Gibbs or Selwood?

[catman 71]

Hearing the radio today, I heard some Carlton fans potting Bryce Gibbs. It makes me wonder if there is someone else Carlton fans wish that they picked as No.1 pick instead. With Geelong and Carlton playing on Friday night, here is a question for you:-

Who would you prefer to have :- Bryce Gibbs (picked 1 in the 2007 draft), or Joel Selwood (picked 7 in the 2007 Draft)? Why?

 

[cookie monster]

Obvious troll is obvious

 

[catman 71]

Obvious troll is obvious

---------------------------------------------------------------------

How is it trolling?

 

[Mister Carlton]

Hearing the radio today, I heard some Carlton fans potting Bryce Gibbs. It makes me wonder if there is someone else Carlton fans wish that they picked as No.1 pick instead. With Geelong and Carlton playing on Friday night, here is a question for you:-

Who would you prefer to have :- Bryce Gibbs (picked 1 in the 2007 draft), or Joel Selwood (picked 7 in the 2007 Draft)? Why?

[YOUTUBE]RUFT35S7Jb4[/YOUTUBE]

Goodbye.

 

[dropdead1]

Hearing the radio today, I heard some Carlton fans potting Bryce Gibbs. It makes me wonder if there is someone else Carlton fans wish that they picked as No.1 pick instead. With Geelong and Carlton playing on Friday night, here is a question for you:-

Who would you prefer to have :- Bryce Gibbs (picked 1 in the 2007 draft), or Joel Selwood (picked 7 in the 2007 Draft)? Why?

Cotchin is clearly the best mid to come out of the 2007 draft.

 

[jj1978]

I was thinking this the other day. If I was given the option of making 1 change from our drafts the last 10 years it wouldn't be

1. Murphy for Thomas/Pendlebury
2. Kennedy for Thomas/Pendlebury
3. Kreuzer for Cotchin
4. Yarran for Rich

etc etc

I would in a heartbeat change Gibbs for Selwood. Hindsight is a beautiful thing and if we had Selwood we would of had another psycho like Mitch Robinson (with A grade skills) who we are desperately in need of, plus a player that oozes leadership, which we currently are devoid of.

 

[dropdead1]

I was thinking this the other day. If I was given the option of making 1 change from our drafts the last 10 years it wouldn't be

1. Murphy for Thomas/Pendlebury
2. Kennedy for Thomas/Pendlebury
3. Kreuzer for Cotchin
4. Yarran for Rich

etc etc

I would in a heartbeat change Gibbs for Selwood. Hindsight is a beautiful thing and if we had Selwood we would of had another psycho like Mitch Robinson (with A grade skills) who we are desperately in need of, plus a player that oozes leadership, which we currently are devoid of.

Some things are better left unsaid.

 

[I bleed Blue]

How is it trolling? Clearly you know that alot of Carlton fans are unhappy with Gibbs at the moment and you come here to start this thread.

 

[Silvagnis]

Hearing the radio today, I heard some Carlton fans potting Bryce Gibbs. It makes me wonder if there is someone else Carlton fans wish that they picked as No.1 pick instead. With Geelong and Carlton playing on Friday night, here is a question for you:-

Who would you prefer to have :- Bryce Gibbs (picked 1 in the 2007 draft), or Joel Selwood (picked 7 in the 2007 Draft)? Why?

Another King of hindsight. Odds on Geelong didn't want Selwood if they had an earlier pick. Medical reports weren't good. Noticed a commentator said that Selwood was icing his knee/s before the game against GWS.

I'll take your Father-Son picks because apparently getting your hands on the likes of Hawkins, Scarlett, Ablett and Cloke doesn't help you win flags.

 

[Aphrodite]

This won't end well.

Locked