.

There is still more to be played out here.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

He's a Mitch Brown/Shane Kersten type who is playing to the limit of his potential,give him a wide berth,perfect hand bag material.
Not sure how the football world and his coach at school, Robert Shaw, got it so wrong with Watts. I'd say he has inconsistently played to his full potential because he was allowed to get away with that. Anyway, Geelong is not in the frame for Watts so we can all relax.
 
More than happy to offer Stringer $600k - essentially Motlop out, Stringer in - as well as pick 20 and steak knives to the Bulldogs.

Thats more than he is worth

I am glad that the people doing the wheeling and dealing for the Cats are not Bigfooty members.
 
A) You often need to pay more than a player is worth to get them, especially if contracted and/or another club also wants them
B) He's an AA mid sized forward. Do not grow on trees.
C) We need more quality forward firepower.

600k and 2018 R1/ 2017 Pick 20. Get it done cats.

Obviously we not willing to give up 2018 round 1, and probably rightly so. Just wish we could find someone to take 20 plus Stanley and gives us back a 10-15 pick..
 
A) You often need to pay more than a player is worth to get them, especially if contracted and/or another club also wants them
B) He's an AA mid sized forward. Do not grow on trees.
C) We need more quality forward firepower.

600k and 2018 R1/ 2017 Pick 20. Get it done cats.

and all that is being offered for him by Ess may be P28 ... one has to beat their offer , but not over pay by that much
 
Not sure how the football world and his coach at school, Robert Shaw, got it so wrong with Watts. I'd say he has inconsistently played to his full potential because he was allowed to get away with that. Anyway, Geelong is not in the frame for Watts so we can all relax.
I really want him.

The salivating over a 9.9 possession, 0.9 goal forward with a dodgy knee is hilarious.

Watts is way better than Smith, much bigger and more skilled.

Unlike Smith, Watts has also proven he has the tank to play midfield.
 
and all that is being offered for him by Ess may be P28 ... one has to beat their offer , but not over pay by that much
For all that bluster you seriously think if the Dogs refuse to cave Dodo won't stump up 11 to get him. Ok then.
Who cares about monetary value? We happily paid 600k to Motlop pre-CBA deal and he looks like he's off.

Paying Stringer that much makes more sense than doing it for SM.
Stringer is there for the taking if we want him enough. No use letting him pass if we can get him then just taking a pick in the draft.

We're looking at the now, just because some of the weaklings on here have waved the white flag and given up so soon doesn't mean the club has.
Worrying about 600k and using one of p20 or 2018 R1 is small fry stuff.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top