Analysis Giants Coaching. Your thoughts.

Isaac Cumming No 1

Cancelled
Mar 28, 2018
10,506
8,433
AFL Club
GWS
Richardson is a desperate man coaching for his life. He may not be the boss of all St Kilda fans in a few weeks time.

Coaches venture to the bench as a change up or shock tactic. Tell me a coach that starts from the sideline every week other than Cameron.

You’re basically proving beyond any doubt that you don’t watch the game and are unfamiliar with traditional convention.

I think you need to free yourself of the need to prove me wrong and just debate issues on their merit. You come across as just wanting to troll arguments for the sake of it.

I was really us ignoring each other, we had a good thing going and you’ve gone and wrecked it :-(
So we've somehow gone from Richardson doesn't coach from the bench, to he does but his life is threatened if he doesn't? Breathtaking hypocracy.

Are you worried your hypocracy will be challenged constantly? Or you wont be able to ignorantly "mock" with impunity.

Your understanding of the word "troll" is as clear as your understanding of the word "benchmark", clearly.
 

Andre the Giant

Norm Smith Medallist
Feb 20, 2012
5,403
6,479
AFL Club
GWS
So we've somehow gone from Richardson doesn't coach from the bench, to he does but his life is threatened if he doesn't? Breathtaking hypocracy.

Are you worried your hypocracy will be challenged constantly? Or you wont be able to ignorantly "mock" with impunity.

Your understanding of the word "troll" is as clear as your understanding of the word "benchmark", clearly.
If you are in such a mood to debate with me let’s take this private, the MODS have repeatedly asked us to refrain from conversing as they nor anybody else is interested in petty squabbling but you just can’t help yourself.

I’m placing you back in Coventry! Goodnight :)
 

Isaac Cumming No 1

Cancelled
Mar 28, 2018
10,506
8,433
AFL Club
GWS
If you are in such a mood to debate with me let’s take this private, the MODS have repeatedly asked us to refrain from conversing as they nor anybody else is interested in petty squabbling but you just can’t help yourself.

I’m placing you back in Coventry! Goodnight :)
Do as you wish.
It's both condescending and arrogant to attempt to tell me what to do though.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Determinant

Moderator
Jan 9, 2012
7,122
6,462
AFL Club
GWS
Other Teams
St Kilda, Bucks, Who Dats
The issue I have, and to be frank, the bigfooty rules have, with "discussions" like the last one is they turn discussion into shitfight.
Nobody wins a shitfight and it turns people away from the thread who may want to engage in the thread topic without becoming personal, or having to step through other people's personal detritus.
It is easy enough to argue a point without becoming abusive, and vastly more productive, there is nothing wrong with simply agreeing to disagree.

I am going to leave posts where they are for now as an example of how not to foster an involving forum environment.

 

Isaac Cumming No 1

Cancelled
Mar 28, 2018
10,506
8,433
AFL Club
GWS
The issue I have, and to be frank, the bigfooty rules have, with "discussions" like the last one is they turn discussion into shitfight.
Nobody wins a shitfight and it turns people away from the thread who may want to engage in the thread topic without becoming personal, or having to step through other people's personal detritus.
It is easy enough to argue a point without becoming abusive, and vastly more productive, there is nothing wrong with simply agreeing to disagree.

I am going to leave posts where they are for now as an example of how not to foster an involving forum environment.

My post yesterday morning was actually referring to the press article suggesting Leon was dismissed from the coaching box. I thought that was pretty clear from what I said.

I did choose to confront some statements that made no sense. I dont regret that and facing constant defection chose to stay on message. I dont regret that, in my my view it needed to be said.

I do get that kind of conflict can be intimidating to other posters. Unfortunately life isn't all beer and skittles. If you research why people read and are reluctant to post in forums, it's more about fear of being mocked and irrationally attacked than witnessing conflict I think. I dont get what bigfooty rule is breached by attempting rational discussion on a topic in any case.
 

General Giant

Hall of Famer
Apr 12, 2012
33,598
25,890
AFL Club
GWS
If you research why people read and are reluctant to post in forums, it's more about fear of being mocked and irrationally attacked than witnessing conflict I think. I dont get what bigfooty rule is breached by attempting rational discussion on a topic in any case.
Also

How anyone could conclude otherwise is beyond me. Unless you were really ignorant and determined to express hate.


Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk
 

Determinant

Moderator
Jan 9, 2012
7,122
6,462
AFL Club
GWS
Other Teams
St Kilda, Bucks, Who Dats
My post yesterday morning was actually referring to the press article suggesting Leon was dismissed from the coaching box. I thought that was pretty clear from what I said.

I did choose to confront some statements that made no sense. I dont regret that and facing constant defection chose to stay on message. I dont regret that, in my my view it needed to be said.

I do get that kind of conflict can be intimidating to other posters. Unfortunately life isn't all beer and skittles. If you research why people read and are reluctant to post in forums, it's more about fear of being mocked and irrationally attacked than witnessing conflict I think. I dont get what bigfooty rule is breached by attempting rational discussion on a topic in any case.
[URL="https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/board-rules-please-read-before-posting.932183/"]BOARD RULES - please read before posting[/URL]

GWS GIANTS board rules
  • New posters are always welcome and are to be treated as such.
  • No personal abuse. Attack the ball, not the man.
  • No evasion of the swear filter. If we as contributors to the board see a bunch of asterisks in your post, we all know the point you’re trying to get across!
  • Exaggerated criticism of the players or the club will not be tolerated.
  • Everyone is entitled to their opinion, and each opinion should be respected. If you disagree with someone’s opinion, provide a reasonable reply explaining why you disagree rather than using dismissal or abuse.
  • Rumours should be clearly labelled as rumours; we have a thread prefix for that. Rumours posted without a source will be taken with a grain of salt
  • If you find a post to be offensive, out of line or in breach of the forum or board rules, please click ‘Report Post’. We as moderators do spend a lot of time on the board however we might not catch everything.
 

Isaac Cumming No 1

Cancelled
Mar 28, 2018
10,506
8,433
AFL Club
GWS
BOARD RULES - please read before posting

GWS GIANTS board rules
  • New posters are always welcome and are to be treated as such.
  • No personal abuse. Attack the ball, not the man.
  • No evasion of the swear filter. If we as contributors to the board see a bunch of asterisks in your post, we all know the point you’re trying to get across!
  • Exaggerated criticism of the players or the club will not be tolerated.
  • Everyone is entitled to their opinion, and each opinion should be respected. If you disagree with someone’s opinion, provide a reasonable reply explaining why you disagree rather than using dismissal or abuse.
  • Rumours should be clearly labelled as rumours; we have a thread prefix for that. Rumours posted without a source will be taken with a grain of salt
  • If you find a post to be offensive, out of line or in breach of the forum or board rules, please click ‘Report Post’. We as moderators do spend a lot of time on the board however we might not catch everything.
I actually believe I did attemot stick to the argument. My issue is never people people having a different opinion. It's mocking others while playing the victim. I do get it's subjective and you can moderate the board as you wish, but it remains my view.
 

combaning

Team Captain
Jun 25, 2009
467
283
AFL Club
GWS
I still believe our forward structure and forward entries require work next year.

It almost make us unwatchable with our predictability. Long bombs are predictable and do not play to our strengths as we have poor F50 pressure (although improving with Langdon and Daniels).

Whether this is new personnel on and/or off the field is up to the club. I love the ball in the hands of Lids and Whitfield entering F50.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Smartest Brain

Premiership Player
Jun 11, 2017
3,104
1,825
AFL Club
GWS
With some player exits from the club I think the coaches are going to be under more pressure next year. It also seems we are on a downward curve. 2016 was better than 2017 which was better than 2018.
 

Danny88

Club Legend
Mar 21, 2014
2,265
1,650
AFL Club
GWS
I think if any area needs work it’s the defensive setup. We are good stoppers but too often if we can’t run it out end up kicking long and creating repeat entries for the oppo
 

captainMyCaptain

Norm Smith Medallist
Apr 30, 2011
7,111
5,108
AFL Club
GWS
While I support Cameron can't help but think that in the world of what ifs, its worth remembering when the club was looking at a replacement for Sheedy. Gubby decided to go with Cameron rather then Adam Simpson as he felt Simpson wasn't ready yet but if nothing else the decision made us miss out on a coach that has shown in his time at the Eagles to be a coach with a very high footy IQ.
 

