Would be disappointed to give up 2 first rounders. Absolutely want to club to trade aggressively, but also smartly. Gibbs makes us better, but not "missing puzzle piece" better, and losing the second first round pick makes getting the other things we need harder, regardless of any later picks coming back the other way.
Yes, in a dream world, we win the flag and they finish bottom and we from from 18 to 19 but it would also be mighty tempting to the footy gods to deliver us our first top 5 pick.