Giansiracusa to collingwood???

magpies42

Premiership Player
Joined
Jun 10, 2005
Posts
3,234
Likes
895
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
collingwood
#26
jabso said:
If you think we are going to get any of those players mentioned let alone a few without giving up something VALUABLE you are kidding.
Well rumour has it that Bartel, salopak, polak and kerr maybe leaving there clubs for differing reasons, so i dont see why we couldnt get them for less then what they are worth!
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Joined
Jul 5, 2005
Posts
2,746
Likes
109
Location
Doglands
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Other Teams
Melbourne Victory
#27
magpies42 said:
Well rumour has it that Bartel, salopak, polak and kerr maybe leaving there clubs for differing reasons, so i dont see why we couldnt get them for less then what they are worth!
Polak, Bartel and Kerr ANY club will have to pay over the odds to get 'em. Salopek might be a player a team could get cheapish. I.e - Trading a player that is around the same level as him, or slightly less.

Something to that affect.
 

bogan4life

Premiership Player
Suspended
Joined
Apr 11, 2005
Posts
3,584
Likes
3
Location
Whitten Oval
Other Teams
Footscray
#28
Gia will not be leaving the dogs, his mum would kill him :D

Lets have a little play at this and tell you what we would want for our star kid who just resigned, Give us pick 5 and Cole.

You can trade for Birss for a 2nd round pick, for Sam Power for Cole or a 2nd round pick (please not is his brother wants to be traded his trade value goes way up) or Brad Murphy and our 2nd pick for your 2nd pick.
 

hotpie

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
May 1, 2002
Posts
16,837
Likes
21
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Collingwood
#30
bogan4life said:
Lets have a little play at this and tell you what we would want for our star kid who just resigned, Give us pick 5 and Cole.

You can trade for Birss for a 2nd round pick, for Sam Power for Cole or a 2nd round pick (please not is his brother wants to be traded his trade value goes way up) or Brad Murphy and our 2nd pick for your 2nd pick.
I think what you've put up is very fair and reasonable. Probably a little over the odds on Gia, probably a straight swap for pick 5but not 5 + Cole. Either way I'd rather we kept pick 5 for the draft unless we got a genuine gun, and Gia is not quite in that category.

Similarly, Birss or Power for pick 21 could be considered (I think 37 is probably fairer though for a VFL player) although a straight swap for a Cole, Lonie, O'Bree, etc would be better. Don't know much about Brad Murphy, so will you give us Robert Murphy instead??? :)
 

Rookie

Club Legend
Joined
May 12, 2004
Posts
2,830
Likes
1,288
Location
Globetrotting
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
#31
hotpie said:
I think what you've put up is very fair and reasonable. Probably a little over the odds on Gia, probably a straight swap for pick 5but not 5 + Cole. Either way I'd rather we kept pick 5 for the draft unless we got a genuine gun, and Gia is not quite in that category.

Similarly, Birss or Power for pick 21 could be considered (I think 37 is probably fairer though for a VFL player) although a straight swap for a Cole, Lonie, O'Bree, etc would be better. Don't know much about Brad Murphy, so will you give us Robert Murphy instead??? :)

I think moving up 6 spots in the draft for Brad Murphy is VERY generous! Could we swap our third rounders as well? :) I'd take that.

Birss for 21 is a win for you and Birssy, Power could probably pull a second rounder but heck, you'd want Birss out of the two. Power for Cole sounds very fair IMO, maybe slanted our way?
 

bogan4life

Premiership Player
Suspended
Joined
Apr 11, 2005
Posts
3,584
Likes
3
Location
Whitten Oval
Other Teams
Footscray
#32
hotpie said:
I think what you've put up is very fair and reasonable. Probably a little over the odds on Gia, probably a straight swap for pick 5but not 5 + Cole. Either way I'd rather we kept pick 5 for the draft unless we got a genuine gun, and Gia is not quite in that category.

Similarly, Birss or Power for pick 21 could be considered (I think 37 is probably fairer though for a VFL player) although a straight swap for a Cole, Lonie, O'Bree, etc would be better. Don't know much about Brad Murphy, so will you give us Robert Murphy instead??? :)
I can see Birss being traded for a pick 20,21,22 or 23 he is a hard in and under players and would be great at any other side with out the likes of Cooney Cross Gia West Smith Johnson Gilbee etc...

You would have to pay well over market value for Gia becasue he is under contract.

Brad Murhpy would suit collingwood coming in as a HFF who can play mid field, got 23 or touchs in his first game and is another who struggles to get a game due to our midfield.