fridgeman

Club Legend
Jan 26, 2014
2,282
1,666
AFL Club
GWS
While I support Cameron can't help but think that in the world of what ifs, its worth remembering when the club was looking at a replacement for Sheedy. Gubby decided to go with Cameron rather then Adam Simpson as he felt Simpson wasn't ready yet but if nothing else the decision made us miss out on a coach that has shown in his time at the Eagles to be a coach with a very high footy IQ.
I think Sam Mitchell was a massive influence with the Eagles winning the flag although Simpson as well was a driving force I just feel without Mitchell the Eagles don't get to the GF and I think it is about getting the most out of players and it is what they have done both at the Eagles and Pies
I look at the Tigers last year and the role players that had career best years, Houli/Grigg/Grimes and others
I think that is what the key is for the Giants next year having guys like Tomlinson/Corr/MDB have career best years that will go along way to the giants winning the flag and maybe Nicks is the missing link but it is about how to get the players to realise the potential they have
 

Isaac Cumming No 1

Cancelled
Mar 28, 2018
10,506
8,433
AFL Club
GWS
While I support Cameron can't help but think that in the world of what ifs, its worth remembering when the club was looking at a replacement for Sheedy. Gubby decided to go with Cameron rather then Adam Simpson as he felt Simpson wasn't ready yet but if nothing else the decision made us miss out on a coach that has shown in his time at the Eagles to be a coach with a very high footy IQ.
Mmmm
The proof of the pudding, flag etc.....

Last year Simpson was largely seen as limited by their supporters. He did have the the belief to go against the trend with their gameplan, and lead the next trend instead. You have to admire that.
 
Last edited:

Danny88

Club Legend
Mar 21, 2014
2,265
1,650
AFL Club
GWS
I think Sam Mitchell was a massive influence with the Eagles winning the flag although Simpson as well was a driving force I just feel without Mitchell the Eagles don't get to the GF and I think it is about getting the most out of players and it is what they have done both at the Eagles and Pies
I look at the Tigers last year and the role players that had career best years, Houli/Grigg/Grimes and others
I think that is what the key is for the Giants next year having guys like Tomlinson/Corr/MDB have career best years that will go along way to the giants winning the flag and maybe Nicks is the missing link but it is about how to get the players to realise the potential they have
I agree with this. It’s not as simple as Simpson would have fixed us- the assistants are massive. Mitchell’s role can’t be overstated
 

captainMyCaptain

Norm Smith Medallist
Apr 30, 2011
7,111
5,108
AFL Club
GWS
I think Sam Mitchell was a massive influence with the Eagles winning the flag although Simpson as well was a driving force I just feel without Mitchell the Eagles don't get to the GF and I think it is about getting the most out of players and it is what they have done both at the Eagles and Pies
I look at the Tigers last year and the role players that had career best years, Houli/Grigg/Grimes and others
I think that is what the key is for the Giants next year having guys like Tomlinson/Corr/MDB have career best years that will go along way to the giants winning the flag and maybe Nicks is the missing link but it is about how to get the players to realise the potential they have
No doubt Mitchell added a bit but I just feel you shouldn't undersell Simpson, and even when he first joined the eagles he showed his footy IQ as when
the eagles lost a number of key backs to long term injury he brought in the web which was a key to getting them to a grand final in '15 after missing the finals the previous year.
 

kulak

Premiership Player
May 16, 2006
3,216
4,175
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
GWS
Nick Poulos, that’s promising

He was at the Crows in the same role for a few years up to about 2016.

Quite well regarded, and I think we were well prepared and didn’t have too many injuries

Lots of injuries in the last two years since Poulos left
 

Determinant

Moderator
Jan 9, 2012
7,122
6,462
AFL Club
GWS
Other Teams
St Kilda, Bucks, Who Dats
Nick Poulos, that’s promising

He was at the Crows in the same role for a few years up to about 2016.

Quite well regarded, and I think we were well prepared and didn’t have too many injuries

Lots of injuries in the last two years since Poulos left
Good info, it's a key area regarding improvement and am pleased the club have moved on it
 

General Giant

Hall of Famer
Apr 12, 2012
33,598
25,890
AFL Club
GWS

Top Bottom