Ginbey/Lalor incident

[Red Black and Blue]

Lol, this MRO office is special.

Practice match, Ginbey shoves Lalor into a marking contest at top speed without ever looking like contesting the ball himself. Lalor gets a broken jaw and concussion.

MRO says no case to answer.

Wind forward to rd 22, same season. Rules haven't changed. Dylan Shiel does the exact same thing though nobody is hurt, although his team-mate was placed in a pretty precarious position by the incident, fortunately no significant injury.

MRO says off to the Tribunal you go Dylan Shiel.

Now talk us through the Ginbey one again Christian & whoever the stupid campaigner is who is in charge of that stupid campaigner.

Wtf is going on with these idiots? Same people judging it, same rules, almost identical action, certainly in every material detail . The one with the much worse outcome in terms of injury gets no case to answer. The one that caused no injury gets referred directly to the Tribunal. Funking clown show cubed.

It’s not really an identical incident, Shiel really had no idea Lual was coming into the contest. Lual hadn’t even left the ground by the time Shiel had finished pushing him. Straight up just a push in the back.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Rules did change. Ginbey would be suspended if he did the same thing this weekend.

No they didn't. Any rule that is used to suspend Shiel was already in place at the start of the season.

 

[MisterMarcus]

The rules absolutely did change. I know you're annoyed because your player got injured, but you lot spent the next month crying so they changed the rules.

This has gone to the tribunal because the action injured his own teammate so doesnt fit the guidelines, despite the action itself now being a reportable offense

Yeah Richmond fans got exactly what they wanted in changing the rules to help stamp “attempted murder” out of the game.

Not sure why they’re still sooking it up.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

The rules absolutely did change. I know you're annoyed because your player got injured, but you lot spent the next month crying so they changed the rules.

This has gone to the tribunal because the action injured his own teammate so doesnt fit the guidelines, despite the action itself now being a reportable offense

The action was always a reportable offence. Laura Kane sending a memo to clubs half way through the season to remind them of this did not change the rules.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Yeah Richmond fans got exactly what they wanted in changing the rules to help stamp “attempted murder” out of the game.

Not sure why they’re still sooking it up.

All we want is a fair set of rules applied equally to every club. Same as any footy supporter should want.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

It’s not really an identical incident, Shiel really had no idea Lual was coming into the contest. Lual hadn’t even left the ground by the time Shiel had finished pushing him. Straight up just a push in the back.

You are only supporting my point. The incident with less guilt attached and a better outcome in terms of injury gets treated as if it is worse than the incident with the worse action and much worse injury outcome - by the exact same people judging the incident under the exact same rules.

 

[Tugga27]

All we want is a fair set of rules applied equally to every club. Same as any footy supporter should want.

It happened in the pre-season.
Move on FFS.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

It happened in the pre-season.
Move on FFS.

If we met, and I did something to break your jaw, and got away with it, would you be happy to move on?

 

[Tugga27]

If we met, and I did something to break your jaw, and got away with it, would you be happy to move on?

Don't be so dramatic princess.

He didn't even miss a game.

 

[Freddy Swift]

Don't be so dramatic princess.

He didn't even miss a game.

Would you be so blasé about it if the roles were reversed and your player was injured? I think not.

 

[Tugga27]

Would you be so blasé about it if the roles were reversed and your player was injured? I think not.

Considering it happened 6 months ago, yes.

 

[Aristotle Pickett the3rd]

Considering it happened 6 months ago, yes.

Ginby is a dog and should have got 4 weeks for that.

 

[Aristotle Pickett the3rd]

Don't be so dramatic princess.

He didn't even miss a game.

He did miss a game

 

[Freddy Swift]

Considering it happened 6 months ago, yes.

Hmmm, and what about at the time?

 

[Tugga27]

He did miss a game

Pre-season game

 

[Tugga27]

Hmmm, and what about at the time?

Can't remember.

I've moved on.
So should you.

 

[Tugga27]

Ginby is a dog and should have got 4 weeks for that.

Noah Belter says hi.

 

[Tugga27]

Ginby is a dog and should have got 4 weeks for that.

Is Mansell a dog or unlucky

 

[FreddyTwoShoes]

Ginby is a dog and should have got 4 weeks for that.

Which dog is worse? Ginbey or Stewart?

 

[Aristotle Pickett the3rd]

Which dog is worse? Ginbey or Stewart?

They're both dogs but this thread is about Ginbey concussing and breaking Lalor's jaw

 

[Obeanie1]

Yeah Richmond fans got exactly what they wanted in changing the rules to help stamp “attempted murder” out of the game.

Not sure why they’re still sooking it up.

You answered your own question at the start.

Richmond fans.

 

[FreddyTwoShoes]

They're both dogs but this thread is about Ginbey concussing and breaking Lalor's jaw

No worries. Just checking. Ginbey and Stewart are equally doggish. Got it.

 

[Obeanie1]

They're both dogs but this thread is about Ginbey concussing and breaking Lalor's jaw

Get over it.

This thread is about sooks not understanding the rules or how football is played and coached.

And you are one of the biggest sooks on BF.

 

[Aristotle Pickett the3rd]

Get over it.

This thread is about sooks not understanding the rules or how football is played and coached.

And you are one of the biggest sooks on BF.

They made a reinterpretation of the rule after Ginbey's dog act if you remember correctly.

 

[Freddy Swift]

They're both dogs but this thread is about Ginbey concussing and breaking Lalor's jaw

Don’t call them dogs. That’s an insult to real dogs