Sam Power has all the skills, the blood line and also would be a must if you are after Luke Power.
 

acker

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
May 5, 2005
Posts
9,259
Likes
392
Location
Riverina
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Other Teams
Bulldogs
#33
tarrant said:
What do you think about Daniel Giansiracusa possibly coming to collingwood??

i think he would b very handy almost like another caracella.
You've got nothing usefull to trade him for ho-hum. Unless of course you can get us Jason Akermanis :D
 

Swifty_446

Premiership Player
Suspended
Joined
Jan 28, 2005
Posts
3,078
Likes
1
Location
Northcote
Other Teams
Bulldogs, Arsenal, SAS
#34
Hawthorn board:

Thought you guys would like to have a laugh

Trade J.Hay and Nick Ries and C.Brown to Fremantle for Pick 10 (A. Swallow)
Trade J.Smith R.Vanderberg M.Osbourne and L.Brennan to Carlton for Pick 9 (M.Clark)
Trade M.Little and J.Thurgood R.Campbell and T.Boyle to Collingwood for Pick 5 (J.Kennedy)

Delist
D.Sccot
N.Lonie
B.Kane
B.Nixon

Retire
A.Lekkas
P.Everit
B.Dixon

Hawks in 2005 Draft
3# S.Hurn
5#J.Kennedy
6#P.Ryder
9#M.Clark
10#A.Swallow
22#T.Varcoe
F.S - T.Tuck
 

Nardz

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 17, 2003
Posts
7,030
Likes
140
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
NUFC
#35
Swifty_446 said:
Hawthorn board:

Thought you guys would like to have a laugh

Trade J.Hay and Nick Ries and C.Brown to Fremantle for Pick 10 (A. Swallow)
Trade J.Smith R.Vanderberg M.Osbourne and L.Brennan to Carlton for Pick 9 (M.Clark)
Trade M.Little and J.Thurgood R.Campbell and T.Boyle to Collingwood for Pick 5 (J.Kennedy)

Delist
D.Sccot
N.Lonie
B.Kane
B.Nixon

Retire
A.Lekkas
P.Everit
B.Dixon

Hawks in 2005 Draft
3# S.Hurn
5#J.Kennedy
6#P.Ryder
9#M.Clark
10#A.Swallow
22#T.Varcoe
F.S - T.Tuck
Campbel and Thurgood i'd take, but they're absolutely dreaming if they think we're gonna give up pick 5 for those two and another two duds. Throwing those two duds in reduces the value of the trade if anything .

Campbell and Thurgood for a 3rd rounder
 

acker

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
May 5, 2005
Posts
9,259
Likes
392
Location
Riverina
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Other Teams
Bulldogs
#36
Nardz said:
Campbel and Thurgood i'd take, but they're absolutely dreaming if they think we're gonna give up pick 5 for those two and another two duds. Throwing those two duds in reduces the value of the trade if anything .

Campbell and Thurgood for a 3rd rounder
You severely over-estimate the pies bargining power eddy; giansiracusa obviously pies pipe dream on lsd.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Murray

Brownlow Medallist
Suspended
Joined
Sep 20, 2002
Posts
18,424
Likes
17
Location
Frankston
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Collingwood
#37
acker said:
You severely over-estimate the pies bargining power eddy; giansiracusa obviously pies pipe dream on lsd.
I think its time we gave you a Collingwood membership number.
 

Nardz

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 17, 2003
Posts
7,030
Likes
140
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
NUFC
#38
acker said:
You severely over-estimate the pies bargining power eddy; giansiracusa obviously pies pipe dream on lsd.
you seriously overestimate collingwoods interest in any of those hawthorn players mentioned.

Giansiracusa had nothing to do with my post, why bring him up??

i notice you've been spending a little bit of time in here of late?
 

Dazman

Club Legend
Joined
Aug 4, 2005
Posts
1,863
Likes
6
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Liverpool, Pies VFL
#39
hotpie said:
Either way I'd rather we kept pick 5 for the draft unless we got a genuine gun, and Gia is not quite in that category.
Totally agree. I would be inclined to pick up some young talent with pick 2 and 5, unless someone really good seeked a trade, ie. Bartel and L. Power.
 

Jimbeam

Club Legend
Suspended
Joined
Sep 2, 2005
Posts
1,104
Likes
0
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
pies
#40
if spida is not wanted at the hawks i'll take him... AA this year again, wtf are they thinking down there..
 
Top Bottom