Gibbs for Judd??

[Hu$$ey]

LOL @ Gibbs for Judd..
What a rip-off

It'd be more like Fevola, Walker, #1 2006 Pick = Judd

That'd be more fair, carlton you have got to be kiddin yourselves.

This might get sidetracked in to another debate but FWIW I'd be reluctant to do Fevola for Judd straight swap.

Fevola is awesome, so is Judd, it might work out but I won't be actively seeking it.

 

[sydney eagle]

Perhaps the other question is "Would West Coast trade Judd for Gibbs ?" I think the answer to that is a resounding "No" !

 

[wires on fire.]

judd>carlton's whole list combined
judd>every player in this years draft combined
judd>jesus
judd>alla
judd>budda
judd>god
judd>me

and lastly....

judd>gibbs

basically, judd>the other 6 billion people on the planet.

 

[lebron]

Can the people who voted 'No' be removed from the board? They clearly don't want what's best for the Carlton Football Club

 

[smooking39]

You have to say judd. Gibbs will be a very good player and i cant wait to get him at the club BUT
Chris judd is a champion there is no other player in the comp that is anywhere near as good as him except perhaps Jonathon Brown.
Judd= champion

 

[Furn]

That's why Wayne Hughes said that Gibbs has done more at his age than any player he has seen since Buckley and Wanganeen, and if you can't work it out, that includes the Hodge/Ball/Judd draft.

This isn't in any way a knock on Judd but if you were comparing relative achievements of the players at similar ages then you would have Gibbs in front.

Having said that however, I would do it the trade in a heartbeat, heck I'd package pick 17 with it too to get Judd, that's how good he is.

P.S: Thanks Nostradamus for letting us know he won't be as good as any of Judd/Ball/Hodge, now we can concentrate on picking someone else with our first pick who has a better chance

Hansen is best player in this draft my friend but carlton dont have the balls to pick him for some reason

Juz be ready to answer all those how does it feel to have overlooked hansen threads

 

[Dramoth]

I am putting my money on Gibbs being a better player for the blues than Judd would be for us...

He wants to be like Cousins... and we all know that Cousins almost kills himself every match. This is the sort of player we want for the blues... someone who doesnt give 110% for the club, but goes balls to the wall for 200%

Judd might be a match breaker, but Gibbs will be our engine room for years to come...

 

[parrot]

Gibbs thanks.

 

[geelong_crazy26]

gibbs definately will be a top player, but their is no way iff the trade of number 1 pick for the already made legend chris judd came along that the offer would be turned down. i highly doubt gibbs will be better then chris judd.

 

[geelong_crazy26]

i reckon any other player and you would say no, but chris judd is in a league of his own.