I'm not convinced on Gibbs either and won't be desperately unhappy if it doesn't work out. Does he actually want to play for us or does he just want to come home with a decent pay packet?
And isn't this the guy who only a year or two ago was scathing about Adelaide and said he'd never play here?

Not convinced. In fact focusing on someone who for his own reasons says he 'wants to come home' could be a distraction from other players we should seriously consider.