OK, I'll try put my view of Charlie in perspective...
When he first started I thought he was crap. Simply, plainly, unfortunately, crap.
He's tall-ish, athletic, and could be a very versatile player
if he could play football.
A lot of people (myself included) thought he may have silenced his doubters in last year's prelim against Brisbane when he kicked 2 very crucial goals. But he hasn't shown that form again once in this whole season. So what's that? 2 years of potential, then 1 very good game, and then crap for another season.
It's not like he has had the run of Henry Playfair, constantly moving between different positions (back, fwd, ruck), and the VFL until this year...Charlie has been given a similar role all the time, and still hasn't come good.
Sorry Charlie, but I think we should trade you for anything we can possibly get.
Maybe, he could come good under another coach, I'm sure Bomber hasn't got his head up his arse, and obviosuly sees something that we supporters don't, but he has failed, IMHO...miserably.
Sorry Charlie, but you are the weakest link. Goodbye!